# FINAL_5_network_nodes

canonical_name [F2d]: Erin Billings
relationship_description [F3]:
  Insufficient context to determine relationship.

  The email excerpts provided do not contain any direct communication between Erin Billings and Jeffrey Epstein, nor do they mention Erin Billings at all. The emails appear to focus on legal and media relations work regarding Turkish cleric Fethullah Gulen, with only brief references to Jeffrey Epstein's email address in header information.

discussion_ids:
  ["IMAGES-011-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_031472.txt_2317", "IMAGES-011-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_031474.txt_5512", "IMAGES-011-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_031478.txt_19997", "IMAGES-011-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_031479.txt_20372", "IMAGES-011-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_031483.txt_25079", "IMAGES-011-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_031484.txt_21773", "IMAGES-011-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_031486.txt_20217", "IMAGES-011-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_031487.txt_20154", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_031472.txt_24560", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_031480.txt_1441"]


canonical_name [F2d]: Forrest Miller
relationship_description [F3]:
  Insufficient context to determine relationship.

  The email excerpts show multiple people named Miller (including "Miller, Micha" and references to "Michael") in correspondence chains that include Jeffrey Epstein, but there are no clear email exchanges directly between Forrest Miller and Epstein that would indicate the nature of their relationship. The emails primarily focus on Turkish cleric Fethullah Gulen-related news stories and contain one reference to a legal case involving Trump and Epstein, but without direct communication between Forrest Miller and Epstein, their specific relationship cannot be determined from these excerpts.

discussion_ids:
  ["IMAGES-010-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_028602.txt_19598", "IMAGES-011-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_031472.txt_2317", "IMAGES-011-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_031474.txt_5512", "IMAGES-011-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_031475.txt_5860", "IMAGES-011-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_031478.txt_19997", "IMAGES-011-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_031479.txt_20372", "IMAGES-011-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_031484.txt_21773", "IMAGES-011-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_032063.txt_17824", "IMAGES-011-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_032272.txt_15913", "IMAGES-011-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_032304.txt_13350", "IMAGES-011-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_032307.txt_14903", "IMAGES-011-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_032331.txt_6916", "IMAGES-011-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_032358.txt_21443", "IMAGES-012-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_032892.txt_5420", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_028589.txt_9064", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_028601.txt_8404", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_031472.txt_24560", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_031480.txt_1441", "TEXT-002-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_032272.txt_21409", "TEXT-002-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_032306.txt_21217", "TEXT-002-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_032358.txt_15867", "TEXT-002-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_032892.txt_21075"]


canonical_name [F2d]: Katelyn Wohlford
relationship_description [F3]:
  Insufficient context to determine relationship.

  The email excerpts provided do not contain any substantive content or interactions between Katelyn Wohlford and Jeffrey Epstein. While there are email headers showing correspondence between Reid Weingarten and Jeffrey Epstein, and other communications about legal matters involving Turkish cleric Fethullah Gulen, there is no actual content or context provided about any relationship between Katelyn Wohlford and Epstein.

discussion_ids:
  ["IMAGES-011-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_031472.txt_2317", "IMAGES-011-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_031474.txt_5512", "IMAGES-011-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_031475.txt_5860", "IMAGES-011-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_031477.txt_3860", "IMAGES-011-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_031478.txt_19997", "IMAGES-011-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_031479.txt_20372", "IMAGES-011-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_031482.txt_24890", "IMAGES-011-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_031483.txt_25079", "IMAGES-011-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_031486.txt_20217", "IMAGES-011-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_031487.txt_20154", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_031472.txt_24560", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_031480.txt_1441"]


canonical_name [F2d]: Kathryn
relationship_description [F3]:
  Insufficient context to determine relationship.

  The email excerpts provided do not contain any mention of Kathryn or any apparent communication between Kathryn and Jeffrey Epstein. The emails appear to be between other parties (Reid Weingarten, Will Bohlen, and Keough) discussing news articles about Turkish cleric Fethullah Gulen and legal matters related to Turkey's coup attempt.

discussion_ids:
  ["IMAGES-011-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_031472.txt_2317", "IMAGES-011-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_031474.txt_5512", "IMAGES-011-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_031475.txt_5860", "IMAGES-011-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_031484.txt_21773", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_031480.txt_1441"]


canonical_name [F2d]: Osman Oz
relationship_description [F3]:
  Insufficient context to determine relationship.

  The email excerpts provided do not contain any substantive content showing interactions between Osman Oz and Jeffrey Epstein. While there are email headers indicating correspondence between Reid Weingarten and Jeffrey Epstein, and the bulk of the emails discuss legal matters involving Turkish cleric Fethullah Gulen, there is no apparent connection to or mention of Osman Oz in the provided content.

discussion_ids:
  ["IMAGES-011-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_031472.txt_2317", "IMAGES-011-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_031474.txt_5512", "IMAGES-011-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_031475.txt_5860", "IMAGES-011-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_031477.txt_3860", "IMAGES-011-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_031478.txt_19997", "IMAGES-011-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_031482.txt_24890", "IMAGES-011-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_031483.txt_25079", "IMAGES-011-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_031484.txt_21773", "IMAGES-011-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_031486.txt_20217", "IMAGES-011-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_031487.txt_20154", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_031472.txt_24560", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_031480.txt_1441"]


canonical_name [F2d]: Remzi Kulen
relationship_description [F3]:
  Insufficient context to determine relationship.

  The email excerpts provided focus entirely on legal and media strategy discussions regarding Turkish cleric Fethullah Gulen and potential extradition proceedings. While there are two email headers showing correspondence between Reid Weingarten and Jeffrey Epstein, the actual content of those communications is not included in the excerpts, making it impossible to determine the nature of their relationship.

discussion_ids:
  ["IMAGES-011-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_031472.txt_2317", "IMAGES-011-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_031473.txt_2606", "IMAGES-011-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_031474.txt_5512", "IMAGES-011-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_031475.txt_5860", "IMAGES-011-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_031478.txt_19997", "IMAGES-011-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_031482.txt_24890", "IMAGES-011-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_031483.txt_25079", "IMAGES-011-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_031484.txt_21773", "IMAGES-011-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_031486.txt_20217", "IMAGES-011-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_031487.txt_20154", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_031472.txt_24560", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_031480.txt_1441"]


canonical_name [F2d]: Will Bohlen
relationship_description [F3]:
  Insufficient context to determine relationship.

  The email excerpts show Will Bohlen communicating with colleagues at what appears to be the Steptoe law firm about media coverage and video distribution related to Turkish cleric Fethullah Gulen, but there is no direct communication between Will Bohlen and Jeffrey Epstein, nor any mention of Epstein in the substantive email content shown.

discussion_ids:
  ["IMAGES-011-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_031472.txt_2317", "IMAGES-011-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_031473.txt_2606", "IMAGES-011-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_031474.txt_5512", "IMAGES-011-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_031475.txt_5860", "IMAGES-011-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_031477.txt_3860", "IMAGES-011-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_031478.txt_19997", "IMAGES-011-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_031479.txt_20372", "IMAGES-011-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_031480.txt_23431", "IMAGES-011-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_031482.txt_24890", "IMAGES-011-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_031484.txt_21773", "IMAGES-011-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_031486.txt_20217", "IMAGES-011-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_031487.txt_20154", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_031472.txt_24560", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_031480.txt_1441"]


canonical_name [F2d]: Y. Alp Aslandogan
relationship_description [F3]:
  Insufficient context to determine relationship.

  The email excerpts discuss legal representation of Turkish cleric Fethullah Gulen by what appears to be Steptoe law firm attorneys regarding extradition matters and media strategy, but Y. Alp Aslandogan is not mentioned in any of the provided email content, nor is there any clear reference to Jeffrey Epstein in these excerpts.

discussion_ids:
  ["IMAGES-011-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_031472.txt_2317", "IMAGES-011-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_031473.txt_2606", "IMAGES-011-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_031474.txt_5512", "IMAGES-011-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_031475.txt_5860", "IMAGES-011-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_031477.txt_3860", "IMAGES-011-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_031478.txt_19997", "IMAGES-011-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_031479.txt_20372", "IMAGES-011-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_031482.txt_24890", "IMAGES-011-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_031483.txt_25079", "IMAGES-011-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_031486.txt_20217", "IMAGES-011-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_031487.txt_20154", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_031472.txt_24560", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_031480.txt_1441"]


canonical_name [F2d]: Michael C. Miller
relationship_description [F3]:
  Based on the email excerpts, Michael C. Miller appears to have served as Jeffrey Epstein's legal representative or attorney. This is evidenced by journalist Joseph Palazzolo reaching out to Miller seeking comment "on behalf of Mr. Epstein" regarding a legal case in the Southern District of New York involving both Trump and Epstein. The professional nature of this relationship is further supported by the presence of court system notifications and privileged communications in the email chain, suggesting Miller was handling legal matters for Epstein.

discussion_ids:
  ["IMAGES-011-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_031477.txt_3860", "IMAGES-011-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_031482.txt_24890", "IMAGES-011-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_032304.txt_13350", "IMAGES-011-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_032306.txt_15724", "IMAGES-011-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_032329.txt_18164", "TEXT-002-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_032063.txt_25136", "TEXT-002-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_032304.txt_20749", "TEXT-002-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_032306.txt_21217", "TEXT-002-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_032329.txt_25581", "TEXT-002-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_032331.txt_1442"]


canonical_name [F2d]: David Grosof
relationship_description [F3]:
  Based on the email excerpts, David Grosof and Jeffrey Epstein appear to have had an intellectual/academic relationship centered around scientific and mathematical discussions. The emails show exchanges about topics like probability, statistics, neuroscience, and biological systems, with Grosof asking detailed questions about research areas and Epstein responding with theoretical musings about mathematical concepts. The tone suggests a collaborative intellectual exchange, with Grosof expressing alignment with Epstein's interests and referencing a previous meeting in Epstein's office.

discussion_ids:
  ["IMAGES-006-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_021759.txt_2058", "IMAGES-008-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_025169.txt_10088", "IMAGES-008-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_025172.txt_13267", "IMAGES-008-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_025176.txt_19076", "IMAGES-008-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_025180.txt_12702", "IMAGES-008-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_025185.txt_7820", "IMAGES-010-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_029085.txt_22417", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_021759.txt_15522", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_025169.txt_3386", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_025172.txt_19464", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_025176.txt_25646", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_025180.txt_6425", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_025185.txt_1609", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_029085.txt_9673"]


canonical_name [F2d]: Francis Crick
relationship_description [F3]:
  Insufficient context to determine relationship.

  The email excerpts provided do not contain any direct correspondence between Francis Crick and Jeffrey Epstein, nor do they mention Francis Crick by name. The emails appear to be exchanges between Jeffrey Epstein and other individuals (David Grosof and someone with the email "triversr@gmail.com") discussing scientific topics, but without any clear connection to Francis Crick being established in the content shown.

discussion_ids:
  ["IMAGES-005-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_020446.txt_17827", "IMAGES-008-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_025169.txt_10088", "IMAGES-008-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_025172.txt_13267", "IMAGES-008-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_025176.txt_19076", "IMAGES-008-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_025185.txt_7820", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_020446.txt_15110", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_025176.txt_25646", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_025185.txt_1609"]


canonical_name [F2d]: Jim Watson
relationship_description [F3]:
  Insufficient context to determine relationship.

  The email excerpts do not contain any direct communications between Jim Watson and Jeffrey Epstein. The only reference to Watson is from Robert Trivers mentioning to Epstein that "you are now friends with JD Watson," but this provides no details about the nature, context, or extent of any relationship between Watson and Epstein.

discussion_ids:
  ["IMAGES-008-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_025140.txt_11087", "IMAGES-008-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_025169.txt_10088", "IMAGES-008-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_025172.txt_13267", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_020446.txt_15110", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_025140.txt_4696", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_025169.txt_3386", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_025172.txt_19464", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_025176.txt_25646", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_025185.txt_1609"]


canonical_name [F2d]: Lilly Jack
relationship_description [F3]:
  Insufficient context to determine relationship.

  The email excerpts are too fragmented and unclear to establish any meaningful relationship between Lilly Jack and Jeffrey Epstein. The emails appear to involve various individuals named Jack (including Jack Browning, an attorney), but there's no clear evidence of direct communication or interaction between someone specifically identified as "Lilly Jack" and Epstein.

discussion_ids:
  ["IMAGES-004-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_016479.txt_20236", "IMAGES-004-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_016480.txt_23541", "IMAGES-011-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_030626.txt_1615", "IMAGES-012-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_032811.txt_17280", "IMAGES-012-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_033460.txt_17373", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_026632.txt_13297", "TEXT-002-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_033120.txt_18969", "TEXT-002-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_033122.txt_16538"]


canonical_name [F2d]: Paul Manafort
relationship_description [F3]:
  Insufficient context to determine relationship.

  The emails show Jeffrey Epstein receiving news articles and updates about Paul Manafort's legal troubles and cooperation with authorities, but there is no direct communication between them or evidence of any personal, professional, or business relationship. The exchanges appear to be informational sharing about political developments rather than evidence of any substantive connection between Epstein and Manafort.

discussion_ids:
  ["IMAGES-010-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_030444.txt_5847", "IMAGES-011-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_031682.txt_23627", "IMAGES-011-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_031742.txt_17543", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_030444.txt_18639", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_031682.txt_1641", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_031742.txt_7352"]


canonical_name [F2d]: Sultan Hamad Jabor
relationship_description [F3]:
  Insufficient context to determine relationship.

  The email excerpts do not clearly identify Sultan Hamad Jabor as a specific correspondent, and the content primarily consists of news article shares about political topics, scattered personal notes, and brief logistical communications about travel plans. While there are references to meetings in various locations (Marrakesh, Doha, Paris), the fragmented nature of these exchanges and lack of clear identification of the parties involved makes it impossible to characterize the specific relationship between Epstein and Sultan Hamad Jabor.

discussion_ids:
  ["IMAGES-009-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_026632.txt_16612", "IMAGES-010-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_028859.txt_9423", "IMAGES-011-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_030786.txt_2514", "IMAGES-011-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_031637.txt_16518", "IMAGES-011-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_032359.txt_22122", "IMAGES-011-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_032360.txt_23707", "IMAGES-012-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_032529.txt_6301", "IMAGES-012-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_032914.txt_20751", "IMAGES-012-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_032946.txt_11628", "IMAGES-012-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_033011.txt_24931", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_019871.txt_1772", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_023418.txt_12069", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_025820.txt_24155", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_025827.txt_19439", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_025834.txt_24111", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_026632.txt_13297", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_028859.txt_22358", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_028862.txt_24398", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_028870.txt_21274", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_028875.txt_22800", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_029213.txt_21376", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_030786.txt_25576", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_031637.txt_6633", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_031682.txt_1641", "TEXT-002-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_032359.txt_14729", "TEXT-002-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_032529.txt_22120", "TEXT-002-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_032903.txt_5772", "TEXT-002-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_032914.txt_4156", "TEXT-002-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_032946.txt_15300", "TEXT-002-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_033011.txt_1927"]


canonical_name [F2d]: Jesse Kornbluth
relationship_description [F3]:
  Based on the limited email excerpts provided, Jesse Kornbluth appears to have no direct relationship with Jeffrey Epstein, but rather was investigating or questioning publicist Peggy Siegal about her continued association with Epstein after his legal troubles. The emails suggest Kornbluth was working on journalistic coverage of Epstein's social circle and was specifically probing Siegal about why she maintained her friendship with Epstein post-prison and what events she organized for him. The tone indicates Kornbluth was acting in a journalistic capacity, seeking to understand the dynamics of Epstein's continued social acceptance among powerful figures.

discussion_ids:
  ["IMAGES-011-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_031691.txt_19970", "IMAGES-011-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_031692.txt_21542", "IMAGES-011-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_031694.txt_24700", "IMAGES-011-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_031695.txt_25253", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_031691.txt_3320", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_031694.txt_1662"]


canonical_name [F2d]: Joe Allen
relationship_description [F3]:
  Insufficient context to determine relationship.

  The email excerpts only mention Joe Allen in passing as being married to Annette Tapert and living "near you in PB" (presumably Palm Beach, near Epstein), but there is no direct communication between Joe Allen and Jeffrey Epstein or any indication of their having a direct relationship of any kind.

discussion_ids:
  ["IMAGES-011-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_031691.txt_19970", "IMAGES-011-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_031694.txt_24700", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_031691.txt_3320", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_031694.txt_1662"]


canonical_name [F2d]: Katie Couric
relationship_description [F3]:
  Insufficient context to determine relationship.

  The email excerpts mention Katie Couric only in passing within a Daily Beast article URL about Jeffrey Epstein's social circle, but contain no direct communications between Couric and Epstein or specific details about the nature of any relationship they may have had.

discussion_ids:
  ["IMAGES-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_011905.txt_20183", "IMAGES-007-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_023198.txt_12280", "IMAGES-007-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_023202.txt_8479", "IMAGES-007-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_023205.txt_12650", "IMAGES-007-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_023545.txt_14863", "IMAGES-007-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_023548.txt_11028", "IMAGES-011-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_030889.txt_8058", "IMAGES-011-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_030893.txt_16162", "IMAGES-011-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_031383.txt_13763", "IMAGES-011-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_031692.txt_21542", "IMAGES-011-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_031694.txt_24700", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_011904.txt_11678", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_021406.txt_14594", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_023198.txt_14939", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_023202.txt_19202", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_023205.txt_14608", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_023548.txt_13121", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_030889.txt_17218", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_030909.txt_11590", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_030915.txt_19086", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_031026.txt_8793", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_031031.txt_7200", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_031383.txt_11097", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_031691.txt_3320", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_031694.txt_1662"]


canonical_name [F2d]: David Fizel
relationship_description [F3]:
  Based on these email excerpts, David Fiszel appears to have a business/investment relationship with Jeffrey Epstein, sharing investment opportunities and market insights. Fiszel regularly updates Epstein on tech companies like Palantir, discusses investment valuations, and suggests social meetings ("Let's hang in PB" - likely Palm Beach). The tone is informal and collaborative, suggesting they are investment partners or that Fiszel serves as an investment advisor to Epstein, sharing opportunities he believes would interest Epstein.

discussion_ids:
  ["IMAGES-010-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_028494.txt_7979", "IMAGES-012-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_033207.txt_24760", "IMAGES-012-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_033208.txt_2261", "IMAGES-012-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_033580.txt_3694", "TEXT-002-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_033207.txt_1700", "TEXT-002-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_033208.txt_24221", "TEXT-002-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_033580.txt_19538"]


canonical_name [F2d]: Bradley Edwards
relationship_description [F3]:
  Based on the email excerpts, Bradley Edwards appears to have had an adversarial legal relationship with Jeffrey Epstein. Edwards was representing clients who alleged they were underage victims of Epstein and had filed claims against him that were scheduled for jury trial. According to the journalist's inquiry, Edwards claimed that Epstein maliciously attempted to intimidate both him and his clients into retracting their allegations.

discussion_ids:
  ["IMAGES-002-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_013405.txt_25096", "IMAGES-007-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_023018.txt_16314", "IMAGES-007-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_023020.txt_15924", "IMAGES-007-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_023022.txt_13088", "IMAGES-007-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_023024.txt_16265", "IMAGES-007-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_023028.txt_8187", "IMAGES-007-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_023067.txt_4716", "IMAGES-011-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_030618.txt_1707", "IMAGES-011-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_030620.txt_4793", "IMAGES-011-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_030622.txt_4950", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_013405.txt_22658", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_023018.txt_7720", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_023020.txt_11719", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_023022.txt_10983", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_023024.txt_7779", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_023026.txt_8431", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_023028.txt_19028", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_030618.txt_24769", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_030622.txt_21559", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_030624.txt_24721"]


canonical_name [F2d]: Fred Haddad
relationship_description [F3]:
  Insufficient context to determine relationship.

  The email excerpts show that Fred Haddad had direct email communication with Jeffrey Epstein and was also in contact with Darren Indyke (who appears to be associated with Epstein's legal matters), but the actual content of these communications is not provided. While there are references to legal proceedings and media coverage involving Epstein, the nature and context of Haddad's specific relationship to Epstein cannot be determined from these incomplete email headers and fragments.

discussion_ids:
  ["IMAGES-007-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_023024.txt_16265", "IMAGES-007-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_023026.txt_19252", "IMAGES-007-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_023028.txt_8187", "IMAGES-007-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_023067.txt_4716", "IMAGES-011-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_030618.txt_1707", "IMAGES-011-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_030622.txt_4950", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_023024.txt_7779", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_023026.txt_8431", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_023028.txt_19028", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_023067.txt_19671", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_030618.txt_24769", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_030620.txt_20378", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_030622.txt_21559", "TEXT-002-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_033228.txt_6464"]


canonical_name [F2d]: Sharon Churcher
relationship_description [F3]:
  Based on the email excerpts, Sharon Churcher appears to be a journalist investigating Jeffrey Epstein for allegations involving underage victims. The relationship is professional and adversarial, with Churcher seeking information for articles about legal proceedings against Epstein, including claims of witness intimidation and allegations involving underage individuals and high-profile figures like Prince Andrew. The emails show Churcher requesting comment on serious criminal allegations, indicating a typical journalist-subject dynamic during investigative reporting.

discussion_ids:
  ["IMAGES-007-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_023018.txt_16314", "IMAGES-007-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_023020.txt_15924", "IMAGES-007-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_023022.txt_13088", "IMAGES-007-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_023024.txt_16265", "IMAGES-007-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_023026.txt_19252", "IMAGES-007-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_023028.txt_8187", "IMAGES-007-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_023067.txt_4716", "IMAGES-011-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_030618.txt_1707", "IMAGES-011-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_030620.txt_4793", "IMAGES-011-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_030622.txt_4950", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_023018.txt_7720", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_023020.txt_11719", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_023022.txt_10983", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_023024.txt_7779", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_023026.txt_8431", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_023028.txt_19028", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_023067.txt_19671", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_030618.txt_24769", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_030620.txt_20378", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_030622.txt_21559", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_030624.txt_24721"]


canonical_name [F2d]: Bryan Subotnick
relationship_description [F3]:
  Insufficient context to determine relationship.

  The provided email excerpts show Bryan Subotnick sending emails to "Subotnick Stuart" with content about Palm Beach real estate and finance, but contain no mention of Jeffrey Epstein or any interactions between Bryan Subotnick and Epstein that would indicate the nature of their relationship.

discussion_ids:
  ["IMAGES-012-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_033157.txt_3160", "IMAGES-012-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_033561.txt_24773", "TEXT-002-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_033157.txt_25372", "TEXT-002-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_033561.txt_1720"]


canonical_name [F2d]: Paul Prosperi
relationship_description [F3]:
  Based on the email excerpts, Paul Prosperi appears to have had a business or financial relationship with Jeffrey Epstein. The emails suggest Prosperi may have provided financial management or advisory services to Epstein, with one fragment referencing a meeting at Epstein's Bedford home where Epstein requested help, and Prosperi expressing reluctance about financial interactions affecting their relationship. However, the email excerpts are incomplete and fragmented, making it difficult to determine the full scope or exact nature of their professional relationship.

discussion_ids:
  ["IMAGES-007-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_023279.txt_22959", "IMAGES-007-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_023307.txt_5403", "IMAGES-008-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_025329.txt_22756", "IMAGES-011-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_030863.txt_6695", "IMAGES-012-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_033157.txt_3160", "IMAGES-012-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_033383.txt_1899", "IMAGES-012-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_033561.txt_24773", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_030216.txt_3342", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_030863.txt_16574", "TEXT-002-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_033157.txt_25372", "TEXT-002-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_033383.txt_24898", "TEXT-002-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_033561.txt_1720"]


canonical_name [F2d]: Subotnick Stuart
relationship_description [F3]:
  Insufficient context to determine relationship.

  The email excerpts provided do not contain any clear information about the nature of Stuart Subotnick's relationship with Jeffrey Epstein. While the emails mention various individuals including Stuart Subotnick and reference coordination with a "client's PR firm," there is no explicit discussion of Jeffrey Epstein or the specific context of any interactions between him and Subotnick.

discussion_ids:
  ["IMAGES-009-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_026653.txt_25249", "IMAGES-012-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_033157.txt_3160", "IMAGES-012-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_033561.txt_24773", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_026652.txt_21347", "TEXT-002-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_033157.txt_25372", "TEXT-002-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_033561.txt_1720"]


canonical_name [F2d]: Debbie Fein
relationship_description [F3]:
  Insufficient context to determine relationship.

  The provided email excerpts do not contain any direct correspondence between Debbie Fein and Jeffrey Epstein, nor do they mention Debbie Fein in any context that would reveal the nature of their relationship.

discussion_ids:
  ["IMAGES-002-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_012898.txt_21098", "IMAGES-007-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_023026.txt_19252", "IMAGES-012-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_033575.txt_24728", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_012898.txt_20296", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_023026.txt_8431", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_023067.txt_19671", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_030618.txt_24769", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_030624.txt_24721", "TEXT-002-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_033575.txt_1727"]


canonical_name [F2d]: Peter Thiel
relationship_description [F3]:
  Based on these email excerpts, Peter Thiel and Jeffrey Epstein appear to have had a social and potentially business relationship that involved high-level networking and meetings with political/diplomatic figures. The emails show Epstein organizing meetings with Thiel alongside prominent individuals like "bill burns" (likely diplomat William Burns) and former Obama counsel Kathy Ruemmler, and Thiel was included on what appears to be a guest list for an exclusive "MONEY" seminar alongside other tech luminaries and wealthy individuals. The tone suggests a casual but connected relationship where Epstein served as a facilitator for elite networking opportunities.

discussion_ids:
  ["IMAGES-002-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_013484.txt_12328", "IMAGES-004-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_017574.txt_25237", "IMAGES-004-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_017581.txt_4421", "IMAGES-007-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_023419.txt_15013", "IMAGES-009-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_026549.txt_9596", "IMAGES-009-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_026661.txt_2262", "IMAGES-010-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_028784.txt_5939", "IMAGES-010-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_028859.txt_9423", "IMAGES-010-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_029087.txt_19546", "IMAGES-010-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_029090.txt_21194", "IMAGES-010-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_029092.txt_20824", "IMAGES-010-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_030215.txt_17803", "IMAGES-011-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_030950.txt_24918", "IMAGES-011-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_031569.txt_16192", "IMAGES-011-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_032274.txt_19090", "IMAGES-012-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_032827.txt_12472", "IMAGES-012-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_032864.txt_24649", "IMAGES-012-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_032878.txt_6080", "IMAGES-012-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_033137.txt_7957", "IMAGES-012-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_033213.txt_24752", "IMAGES-012-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_033216.txt_19864", "IMAGES-012-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_033244.txt_12362", "IMAGES-012-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_033306.txt_17398", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_017574.txt_18921", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_017581.txt_10799", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_025820.txt_24155", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_026549.txt_12202", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_026632.txt_13297", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_026661.txt_5178", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_028784.txt_18916", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_028859.txt_22358", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_028862.txt_24398", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_028875.txt_22800", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_029090.txt_8153", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_029092.txt_8032", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_029213.txt_21376", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_030215.txt_4998", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_030950.txt_1869", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_031569.txt_7048", "TEXT-002-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_032274.txt_24655", "TEXT-002-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_032320.txt_6232", "TEXT-002-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_032827.txt_15966", "TEXT-002-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_032864.txt_1814", "TEXT-002-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_032878.txt_22483", "TEXT-002-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_033137.txt_17361", "TEXT-002-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_033213.txt_1739", "TEXT-002-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_033216.txt_3276", "TEXT-002-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_033244.txt_16082", "TEXT-002-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_033306.txt_7447"]


canonical_name [F2d]: Richard Branson
relationship_description [F3]:
  Insufficient context to determine relationship.

  The provided email excerpts do not contain any communication between Richard Branson and Jeffrey Epstein, nor do they mention Richard Branson at all. The emails shown are brief fragments from Jeffrey Epstein to Larry Summers and others, but provide no information about any relationship with Richard Branson.

discussion_ids:
  ["IMAGES-011-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_031659.txt_2817", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_031657.txt_1744", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_031659.txt_25703", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_031662.txt_21132"]


canonical_name [F2d]: Stanley Rosenberg
relationship_description [F3]:
  Based on these email excerpts, Stanley Rosenberg and Jeffrey Epstein appear to have had a professional relationship centered around Rosenberg's expertise on the vagus nerve. The emails show Epstein seeking consultations or discussions with Rosenberg (who appears to be a specialist in this area), with Rosenberg asking about Epstein's specific interest in the vagus nerve and considering travel to New York for meetings, though preferring virtual communication due to his age and travel limitations. The tone seems cordial and professional, with Rosenberg treating this as a consultation or educational exchange about his area of expertise.

discussion_ids:
  ["IMAGES-008-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_026162.txt_1771", "IMAGES-012-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_032565.txt_8262", "IMAGES-012-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_032567.txt_7934", "IMAGES-012-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_033016.txt_21857", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_026162.txt_8474", "TEXT-002-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_032565.txt_18192", "TEXT-002-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_032567.txt_17301", "TEXT-002-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_033016.txt_6277"]


canonical_name [F2d]: Bill Richardson
relationship_description [F3]:
  Insufficient context to determine relationship.

  The email excerpts contain mostly fragmented personal notes, random thoughts, and scattered name lists rather than meaningful correspondence between Bill Richardson and Jeffrey Epstein. While Richardson's name appears in what seems to be contact lists alongside various political figures, there is no actual communication or context provided that would indicate the nature, scope, or character of any relationship between the two individuals.

discussion_ids:
  ["IMAGES-005-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_019871.txt_5271", "IMAGES-009-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_026632.txt_16612", "IMAGES-010-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_029622.txt_15184", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_019871.txt_1772", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_025347.txt_2947", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_026632.txt_13297", "TEXT-002-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_033286.txt_14665"]


canonical_name [F2d]: Danny Hillis
relationship_description [F3]:
  Insufficient context to determine relationship.

  The email excerpts only show Danny Hillis's name appearing on what appear to be guest lists for seminars labeled "MONEY" organized by Jeffrey Epstein's assistant. There are no direct communications between Hillis and Epstein, nor any indication of the actual nature of their relationship or whether Hillis even attended these events.

discussion_ids:
  ["IMAGES-007-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_023454.txt_24678", "IMAGES-009-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_026549.txt_9596", "IMAGES-010-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_028784.txt_5939", "IMAGES-010-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_029280.txt_24503", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_019871.txt_1772", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_026549.txt_12202", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_028784.txt_18916"]


canonical_name [F2d]: Halle Berry
relationship_description [F3]:
  Insufficient context to determine relationship.

  The email excerpts only mention Halle Berry once in passing as part of a list of social events that someone named Stephanie was forwarding to Epstein for his potential interest. There is no indication of direct communication between Berry and Epstein, nor any evidence of an actual relationship of any kind.

discussion_ids:
  ["IMAGES-002-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_012711.txt_4124", "IMAGES-005-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_019871.txt_5271", "IMAGES-010-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_029841.txt_5621", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_012711.txt_4900", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_019871.txt_1772", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_029841.txt_18428"]


canonical_name [F2d]: Jacques Lang
relationship_description [F3]:
  Insufficient context to determine relationship.

  The email excerpts are fragmentary and don't provide clear information about the nature of Jeffrey Epstein's relationship with Jacques Lang. While there are references to "Jacques" and someone with the surname "Lang," the emails are largely incoherent, incomplete, or contain only brief exchanges without substantive content that would indicate the type or context of their relationship.

discussion_ids:
  ["IMAGES-008-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_026159.txt_6389", "IMAGES-008-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_026324.txt_18111", "IMAGES-010-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_029622.txt_15184", "IMAGES-011-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_032298.txt_14858", "IMAGES-011-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_032461.txt_14888", "IMAGES-012-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_032940.txt_8331", "IMAGES-012-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_032968.txt_8340", "IMAGES-012-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_033120.txt_9599", "IMAGES-012-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_033122.txt_6601", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_019871.txt_1772", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_026159.txt_12610", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_026161.txt_6861", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_026324.txt_24274", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_026632.txt_13297", "TEXT-002-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_032811.txt_7924", "TEXT-002-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_032940.txt_18478", "TEXT-002-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_032968.txt_18547", "TEXT-002-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_033120.txt_18969", "TEXT-002-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_033122.txt_16538"]


canonical_name [F2d]: Princess Mette
relationship_description [F3]:
  Insufficient context to determine relationship.

  The email excerpts mention Princess Mette only briefly in one message from Boris Nikolic, where he notes that Eva (their host in Vienna) is "very close friend with mette" and they are "trying to get mette to join at the last moment" for what appears to be social events in Vienna. There is no direct communication between Princess Mette and Jeffrey Epstein in these excerpts, nor enough detail to characterize any relationship between them.

discussion_ids:
  ["IMAGES-005-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_019871.txt_5271", "IMAGES-010-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_028768.txt_2112", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_019871.txt_1772", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_028768.txt_15073"]


canonical_name [F2d]: Steven J Gould
relationship_description [F3]:
  Insufficient context to determine relationship.

  The email excerpts appear to be notes or stream-of-consciousness writing from Jeffrey Epstein to himself, with Steven J. Gould mentioned only as one name in a long list of various academics, politicians, and other figures. There is no direct communication between them or specific context about the nature of any relationship.

discussion_ids:
  ["IMAGES-005-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_019871.txt_5271", "IMAGES-009-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_026632.txt_16612", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_019871.txt_1772", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_026632.txt_13297"]


canonical_name [F2d]: Jeffery Edwards
relationship_description [F3]:
  Insufficient context to determine relationship.

  The provided email excerpts do not contain any communications involving Jeffrey Edwards or Jeffrey Epstein. The emails shown are from Terry Kafka to Mark L. Epstein and promotional emails from DeMilked, with no content that would indicate the nature of any relationship between Jeffrey Edwards and Jeffrey Epstein.

discussion_ids:
  ["IMAGES-006-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_020666.txt_20835", "IMAGES-009-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_026517.txt_1834", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_020666.txt_7271", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_026517.txt_5580"]


canonical_name [F2d]: Ian Osborne
relationship_description [F3]:
  Based on the email excerpts, Ian Osborne appears to have had a business/professional relationship with Jeffrey Epstein, likely serving as an advisor or connector in tech and investment circles. Osborne was being considered for inclusion on Epstein's exclusive "seminar" invitation lists alongside prominent tech figures like Bill Gates, Jeff Bezos, and Peter Thiel, and provided advice to Epstein about tech industry opportunities and personnel. The tone suggests a casual but businesslike relationship, with Osborne offering insights on tech investments and expressing frustration about certain industry practices.

discussion_ids:
  ["IMAGES-002-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_013484.txt_12328", "IMAGES-009-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_026549.txt_9596", "IMAGES-010-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_028784.txt_5939", "IMAGES-011-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_030950.txt_24918", "IMAGES-011-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_030951.txt_25071", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_013484.txt_9904", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_026549.txt_12202", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_028784.txt_18916", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_030950.txt_1869"]


canonical_name [F2d]: Reid Hoffman
relationship_description [F3]:
  Based on these email excerpts, Reid Hoffman and Jeffrey Epstein appear to have had a personal relationship that involved discussions about philanthropy and social issues, with Hoffman planning to meet with Epstein in August. Their exchanges show Epstein proposing ideas about wealthy individuals funding charitable causes to replace government programs, while Hoffman responds briefly and cordially. A third party refers to Hoffman in a business context when discussing potential opportunities with Epstein, suggesting some level of professional acquaintance as well.

discussion_ids:
  ["IMAGES-010-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_029282.txt_23848", "IMAGES-010-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_029983.txt_11325", "IMAGES-010-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_030002.txt_19149", "IMAGES-011-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_030950.txt_24918", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_029282.txt_11174", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_029983.txt_23993", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_030002.txt_6199", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_030950.txt_1869"]


canonical_name [F2d]: Kate Briquelet
relationship_description [F3]:
  Based on these email excerpts, Kate Briquelet appears to be a journalist seeking information about Jeffrey Epstein for reporting purposes. She is contacting what appears to be Epstein's legal counsel (Martin Weinberg) to inquire about Epstein's knowledge of alleged illegal dealings by Donald Trump, specifically related to real estate transactions and potential threats. The relationship appears to be professional and adversarial in nature, with Briquelet attempting to gather information about Epstein for what seems to be investigative journalism.

discussion_ids:
  ["IMAGES-010-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_030150.txt_8557", "IMAGES-011-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_030976.txt_2491", "IMAGES-011-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_030978.txt_24938", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_030149.txt_4254", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_030976.txt_25527", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_030978.txt_1924"]


canonical_name [F2d]: Wilbur Ross
relationship_description [F3]:
  Insufficient context to determine relationship.

  The email excerpts show Jeffrey Epstein receiving news articles about Wilbur Ross's appointment as Commerce Secretary and general information about private equity connections to the Trump administration, but they don't reveal any direct communication, meetings, or specific relationship between Epstein and Ross themselves.

discussion_ids:
  ["IMAGES-009-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_026650.txt_23658", "IMAGES-011-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_032219.txt_1945", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_026650.txt_20603", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_031681.txt_3228", "TEXT-002-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_032219.txt_9257"]


canonical_name [F2d]: Dominique Strauss-Kahn
relationship_description [F3]:
  Based on these email excerpts, there is insufficient context to determine a direct personal or professional relationship between Dominique Strauss-Kahn and Jeffrey Epstein. The emails show Epstein receiving and forwarding conspiracy theory articles about Strauss-Kahn's arrest, and making one comment comparing Strauss-Kahn's case to Prince Andrew's situation. The interactions appear to be Epstein sharing or commenting on news content rather than evidence of any substantial relationship between the two individuals.

discussion_ids:
  ["IMAGES-011-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_031333.txt_24813", "IMAGES-011-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_031335.txt_21629", "IMAGES-011-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_031697.txt_23071", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_023065.txt_22235", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_031333.txt_1948", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_031335.txt_5245"]


canonical_name [F2d]: David Asch
relationship_description [F3]:
  Insufficient context to determine relationship.

  The email excerpts provided do not contain any direct correspondence between David Asch and Jeffrey Epstein, nor do they provide meaningful context about their relationship. The only mention of "David" appears in a brief question "what is david doing?" but there is no clear indication this refers to David Asch or provides any substantive information about a relationship with Epstein.

discussion_ids:
  ["IMAGES-011-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_031441.txt_24786", "IMAGES-011-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_031443.txt_23528", "IMAGES-011-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_031591.txt_14350", "IMAGES-011-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_031997.txt_8312", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_031441.txt_1982", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_031591.txt_10890", "TEXT-002-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_031996.txt_2083"]


canonical_name [F2d]: Jamie Rosenwald
relationship_description [F3]:
  Based on the email excerpts, Jamie Rosenwald appears to be a former student of Jeffrey Epstein's from when Epstein taught physics at the Dalton School. The relationship seems to be that of a former teacher-student reconnecting, with Rosenwald reaching out to congratulate Epstein on his financial success while also expressing concern about negative press coverage. The tone is familiar but somewhat cautionary, suggesting they maintained a cordial relationship over the years despite Rosenwald's apparent reservations about Epstein's public image.

discussion_ids:
  ["IMAGES-011-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_031441.txt_24786", "IMAGES-011-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_031443.txt_23528", "IMAGES-011-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_031591.txt_14350", "IMAGES-011-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_031997.txt_8312", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_031441.txt_1982", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_031591.txt_10890", "TEXT-002-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_031996.txt_2083"]


canonical_name [F2d]: Andrew Bryant
relationship_description [F3]:
  Insufficient context to determine relationship.

  The email excerpts only show Jeffrey Epstein forwarding what appears to be a published article or blog post written by Andrew Bryant (and Craig Sherman) about tax benefits for startup founders and investors. There is no direct communication between Epstein and Bryant, nor any indication of whether they had any personal or professional relationship beyond Epstein's apparent interest in sharing Bryant's published content.

discussion_ids:
  ["IMAGES-004-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_018084.txt_22374", "IMAGES-011-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_031089.txt_1984", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_018084.txt_15816", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_031089.txt_24801"]


canonical_name [F2d]: Craig Sherman
relationship_description [F3]:
  Insufficient context to determine relationship.

  The emails show Jeffrey Epstein forwarding what appears to be a published article or newsletter written by Craig Sherman and Andrew Bryant about tax benefits for startup founders and investors. There is no direct communication between Epstein and Sherman, nor any indication of personal or professional interaction between them.

discussion_ids:
  ["IMAGES-004-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_018084.txt_22374", "IMAGES-011-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_031089.txt_1984", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_018084.txt_15816", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_031089.txt_24801"]


canonical_name [F2d]: Caroline Lang
relationship_description [F3]:
  Insufficient context to determine relationship.

  The email excerpts show Caroline Lang and Jeffrey Epstein exchanging brief messages about political topics (referencing the Clinton/Trump debate and presidential campaign) and arranging to meet in person, but there is not enough substantive content to determine the nature of their relationship or the context of their interactions.

discussion_ids:
  ["IMAGES-008-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_026159.txt_6389", "IMAGES-011-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_032297.txt_11755", "IMAGES-011-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_032387.txt_2750", "IMAGES-011-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_032458.txt_16533", "IMAGES-011-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_032464.txt_16575", "IMAGES-012-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_032964.txt_16389", "TEXT-002-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_032297.txt_5909", "TEXT-002-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_032387.txt_8373", "TEXT-002-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_032461.txt_22361", "TEXT-002-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_032464.txt_23905", "TEXT-002-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_032467.txt_25515", "TEXT-002-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_032486.txt_4517", "TEXT-002-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_032491.txt_6143", "TEXT-002-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_032496.txt_2006"]


canonical_name [F2d]: Recep Tayyip Erdogan
relationship_description [F3]:
  Insufficient context to determine relationship.

  The email excerpts show communications between Jeffrey Epstein and Thorbjørn Jagland (former Norwegian Prime Minister and Nobel Committee Chairman) discussing political figures including Erdogan, but there is no direct communication or evidence of any relationship between Epstein and Erdogan themselves. Erdogan is only mentioned in passing as a difficult political figure that Jagland had to deal with regarding a Turkish referendum.

discussion_ids:
  ["IMAGES-009-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_026673.txt_5389", "IMAGES-009-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_026985.txt_6833", "IMAGES-011-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_031472.txt_2317", "IMAGES-011-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_031480.txt_23431", "IMAGES-011-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_032362.txt_24639", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_026673.txt_2018", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_027061.txt_14408", "TEXT-002-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_033233.txt_22503", "TEXT-002-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_033388.txt_4123"]


canonical_name [F2d]: Alex Yablon
relationship_description [F3]:
  Based on these email excerpts, Alex Yablon appears to be a journalist conducting an interview or investigation involving Jeffrey Epstein. The emails show Yablon asking detailed questions about Epstein's Manhattan home, work habits, and media attention, suggesting a professional reporter-subject relationship. The tone is formal and professional, with Yablon attempting to coordinate communication and gather specific information for what appears to be a news story or article.

discussion_ids:
  ["IMAGES-008-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_025875.txt_6248", "IMAGES-008-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_026348.txt_2023", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_025875.txt_12910", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_026348.txt_8194", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_026351.txt_17652"]


canonical_name [F2d]: Ronan Farrow
relationship_description [F3]:
  Insufficient context to determine relationship.

  The email excerpts provided are primarily correspondence between Jeffrey Epstein and Michael Wolff, with only one brief mention of Ronan Farrow in a New York Post article link sent by Richard Kahn to Epstein. There is no direct communication between Epstein and Farrow, nor any substantive discussion about their relationship in these excerpts.

discussion_ids:
  ["IMAGES-008-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_026440.txt_17384", "IMAGES-011-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_030683.txt_12734", "IMAGES-011-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_030684.txt_8182", "IMAGES-011-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_030686.txt_7958", "IMAGES-011-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_030699.txt_14650", "IMAGES-011-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_030771.txt_21607", "IMAGES-012-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_033273.txt_16735", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_030683.txt_15662", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_030684.txt_18181", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_030686.txt_17362", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_030696.txt_14968", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_030699.txt_11826", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_030770.txt_6180", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_030771.txt_5209", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_030773.txt_4553", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_030777.txt_2026", "TEXT-002-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_033273.txt_6570"]


canonical_name [F2d]: Paul Barrett
relationship_description [F3]:
  Based on these email excerpts, Paul Barrett appears to have a professional financial advisor or investment manager relationship with Jeffrey Epstein. Barrett is providing investment recommendations on stocks (particularly Broadcom), options strategies, and currency trades, while Epstein has given him some trading authority over investment decisions. The tone becomes strained and critical, with Epstein expressing frustration over Barrett's trading performance, particularly regarding SPY trades that Epstein characterized as the work of a "rank amateur."

discussion_ids:
  ["IMAGES-011-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_031804.txt_16730", "IMAGES-011-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_031805.txt_17168", "IMAGES-011-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_031806.txt_18806", "IMAGES-011-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_031807.txt_18301", "IMAGES-011-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_031809.txt_9164", "IMAGES-011-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_031810.txt_16686", "IMAGES-011-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_031811.txt_17179", "IMAGES-011-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_031813.txt_18359", "IMAGES-011-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_031814.txt_15616", "IMAGES-011-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_031815.txt_15011", "IMAGES-011-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_031818.txt_10853", "IMAGES-011-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_031819.txt_10256", "IMAGES-011-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_031820.txt_8625", "IMAGES-012-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_033097.txt_9089", "IMAGES-012-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_033270.txt_18303", "TEXT-002-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_031804.txt_23781", "TEXT-002-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_031806.txt_24514", "TEXT-002-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_031809.txt_2033", "TEXT-002-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_031813.txt_25412", "TEXT-002-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_031818.txt_3587", "TEXT-002-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_033097.txt_19069", "TEXT-002-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_033270.txt_8151"]


canonical_name [F2d]: Michael Wolff
relationship_description [F3]:
  Insufficient context to determine relationship.

  The email excerpts mention Michael Wolff's name only in a URL link about his book on Trump, while the other emails appear to involve Jeffrey Epstein discussing grand jury matters with what seems to be legal counsel. There is no clear evidence of direct communication or interaction between Wolff and Epstein in these fragments.

discussion_ids:
  ["IMAGES-011-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_031552.txt_14443", "IMAGES-011-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_031559.txt_8091", "IMAGES-012-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_032704.txt_2038", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_031549.txt_13956", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_031552.txt_10767"]


canonical_name [F2d]: Cyrus R. Vance Jr.
relationship_description [F3]:
  Insufficient context to determine relationship.

  The email excerpts provided do not contain any direct communication between Cyrus R. Vance Jr. and Jeffrey Epstein, nor do they reference any specific interactions between them. While there are references to "the DA's office" in journalist Susan Edelman's emails, these don't provide enough information to characterize the nature of any relationship between Vance (as Manhattan DA) and Epstein.

discussion_ids:
  ["IMAGES-003-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_016465.txt_5960", "IMAGES-003-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_016468.txt_19856", "IMAGES-006-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_022250.txt_2048", "IMAGES-010-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_029766.txt_9735", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_022250.txt_15530", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_029766.txt_22677"]


canonical_name [F2d]: Janet Katka
relationship_description [F3]:
  Insufficient context to determine relationship.

  The email excerpts mention Terry Kafka (not Janet Katka) and Mark L. Epstein, but do not contain any substantive communication between them or clear indication of their relationship nature. The emails primarily consist of political messages about the Iran deal sent to various recipients.

discussion_ids:
  ["IMAGES-008-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_025912.txt_2069", "IMAGES-009-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_026620.txt_13494", "IMAGES-010-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_028482.txt_8172", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_026517.txt_5580", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_026620.txt_16448", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_028482.txt_21008"]


canonical_name [F2d]: Philip Kafka
relationship_description [F3]:
  Based on the email excerpts, Philip Kafka appears to have a casual social relationship with Jeffrey Epstein, mediated through Terry Kafka who seems to know both men. The limited context suggests informal, friendly interactions, with Terry referencing shared experiences like a "lesson in common sense" about French fries at Nathan's, and Philip making a joking political reference ("Epstein 2016!"). However, the emails provide insufficient context to determine the depth, duration, or specific nature of their relationship beyond these brief social exchanges.

discussion_ids:
  ["IMAGES-008-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_025911.txt_456", "IMAGES-008-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_025912.txt_2069", "IMAGES-008-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_025918.txt_19818", "IMAGES-008-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_025919.txt_20521", "IMAGES-008-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_025926.txt_22161", "IMAGES-008-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_025927.txt_21425", "IMAGES-008-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_025928.txt_5294", "IMAGES-009-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_026620.txt_13494", "IMAGES-010-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_028482.txt_8172", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_025911.txt_7169", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_025918.txt_13539", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_025926.txt_15430", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_026620.txt_16448", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_028482.txt_21008"]


canonical_name [F2d]: Alireza Ittihadieh
relationship_description [F3]:
  Based on the email excerpts, Alireza Ittihadieh appears to have had a business relationship with Jeffrey Epstein, primarily involving aircraft sales and possibly real estate transactions. The communications show Ittihadieh providing information about private jets (G550s, G650s, and BBJs) with multi-million dollar price points, while Epstein made inquiries about aircraft specifications and property deals. The relationship appears to have soured, as evidenced by Ittihadieh's final message stating he would "NO longer provide free information" and wanted to limit their interactions to friendship and political discussions rather than continuing to share business intelligence.

discussion_ids:
  ["IMAGES-011-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_032217.txt_25516", "IMAGES-011-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_032436.txt_2807", "IMAGES-011-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_032437.txt_2090", "IMAGES-011-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_032439.txt_25370", "IMAGES-012-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_032792.txt_13204", "IMAGES-012-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_032793.txt_14245", "IMAGES-012-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_032958.txt_16352", "IMAGES-012-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_033001.txt_20242", "IMAGES-012-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_033201.txt_21483", "TEXT-002-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_032217.txt_18221", "TEXT-002-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_032437.txt_9478", "TEXT-002-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_032439.txt_18000", "TEXT-002-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_032441.txt_1865", "TEXT-002-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_032792.txt_10498", "TEXT-002-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_032793.txt_10607", "TEXT-002-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_032958.txt_7204", "TEXT-002-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_033001.txt_4633", "TEXT-002-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_033201.txt_4883"]


canonical_name [F2d]: Zubair Khan
relationship_description [F3]:
  Based on the email excerpts, Zubair Khan appears to have had a professional relationship with Jeffrey Epstein, where Khan was providing social media analytics and political polling data related to the 2016 U.S. presidential election between Trump and Clinton. Khan was seeking business investment from Epstein for his company "InsightsPod," which analyzed Twitter sentiment to predict election outcomes, and regularly sent detailed reports on candidate performance and winning probabilities. The tone suggests a business relationship where Khan was positioning himself as a data analytics expert while soliciting financial backing from Epstein.

discussion_ids:
  ["IMAGES-009-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_026626.txt_16671", "IMAGES-011-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_031518.txt_19377", "IMAGES-011-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_031521.txt_24200", "IMAGES-011-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_031640.txt_23001", "IMAGES-011-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_032280.txt_10100", "IMAGES-011-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_032319.txt_6966", "IMAGES-011-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_032323.txt_10163", "IMAGES-011-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_032325.txt_6921", "IMAGES-012-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_033171.txt_24361", "IMAGES-012-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_033175.txt_20847", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_026626.txt_13274", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_031518.txt_3737", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_031521.txt_2176", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_031640.txt_111", "TEXT-002-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_032280.txt_4285", "TEXT-002-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_032319.txt_1359", "TEXT-002-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_032323.txt_4603", "TEXT-002-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_032325.txt_1410", "TEXT-002-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_033171.txt_2122", "TEXT-002-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_033175.txt_4443"]


canonical_name [F2d]: Donald Trump Jr.
relationship_description [F3]:
  Insufficient context to determine relationship.

  The email excerpts provided do not contain any direct communication between Donald Trump Jr. and Jeffrey Epstein, nor do they reference any specific interactions, meetings, or business dealings between them. The emails consist primarily of third-party political commentary and news articles being shared with Epstein about Trump family matters, but provide no evidence of a direct relationship between Epstein and Trump Jr.

discussion_ids:
  ["IMAGES-008-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_025548.txt_15405", "IMAGES-011-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_031742.txt_17543", "IMAGES-011-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_032308.txt_11762", "IMAGES-012-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_032894.txt_2189", "IMAGES-012-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_033566.txt_22087", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_025548.txt_22037", "TEXT-002-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_032308.txt_6280", "TEXT-002-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_032309.txt_5071", "TEXT-002-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_032894.txt_24170", "TEXT-002-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_033566.txt_6475"]


canonical_name [F2d]: Gianni Serazzi
relationship_description [F3]:
  Based on these email excerpts, Gianni Serazzi and Jeffrey Epstein appear to have had a casual correspondence relationship focused on political discussions, particularly around the time of U.S. elections involving Hillary Clinton. Serazzi was providing Epstein with political analysis about European populist movements and their potential relevance to American politics, suggesting he may have viewed Epstein as someone with political connections or influence. The tone appears informal and advisory, with Serazzi offering insights he thought might be valuable "for HC" (presumably Hillary Clinton).

discussion_ids:
  ["IMAGES-011-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_032308.txt_11762", "IMAGES-011-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_032309.txt_12540", "IMAGES-012-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_032894.txt_2189", "TEXT-002-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_032308.txt_6280", "TEXT-002-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_032309.txt_5071", "TEXT-002-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_032894.txt_24170"]


canonical_name [F2d]: Barry Cohen
relationship_description [F3]:
  Based on these email excerpts, Barry Cohen and Jeffrey Epstein appear to have had a business/advisory relationship focused on aviation and financial matters. Cohen sought Epstein's input on switching aviation service providers and shared aviation tax counsel reviews, suggesting Epstein had expertise or experience in private jet operations that Cohen valued. The tone appears professional and consultative, with Cohen treating Epstein as a knowledgeable advisor on aviation-related business decisions.

discussion_ids:
  ["IMAGES-007-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_023220.txt_13268", "IMAGES-007-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_023255.txt_22217", "IMAGES-007-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_023256.txt_20588", "IMAGES-007-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_023283.txt_21259", "IMAGES-007-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_023301.txt_2236", "IMAGES-007-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_023334.txt_21572", "IMAGES-007-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_023358.txt_11943", "IMAGES-008-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_026216.txt_1120", "IMAGES-008-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_026218.txt_23066", "IMAGES-008-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_026221.txt_21490", "IMAGES-008-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_026222.txt_19913", "IMAGES-008-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_026224.txt_23132", "IMAGES-008-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_026225.txt_23603", "IMAGES-008-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_026455.txt_16476", "IMAGES-008-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_026456.txt_18136", "IMAGES-009-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_026764.txt_11687", "IMAGES-009-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_026765.txt_12634", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_026216.txt_7341", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_026218.txt_16877", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_026221.txt_15277", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_026224.txt_16836", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_026455.txt_22676", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_026764.txt_8661", "TEXT-002-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_033301.txt_10375"]


canonical_name [F2d]: David Marin
relationship_description [F3]:
  Insufficient context to determine relationship.

  The email excerpts provided do not mention David Marin or Jeffrey Epstein. Instead, they appear to be communications between lawyers at Steptoe & Johnson LLP (including Will Bohlen, Michael Keough, and Kathryn King) regarding media strategy and press coverage for Turkish cleric Fethullah Gulen, who was accused by Turkey of orchestrating a coup attempt in 2016.

discussion_ids:
  ["IMAGES-011-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_031472.txt_2317", "IMAGES-011-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_031473.txt_2606", "IMAGES-011-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_031474.txt_5512", "IMAGES-011-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_031475.txt_5860", "IMAGES-011-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_031477.txt_3860", "IMAGES-011-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_031478.txt_19997", "IMAGES-011-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_031479.txt_20372", "IMAGES-011-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_031482.txt_24890", "IMAGES-011-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_031483.txt_25079", "IMAGES-011-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_031484.txt_21773", "IMAGES-011-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_031486.txt_20217", "IMAGES-011-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_031487.txt_20154"]


canonical_name [F2d]: Fethullah Gulen
relationship_description [F3]:
  Insufficient context to determine relationship.

  The email excerpts show communications between Will Bohlen, Keough, and others sharing news articles about Fethullah Gulen and Turkey's extradition demands following a failed coup attempt. While there is one email fragment showing Reid Weingarten sending something to "jeffrey E." at an email address, there is no substantive content or clear context establishing the nature of any relationship between Gulen and Jeffrey Epstein.

discussion_ids:
  ["IMAGES-011-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_031472.txt_2317", "IMAGES-011-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_031473.txt_2606", "IMAGES-011-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_031474.txt_5512", "IMAGES-011-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_031480.txt_23431", "IMAGES-011-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_031483.txt_25079", "IMAGES-011-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_031484.txt_21773"]


canonical_name [F2d]: Michael A. Keough
relationship_description [F3]:
  Insufficient context to determine relationship.

  The email excerpts provided do not contain any correspondence between Michael A. Keough and Jeffrey Epstein, nor do they mention Jeffrey Epstein in any context related to Keough. The emails appear to focus on legal representation of Turkish cleric Fethullah Gulen, while only one email shows Jeffrey Epstein's email address as a recipient in a separate correspondence from Reid Weingarten.

discussion_ids:
  ["IMAGES-011-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_031472.txt_2317", "IMAGES-011-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_031473.txt_2606", "IMAGES-011-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_031474.txt_5512", "IMAGES-011-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_031475.txt_5860", "IMAGES-011-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_031477.txt_3860", "IMAGES-011-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_031478.txt_19997", "IMAGES-011-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_031482.txt_24890", "IMAGES-011-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_031483.txt_25079", "IMAGES-011-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_031484.txt_21773", "IMAGES-011-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_031486.txt_20217", "IMAGES-011-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_031487.txt_20154", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_031472.txt_24560"]


canonical_name [F2d]: William Drake
relationship_description [F3]:
  Insufficient context to determine relationship.

  The email excerpts provided do not contain any meaningful content about William Drake's relationship with Jeffrey Epstein. The emails primarily discuss Turkish cleric Fethullah Gulen's legal situation and media coverage, with only fragmentary headers showing Jeffrey Epstein's email address without any substantive communication content.

discussion_ids:
  ["IMAGES-011-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_031472.txt_2317", "IMAGES-011-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_031474.txt_5512", "IMAGES-011-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_031475.txt_5860", "IMAGES-011-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_031478.txt_19997", "IMAGES-011-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_031482.txt_24890", "IMAGES-011-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_031483.txt_25079", "IMAGES-011-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_031484.txt_21773", "IMAGES-011-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_031486.txt_20217", "IMAGES-011-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_031487.txt_20154", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_031472.txt_24560"]


canonical_name [F2d]: William Carlos Williams
relationship_description [F3]:
  I notice there's a discrepancy in your request. You ask about William Carlos Williams' relationship with Jeffrey Epstein, but William Carlos Williams was a poet who died in 1963, decades before these emails were written. 

  The emails actually discuss a video project about Williams' poem "This Is Just to Say" involving Woody Allen, with Jeffrey Epstein apparently facilitating the filming. The emails show Epstein had a professional/social relationship with the filmmakers, helping arrange access to Allen for the poetry project, though Allen's legal team ultimately blocked the footage's use.

  If you meant to ask about a different person's relationship with Epstein from these emails, please clarify.

discussion_ids:
  ["IMAGES-010-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_028957.txt_23070", "IMAGES-010-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_029251.txt_21264", "IMAGES-010-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_029253.txt_20739", "IMAGES-010-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_029839.txt_15301", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_023202.txt_19202", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_028955.txt_12521", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_028957.txt_10132", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_029251.txt_8476", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_029253.txt_7723", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_029839.txt_2325"]


canonical_name [F2d]: Benjamin Harnwell
relationship_description [F3]:
  Insufficient context to determine relationship.

  The email excerpts show Benjamin Harnwell sending news articles about Steve Bannon's European political activities, but there is no direct communication or interaction between Harnwell and Jeffrey Epstein visible in these exchanges. The connection between Harnwell and Epstein cannot be determined from the provided material.

discussion_ids:
  ["IMAGES-005-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_019302.txt_20096", "IMAGES-005-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_019303.txt_20249", "IMAGES-005-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_019305.txt_23407", "IMAGES-005-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_019312.txt_25024", "IMAGES-005-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_019317.txt_20279", "IMAGES-005-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_019334.txt_2375", "IMAGES-005-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_019339.txt_23452", "IMAGES-005-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_019344.txt_12173", "IMAGES-005-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_020440.txt_14529", "IMAGES-005-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_020442.txt_14478", "IMAGES-010-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_029021.txt_16126", "IMAGES-010-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_029042.txt_22593", "IMAGES-010-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_029063.txt_3269", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_019302.txt_22779", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_019305.txt_20713", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_019308.txt_5119", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_019312.txt_22297", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_019316.txt_22812", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_019334.txt_5072", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_029021.txt_3368"]


canonical_name [F2d]: Giulio Tononi
relationship_description [F3]:
  Based on the provided email excerpts, there is insufficient context to determine a direct relationship between Giulio Tononi and Jeffrey Epstein. The emails are from Robert Kuhn to Jeffrey Epstein, and Tononi is only mentioned as Kuhn's friend and contributor to Kuhn's "Closer To Truth" program who has invited Kuhn to visit his lab in Madison. No direct interaction or relationship between Tononi and Epstein is evident from these communications.

discussion_ids:
  ["IMAGES-008-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_026057.txt_13615", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_026057.txt_19930", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_029117.txt_16834", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_029122.txt_10479", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_029126.txt_8909", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_029131.txt_7303", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_029143.txt_5794", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_029150.txt_2421"]


canonical_name [F2d]: Andrew Grossman
relationship_description [F3]:
  Insufficient context to determine relationship.

  The email excerpts show Andrew Grossman communicating with David Rivkin about a Wall Street Journal op-ed regarding the Mueller investigation, and there are separate emails between Jeffrey Epstein (using jeevacation@gmail.com) and Steve Bannon/Kathy Ruemmler about legal matters. However, there are no direct communications or clear connections shown between Andrew Grossman and Jeffrey Epstein in these excerpts.

discussion_ids:
  ["IMAGES-008-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_026273.txt_10789", "IMAGES-008-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_026278.txt_18291", "IMAGES-008-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_026280.txt_15720", "IMAGES-008-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_026286.txt_18897", "IMAGES-009-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_026477.txt_2432", "IMAGES-009-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_026482.txt_20035", "IMAGES-009-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_026484.txt_23209", "IMAGES-009-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_026490.txt_23178", "IMAGES-009-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_026491.txt_23535", "IMAGES-009-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_026497.txt_20292", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_026273.txt_4129", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_026280.txt_21928", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_026477.txt_5002", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_026484.txt_19417", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_026491.txt_20914"]


canonical_name [F2d]: Elizabeth Price Foley
relationship_description [F3]:
  Insufficient context to determine relationship.

  The email excerpts show Elizabeth Price Foley only as a co-author of a Wall Street Journal op-ed about Robert Mueller's investigation, with no direct communication between her and Jeffrey Epstein. The emails appear to be forwarding or discussing this published article rather than revealing any personal or professional relationship between Foley and Epstein.

discussion_ids:
  ["IMAGES-008-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_026273.txt_10789", "IMAGES-009-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_026477.txt_2432", "IMAGES-009-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_026484.txt_23209", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_026273.txt_4129", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_026280.txt_21928"]


canonical_name [F2d]: Anders Corr
relationship_description [F3]:
  Insufficient context to determine relationship.

  The email excerpts show Anders Corr sending news articles about China-Iran business ties, while the emails from "jeffrey E." are sent to Steve Bannon with links to water pump equipment. There is no direct communication between Anders Corr and Jeffrey Epstein visible in these excerpts, nor any content that establishes a relationship between them.

discussion_ids:
  ["IMAGES-010-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_030372.txt_15440", "IMAGES-010-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_030408.txt_8726", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_030372.txt_2458", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_030408.txt_21716"]


canonical_name [F2d]: Alex Acosta
relationship_description [F3]:
  Based on these email excerpts, Alex Acosta and Jeffrey Epstein had a legal relationship where Acosta served as the lead federal prosecutor handling Epstein's criminal case involving underage sex crimes. The emails indicate that Acosta gave Epstein a "ridiculously lenient sentence" through a controversial plea deal, despite having knowledge that the lead prosecutor in the case had previously been rebuked for mishandling another child sex case. The relationship appears to be the subject of ongoing legal and political scrutiny, with the emails discussing media coverage and potential hearings related to Acosta's prosecutorial decisions.

discussion_ids:
  ["IMAGES-006-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_021740.txt_23758", "IMAGES-007-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_022998.txt_3818", "IMAGES-007-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_023126.txt_23468", "IMAGES-010-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_030255.txt_4838", "IMAGES-010-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_030315.txt_23213", "IMAGES-010-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_030318.txt_2647", "IMAGES-011-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_030958.txt_5719", "IMAGES-011-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_030962.txt_2464", "IMAGES-011-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_030983.txt_20336", "IMAGES-011-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_031775.txt_11577", "IMAGES-011-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_031795.txt_17439", "IMAGES-011-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_032056.txt_11449", "IMAGES-012-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_032502.txt_4712", "IMAGES-012-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_032980.txt_6792", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_021113.txt_24524", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_021216.txt_13784", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_021740.txt_10316", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_022998.txt_20193", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_028801.txt_17995", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_030255.txt_17675", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_030315.txt_10459", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_030318.txt_15385", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_030958.txt_22298", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_030962.txt_25542", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_030983.txt_4480", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_031728.txt_20205", "TEXT-002-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_031774.txt_5275", "TEXT-002-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_032502.txt_20567"]


canonical_name [F2d]: Randy Schultz
relationship_description [F3]:
  Insufficient context to determine relationship.

  The provided email excerpts do not contain any direct communication from or to Randy Schultz, nor do they mention Randy Schultz in relation to Jeffrey Epstein. The emails are between Robert Grusky and Steve Bannon discussing Alex Acosta's handling of Epstein's case, and from an unidentified sender "J" to Steve Bannon with links and a question about Bill Barr.

discussion_ids:
  ["IMAGES-011-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_030958.txt_5719", "IMAGES-011-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_030962.txt_2464", "IMAGES-011-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_030983.txt_20336", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_030958.txt_22298", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_030962.txt_25542", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_030983.txt_4480"]


canonical_name [F2d]: Robert Grusky
relationship_description [F3]:
  Based on these email excerpts, Robert Grusky appears to have no direct personal or professional relationship with Jeffrey Epstein. The emails show Grusky sharing news articles about Epstein with Steve Bannon, specifically discussing Alex Acosta's lenient prosecution of Epstein's criminal case. The tone is critical of Epstein, referring to him as a "pedophile" and criticizing how he "bought his way out of" legal consequences.

discussion_ids:
  ["IMAGES-011-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_030958.txt_5719", "IMAGES-011-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_030962.txt_2464", "IMAGES-011-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_030983.txt_20336", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_030958.txt_22298", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_030962.txt_25542", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_030983.txt_4480"]


canonical_name [F2d]: Angelina Jolie
relationship_description [F3]:
  Insufficient context to determine relationship.

  The provided email excerpts do not contain any mention of Angelina Jolie or any communications involving her. The emails shown are between Boris Nikolic and Jeffrey Epstein regarding news articles about admired public figures, and one brief message from Epstein to Richard Kahn.

discussion_ids:
  ["IMAGES-006-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_022344.txt_7078", "IMAGES-011-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_031036.txt_14248", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_022344.txt_20624", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_028529.txt_2498"]


canonical_name [F2d]: Billy Graham
relationship_description [F3]:
  Insufficient context to determine relationship.

  The email excerpts only mention Billy Graham in passing as part of third-party news articles and polling data that were forwarded to Jeffrey Epstein. There is no evidence of direct communication, meetings, or any actual relationship between Billy Graham and Jeffrey Epstein in these materials.

discussion_ids:
  ["IMAGES-006-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_022344.txt_7078", "IMAGES-011-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_030863.txt_6695", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_022344.txt_20624", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_028529.txt_2498", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_030863.txt_16574"]


canonical_name [F2d]: George W. Bush
relationship_description [F3]:
  Insufficient context to determine relationship.

  The email excerpts provided do not contain any substantive information about a direct relationship between George W. Bush and Jeffrey Epstein. Bush is only mentioned in passing within news articles and surveys that reference multiple public figures, with no indication of personal interaction, business dealings, or any other form of relationship between the two individuals.

discussion_ids:
  ["IMAGES-002-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_013482.txt_9034", "IMAGES-006-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_022344.txt_7078", "IMAGES-008-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_026440.txt_17384", "IMAGES-009-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_026609.txt_13984", "IMAGES-011-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_031540.txt_17754", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_013482.txt_6604", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_022344.txt_20624", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_026440.txt_24032", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_026609.txt_17413", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_028529.txt_2498", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_031540.txt_7584", "TEXT-002-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_033329.txt_10385"]


canonical_name [F2d]: Oprah Winfrey
relationship_description [F3]:
  Insufficient context to determine relationship.

  The email excerpts provided do not contain any direct communication between Oprah Winfrey and Jeffrey Epstein, nor do they mention any specific interactions, meetings, or relationship between them. The only reference to Oprah appears to be in what seems like promotional material for a meditation program with Deepak Chopra, which has no apparent connection to Epstein.

discussion_ids:
  ["IMAGES-006-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_022344.txt_7078", "IMAGES-009-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_026788.txt_9484", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_022344.txt_20624", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_028529.txt_2498"]


canonical_name [F2d]: Adam Sandler
relationship_description [F3]:
  Insufficient context to determine relationship.

  The provided email excerpts do not contain any mention of Adam Sandler or any interactions between Adam Sandler and Jeffrey Epstein. The emails appear to be correspondence between Steven Pfeiffer, Peggy Siegal, and Jeffrey Epstein regarding donations and seating arrangements for the IFP Gotham Awards ceremony, but there is no reference to Adam Sandler in any of the exchanges.

discussion_ids:
  ["IMAGES-010-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_028502.txt_13908", "IMAGES-011-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_031297.txt_22400", "IMAGES-011-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_031323.txt_20319", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_026228.txt_8828", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_028501.txt_2521", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_030679.txt_17196"]


canonical_name [F2d]: Dustin Hoffman
relationship_description [F3]:
  Insufficient context to determine relationship.

  The email excerpts show Jeffrey Epstein purchasing seats ($10,000 worth) at an IFP Gotham Awards ceremony where Dustin Hoffman was receiving an Actor Tribute, but there is no direct communication between Epstein and Hoffman, nor any indication of their relationship beyond both being involved in this awards event.

discussion_ids:
  ["IMAGES-010-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_028502.txt_13908", "IMAGES-011-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_030680.txt_11227", "IMAGES-011-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_031297.txt_22400", "IMAGES-011-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_031323.txt_20319", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_026228.txt_8828", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_028501.txt_2521", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_030679.txt_17196"]


canonical_name [F2d]: Ed Lachman
relationship_description [F3]:
  Insufficient context to determine relationship.

  The email excerpts do not mention or involve Ed Lachman. The correspondence is between Jeffrey Epstein, Peggy Siegal (a publicist), and Steven Pfeiffer regarding Epstein's sponsorship and attendance at the IFP Gotham Awards ceremony, where Epstein agreed to purchase $10,000 worth of seats for the event.

discussion_ids:
  ["IMAGES-010-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_028502.txt_13908", "IMAGES-011-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_030680.txt_11227", "IMAGES-011-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_031297.txt_22400", "IMAGES-011-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_031323.txt_20319", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_026228.txt_8828", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_028501.txt_2521", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_030679.txt_17196"]


canonical_name [F2d]: Jason Blum
relationship_description [F3]:
  Insufficient context to determine relationship.

  The email excerpts do not contain any correspondence involving Jason Blum. The emails show Jeffrey Epstein communicating with Peggy Siegal (an events coordinator) and Steven Pfeiffer regarding attendance and sponsorship of the IFP Gotham Awards ceremony, but Jason Blum is not mentioned or involved in any of these exchanges.

discussion_ids:
  ["IMAGES-010-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_028502.txt_13908", "IMAGES-011-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_030680.txt_11227", "IMAGES-011-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_031297.txt_22400", "IMAGES-011-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_031323.txt_20319", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_026228.txt_8828", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_028501.txt_2521", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_030679.txt_17196"]


canonical_name [F2d]: Nicole Kidman
relationship_description [F3]:
  Insufficient context to determine relationship.

  The emails only show that Jeffrey Epstein purchased seats at the IFP Gotham Awards ceremony where Nicole Kidman was receiving an Actress Tribute, but there is no direct communication between Kidman and Epstein or any indication of a personal or professional relationship between them. The emails demonstrate Epstein's attendance at an industry event where Kidman was being honored, but do not establish any connection beyond that circumstance.

discussion_ids:
[cell repeats an earlier one in this file: 321 characters]


canonical_name [F2d]: Robert Pattinson
relationship_description [F3]:
  Insufficient context to determine relationship.

  The email excerpts provided involve Jeffrey Epstein purchasing tickets/sponsorship for the IFP Gotham Awards ceremony through publicist Peggy Siegal's company, but contain no mention of Robert Pattinson or any direct interaction between Pattinson and Epstein.

discussion_ids:
  ["IMAGES-010-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_028502.txt_13908", "IMAGES-011-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_031297.txt_22400", "IMAGES-011-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_031323.txt_20319", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_026228.txt_8828", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_028501.txt_2521", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_030679.txt_17196"]


canonical_name [F2d]: Sofia Coppola
relationship_description [F3]:
  Insufficient context to determine relationship.

  The email excerpts mention that Sofia Coppola was receiving a Director Tribute at the IFP Gotham Awards ceremony, but there is no direct communication between Sofia Coppola and Jeffrey Epstein, nor any indication of their relationship type or interactions. The emails only show Epstein's involvement as a sponsor/attendee of the awards event where Coppola was being honored.

discussion_ids:
[cell repeats an earlier one in this file: 321 characters]


canonical_name [F2d]: Willem Dafoe
relationship_description [F3]:
  I cannot provide a description of Willem Dafoe's relationship with Jeffrey Epstein based on these email excerpts, as Willem Dafoe is not mentioned anywhere in the provided emails. The emails appear to be correspondence between Steven Pfeiffer, Peggy Siegal, and Jeffrey Epstein regarding donations and seating arrangements for the IFP Gotham Awards ceremony, but contain no references to Willem Dafoe.

discussion_ids:
  ["IMAGES-010-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_028502.txt_13908", "IMAGES-011-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_031297.txt_22400", "IMAGES-011-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_031323.txt_20319", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_026228.txt_8828", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_028501.txt_2521", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_030679.txt_17196"]


canonical_name [F2d]: Sean Parker
relationship_description [F3]:
  Insufficient context to determine relationship.

  The email excerpts do not contain any direct interactions between Sean Parker and Jeffrey Epstein. The emails shown are primarily invitations to social events forwarded to Epstein and other communications that don't establish the nature, context, or tone of any relationship between Parker and Epstein specifically.

discussion_ids:
  ["IMAGES-007-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_023454.txt_24678", "IMAGES-007-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_023545.txt_14863", "IMAGES-007-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_023548.txt_11028", "IMAGES-010-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_029852.txt_2555", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_023548.txt_13121"]


canonical_name [F2d]: Ari Emanuel
relationship_description [F3]:
  Insufficient context to determine relationship.

  The provided email excerpts do not contain any communication to, from, or mentioning Ari Emanuel. The emails shown are between Jeffrey Epstein and Steve Bannon, with one message to someone named Weingarten, but there is no content involving Ari Emanuel that would allow me to characterize their relationship.

discussion_ids:
  ["IMAGES-005-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_019321.txt_2556", "IMAGES-005-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_019338.txt_23262", "IMAGES-005-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_019343.txt_8795", "IMAGES-008-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_026243.txt_15629"]


canonical_name [F2d]: David Brooks
relationship_description [F3]:
  Insufficient context to determine relationship.

  The email excerpts do not contain any direct correspondence between David Brooks and Jeffrey Epstein, nor do they provide substantive details about their relationship. The only reference to David Brooks is a single line from Kathy Ruemmler asking Epstein "Did you read David Brooks today?" - likely referring to a newspaper column or article, which provides no information about the nature of any relationship between Brooks and Epstein.

discussion_ids:
  ["IMAGES-007-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_023198.txt_12280", "IMAGES-007-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_023202.txt_8479", "IMAGES-007-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_023205.txt_12650", "IMAGES-007-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_023418.txt_15617", "IMAGES-007-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_023426.txt_13505", "IMAGES-007-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_023427.txt_13929", "IMAGES-007-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_023429.txt_10327", "IMAGES-007-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_023431.txt_15092", "IMAGES-007-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_023440.txt_24703", "IMAGES-007-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_023448.txt_5948", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_023198.txt_14939", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_023202.txt_19202", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_023205.txt_14608", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_023418.txt_12069", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_023426.txt_10602", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_023427.txt_10503", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_023429.txt_13754", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_023431.txt_12215", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_023433.txt_10512", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_023440.txt_2568", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_023448.txt_21770"]


canonical_name [F2d]: Peter Mandelson
relationship_description [F3]:
  Based on the email excerpts, Peter Mandelson and Jeffrey Epstein appear to have had a personal social relationship involving informal communications about political figures and mutual acquaintances. The exchanges show casual, familiar conversation including discussions about Donald Trump, Prince Andrew, and advice about personal associations, with Epstein noting Mandelson was "right about staying away from andrew." The tone suggests they were comfortable enough to exchange personal opinions and advice, though the specific nature and extent of their relationship cannot be fully determined from these limited excerpts.

discussion_ids:
  ["IMAGES-006-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_021231.txt_22739", "IMAGES-010-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_029914.txt_24310", "IMAGES-010-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_029981.txt_11452", "IMAGES-010-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_030096.txt_5204", "IMAGES-010-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_030456.txt_2586", "IMAGES-010-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_030458.txt_24857", "IMAGES-011-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_030486.txt_8390", "IMAGES-011-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_030516.txt_18225", "IMAGES-011-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_030528.txt_17350", "IMAGES-012-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_032899.txt_23653", "IMAGES-012-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_033184.txt_3331", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_026632.txt_13297", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_029914.txt_11425", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_029981.txt_24345", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_030456.txt_15317", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_030458.txt_12153", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_030486.txt_18399", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_030516.txt_8252", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_030528.txt_7938", "TEXT-002-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_032899.txt_1618", "TEXT-002-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_033184.txt_19936"]


canonical_name [F2d]: Bilbo Baggins
relationship_description [F3]:
  I cannot provide a description of the relationship between Bilbo Baggins and Jeffrey Epstein because Bilbo Baggins does not appear anywhere in these email excerpts. The emails shown are from Jeffrey Epstein to recipients like "Jean Luc Brune" and others, discussing what appears to be his response to allegations against him, but there is no mention of or correspondence with anyone named Bilbo Baggins.

discussion_ids:
  ["IMAGES-006-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_021823.txt_2790", "IMAGES-006-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_022202.txt_17456", "IMAGES-010-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_029975.txt_17574", "IMAGES-011-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_031301.txt_2589", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_021823.txt_14731", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_022202.txt_3749", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_029975.txt_4781", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_031301.txt_25452"]


canonical_name [F2d]: Jean Luc Brunel
relationship_description [F3]:
  Based on these email excerpts, Jean Luc Brunel and Jeffrey Epstein appear to have had a professional relationship connected to the modeling industry, with Brunel operating MC2 modeling agency while facing legal challenges that involved depositions and required psychological counseling. The emails suggest both men were involved in coordinating international travel for models, with communications about arranging tickets and transportation for groups of women between locations like Ibiza, Paris, and Barcelona. The tone indicates an ongoing business partnership that was under significant legal and media scrutiny, with references to "drama in the press" and cancelled depositions suggesting both were facing similar legal troubles.

discussion_ids:
  ["IMAGES-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_011959.txt_15391", "IMAGES-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_011960.txt_17051", "IMAGES-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_011961.txt_16841", "IMAGES-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_011962.txt_18482", "IMAGES-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_011964.txt_15255", "IMAGES-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_012019.txt_6052", "IMAGES-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_012022.txt_2134", "IMAGES-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_012023.txt_2788", "IMAGES-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_012035.txt_500", "IMAGES-009-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_027059.txt_15285", "IMAGES-010-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_030152.txt_7650", "IMAGES-010-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_030154.txt_10947", "IMAGES-010-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_030470.txt_24807", "IMAGES-011-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_030519.txt_8560", "IMAGES-011-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_031177.txt_7629", "IMAGES-011-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_031301.txt_2589", "IMAGES-011-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_031992.txt_10006", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_027059.txt_17849", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_030152.txt_20417", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_030154.txt_23618", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_030470.txt_12049", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_030519.txt_17921", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_031177.txt_17603", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_031301.txt_25452", "TEXT-002-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_031992.txt_4394"]


canonical_name [F2d]: Michael Bloomberg
relationship_description [F3]:
  Insufficient context to determine relationship.

  The email excerpts show communications between Larry Summers and Jeffrey Epstein (jeevacation@gmail.com) discussing policy topics like government programs and ranked-choice voting, with Bloomberg only mentioned briefly in passing as an example of a centrist politician in a third-party academic discussion. There is no direct communication between Bloomberg and Epstein shown, nor any indication of a personal or professional relationship between them.

discussion_ids:
  ["IMAGES-009-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_026509.txt_19470", "IMAGES-010-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_030324.txt_2602", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_026321.txt_19512", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_026508.txt_23378", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_030324.txt_15341"]


canonical_name [F2d]: Jason Weinstein
relationship_description [F3]:
  Insufficient context to determine relationship.

  The email excerpts provided do not contain any meaningful content about Jason Weinstein's relationship with Jeffrey Epstein. While there is one email line showing Reid Weingarten sending something to Jeffrey Epstein's email address, there is no actual content, context, or involvement from Jason Weinstein in any of the email exchanges shown. The majority of the emails appear to concern Turkish cleric Fethullah Gulen and media/legal strategy discussions unrelated to Epstein.

discussion_ids:
  ["IMAGES-011-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_031473.txt_2606", "IMAGES-011-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_031477.txt_3860", "IMAGES-011-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_031483.txt_25079", "IMAGES-011-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_031486.txt_20217", "IMAGES-011-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_031487.txt_20154", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_031472.txt_24560"]


canonical_name [F2d]: Kathryn King
relationship_description [F3]:
  Insufficient context to determine relationship.

  The email excerpts provided do not contain any substantive content involving Kathryn King and Jeffrey Epstein. While Jeffrey Epstein's email address appears in one email header from Reid Weingarten, there is no message content or context provided that would indicate the nature of any relationship between King and Epstein.

discussion_ids:
  ["IMAGES-011-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_031473.txt_2606", "IMAGES-011-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_031477.txt_3860", "IMAGES-011-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_031478.txt_19997", "IMAGES-011-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_031479.txt_20372", "IMAGES-011-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_031482.txt_24890", "IMAGES-011-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_031486.txt_20217", "IMAGES-011-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_031487.txt_20154", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_031472.txt_24560"]


canonical_name [F2d]: Michael Cohen
relationship_description [F3]:
  Based on these email excerpts, there appears to be no direct relationship between Michael Cohen and Jeffrey Epstein. The emails show third parties (Nicholas Ribis, Reid Weingarten, and Richard Kahn) forwarding news articles about Cohen's legal troubles and cooperation with prosecutors to Epstein, suggesting Epstein was receiving updates about Cohen's situation rather than communicating with him directly. The context appears to be informational rather than indicating any personal, professional, or legal relationship between Cohen and Epstein themselves.

discussion_ids:
  ["IMAGES-005-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_020437.txt_21011", "IMAGES-012-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_032798.txt_8333", "IMAGES-012-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_033107.txt_19203", "TEXT-002-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_032050.txt_2628", "TEXT-002-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_032796.txt_9010", "TEXT-002-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_033107.txt_9261"]


canonical_name [F2d]: Marvin Davis
relationship_description [F3]:
  Insufficient context to determine relationship.

  The email excerpts mention "Davis" in two separate contexts - Nicholas Ribis refers to someone named Davis issuing a report about Leon/board and Caesars, while Noam Chomsky discusses a different Davis regarding employment conditions. However, neither email chain provides clear information about the nature, context, or tone of any direct relationship between Marvin Davis and Jeffrey Epstein.

discussion_ids:
  ["IMAGES-006-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_022443.txt_2656", "IMAGES-010-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_028934.txt_16616", "IMAGES-010-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_028940.txt_24689", "IMAGES-010-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_029235.txt_19161", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_022443.txt_14869"]


canonical_name [F2d]: Chuck Schumer
relationship_description [F3]:
  Insufficient context to determine relationship.

  The email excerpts only contain Chuck Schumer's name in two contexts: once in a casual political discussion between third parties about Trump potentially reaching out to Schumer, and once in what appears to be a contact list. There is no direct communication between Schumer and Epstein, nor any substantive information about the nature or extent of any relationship they may have had.

discussion_ids:
  ["IMAGES-008-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_026074.txt_8974", "IMAGES-009-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_026632.txt_16612", "IMAGES-010-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_029622.txt_15184", "IMAGES-010-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_029963.txt_17948", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_026074.txt_2658", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_026632.txt_13297"]


canonical_name [F2d]: Gary Cohn
relationship_description [F3]:
  Insufficient context to determine relationship.

  The email excerpts show various people discussing Gary Cohn with Jeffrey Epstein, but they don't reveal any direct relationship between Cohn and Epstein themselves. The references to Cohn appear to be third-party commentary about his role in the Trump administration, including discussions of his political position, potential departure, and replacement by Larry Kudlow.

discussion_ids:
  ["IMAGES-008-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_025195.txt_11580", "IMAGES-008-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_026074.txt_8974", "IMAGES-008-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_026311.txt_11759", "IMAGES-012-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_033226.txt_5462", "IMAGES-012-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_033276.txt_15019", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_025195.txt_4917", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_026074.txt_2658", "TEXT-002-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_033276.txt_11381"]


canonical_name [F2d]: Nathan Myhrvold
relationship_description [F3]:
  Insufficient context to determine relationship.

  The email excerpts only show Nathan Myhrvold's name appearing on what appears to be guest lists for seminars organized by or for Jeffrey Epstein (labeled "Seminar-MONEY"), alongside other prominent technology and business figures. There is no direct communication between Myhrvold and Epstein, nor any indication of the nature or extent of their relationship beyond Myhrvold potentially being considered for or invited to these events.

discussion_ids:
  ["IMAGES-007-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_023454.txt_24678", "IMAGES-008-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_026074.txt_8974", "IMAGES-009-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_026549.txt_9596", "IMAGES-010-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_028784.txt_5939", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_026074.txt_2658", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_026549.txt_12202", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_028784.txt_18916"]


canonical_name [F2d]: Glenn Simpson
relationship_description [F3]:
  Insufficient context to determine relationship.

  The email excerpts show that Reid Weingarten (who appears to be Epstein's attorney) mentions knowing Glenn Simpson "very well" and references "weird connections" that he wants to discuss in person. However, the emails don't provide any direct communication between Epstein and Simpson, nor do they specify the nature, context, or extent of any relationship between them.

discussion_ids:
  ["IMAGES-011-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_030773.txt_20345", "IMAGES-012-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_032671.txt_2662", "IMAGES-012-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_033052.txt_12213", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_030683.txt_15662", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_030684.txt_18181", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_030770.txt_6180", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_030771.txt_5209", "TEXT-002-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_032671.txt_25746", "TEXT-002-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_033052.txt_15861"]


canonical_name [F2d]: Patrick M. Regan
relationship_description [F3]:
  Insufficient context to determine relationship.

  The provided email excerpts do not contain any communications involving Patrick M. Regan, nor do they provide substantive content about relationships between the parties mentioned (Jeffrey E., Weingarten, and Melanie Spinella).

discussion_ids:
  ["IMAGES-003-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_015015.txt_19661", "IMAGES-004-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_017590.txt_2821", "IMAGES-007-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_023314.txt_2664", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_015002.txt_17708"]


canonical_name [F2d]: Nathan Wolf
relationship_description [F3]:
  Insufficient context to determine relationship.

  The email excerpts provided are between Jeffrey Epstein and Boris Nikolic, not Nathan Wolf. The emails show casual social communication between Epstein and Nikolic, but contain no mentions of or correspondence with Nathan Wolf.

discussion_ids:
  ["IMAGES-011-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_030495.txt_12598", "IMAGES-011-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_030498.txt_13291", "IMAGES-011-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_030503.txt_18914", "IMAGES-011-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_030603.txt_24237", "IMAGES-011-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_030609.txt_3289", "IMAGES-011-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_030612.txt_19363", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_030493.txt_18742", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_030495.txt_15422", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_030498.txt_10386", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_030502.txt_8269", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_030602.txt_2693", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_030606.txt_3740", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_030609.txt_19883", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_030612.txt_3783"]


canonical_name [F2d]: Azeen Ghorayshi
relationship_description [F3]:
  Insufficient context to determine relationship.

  The email excerpts provided do not contain any communications involving Azeen Ghorayshi. All the emails shown are between journalists (Peter Aldhous, Virginia Hughes) investigating sexual misconduct allegations against Lawrence Krauss, with one email from someone identified as "Jeffrey E." offering advice to Krauss about media strategy. There is no mention of or correspondence with Azeen Ghorayshi in any of these excerpts.

discussion_ids:
  ["IMAGES-006-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_021420.txt_24990", "IMAGES-009-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_026775.txt_6867", "IMAGES-011-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_031234.txt_14463", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_021425.txt_7940", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_031233.txt_7003", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_031239.txt_15081", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_031246.txt_2748", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_031255.txt_5440", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_031263.txt_23135"]


canonical_name [F2d]: Virginia Hughes
relationship_description [F3]:
  Insufficient context to determine relationship.

  The email excerpts provided do not contain any correspondence involving Virginia Hughes. While there is one mention of Virginia Hughes submitting a contact form message to Sam Harris regarding a BuzzFeed News investigation into Lawrence Krauss, this only indicates she was working as a journalist on that story. The emails primarily consist of correspondence between BuzzFeed reporter Peter Aldhous and Lawrence Krauss about sexual misconduct allegations, with no direct communication from or meaningful references to Virginia Hughes that would clarify any relationship with Jeffrey Epstein.

discussion_ids:
  ["IMAGES-006-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_021420.txt_24990", "IMAGES-009-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_026775.txt_6867", "IMAGES-011-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_031234.txt_14463", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_021425.txt_7940", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_031233.txt_7003", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_031239.txt_15081", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_031246.txt_2748", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_031255.txt_5440", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_031263.txt_23135"]


canonical_name [F2d]: David Schoen
relationship_description [F3]:
  Based on these email excerpts, David Schoen appears to have had a professional legal relationship with Jeffrey Epstein, likely serving as his attorney or legal counsel. The emails show Schoen regularly updating Epstein on media coverage of his legal cases, discussing settlement outcomes, and referencing legal matters including the Non-Prosecution Agreement (NPA) and various civil lawsuits. The tone suggests an ongoing attorney-client relationship, with Schoen providing legal updates, expressing hope for favorable outcomes for Epstein, and defending him against what he characterizes as unfair media coverage.

discussion_ids:
  ["IMAGES-008-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_026288.txt_8556", "IMAGES-008-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_026291.txt_17293", "IMAGES-011-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_031339.txt_3922", "IMAGES-011-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_031344.txt_18367", "IMAGES-011-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_031492.txt_20186", "IMAGES-011-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_031493.txt_20165", "IMAGES-011-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_031494.txt_23457", "IMAGES-011-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_031560.txt_9745", "IMAGES-011-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_031561.txt_11369", "IMAGES-011-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_031775.txt_11577", "IMAGES-011-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_031798.txt_8393", "IMAGES-011-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_031802.txt_13426", "IMAGES-011-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_031803.txt_14035", "IMAGES-011-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_031823.txt_7011", "IMAGES-011-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_031824.txt_10783", "IMAGES-011-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_031825.txt_10329", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_026287.txt_24816", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_026290.txt_23191", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_031339.txt_19724", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_031344.txt_8407", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_031492.txt_4602", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_031560.txt_13465", "TEXT-002-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_031775.txt_6085", "TEXT-002-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_031798.txt_2760", "TEXT-002-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_031802.txt_20692", "TEXT-002-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_031803.txt_19673", "TEXT-002-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_031823.txt_1345", "TEXT-002-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_031824.txt_3650", "TEXT-002-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_031825.txt_4471"]


canonical_name [F2d]: Nima Mohebbi
relationship_description [F3]:
  Based on the email excerpt, Nima Mohebbi appears to have a professional relationship with Jeffrey Epstein's legal team, likely working as a legal professional or consultant. The context suggests Nima was involved in providing case documents and legal insights for what appears to be a significant litigation matter involving a Middle Eastern bank that resulted in a favorable verdict. The tone indicates a collaborative professional relationship where Nima was thanked for their contributions to the case strategy or documentation.

discussion_ids:
  ["IMAGES-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_012037.txt_2791", "IMAGES-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_012038.txt_25349", "IMAGES-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_012040.txt_9244", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_012037.txt_17742", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_030098.txt_9481"]


canonical_name [F2d]: Denyse Sabagh
relationship_description [F3]:
  Insufficient context to determine relationship.

  The email excerpts provided do not contain any direct communication between Denyse Sabagh and Jeffrey Epstein, nor do they reference Denyse Sabagh in any way. The emails appear to be between Jeffrey Epstein and someone named Weingarten, with minimal content that doesn't provide insight into any relationship with Denyse Sabagh.

discussion_ids:
  ["IMAGES-003-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_015015.txt_19661", "IMAGES-004-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_017590.txt_2821", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_015002.txt_17708", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_017590.txt_9190"]


canonical_name [F2d]: Ellen Kerns
relationship_description [F3]:
  Insufficient context to determine relationship.

  The email excerpts provided do not contain any correspondence with or mention of Ellen Kerns, so no relationship between Ellen Kerns and Jeffrey Epstein can be determined from these materials.

discussion_ids:
  ["IMAGES-003-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_015015.txt_19661", "IMAGES-004-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_017590.txt_2821", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_015002.txt_17708", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_017590.txt_9190"]


canonical_name [F2d]: Katie Beckler
relationship_description [F3]:
  Insufficient context to determine relationship.

  The email excerpts do not contain any direct communication between Katie Beckler and Jeffrey Epstein. The only mention of Katie Beckler appears in what seems to be an incomplete, potentially threatening message to someone named Rich Beckler, but this does not provide clear information about any actual relationship between Katie Beckler and Epstein.

discussion_ids:
  ["IMAGES-003-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_015002.txt_21284", "IMAGES-003-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_015015.txt_19661", "IMAGES-004-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_017590.txt_2821", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_015002.txt_17708", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_015015.txt_19304", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_017590.txt_9190"]


canonical_name [F2d]: Rich Beckler
relationship_description [F3]:
  Insufficient context to determine relationship.

  The email excerpts provided do not contain enough information to characterize Rich Beckler's relationship with Jeffrey Epstein. While there is one email fragment mentioning Rich Beckler that references his daughters and makes an unsubstantiated comparison to Ghislaine Maxwell, this appears to be from an incomplete, potentially unreliable source and does not establish any clear professional, social, or legal relationship between Beckler and Epstein.

discussion_ids:
  ["IMAGES-003-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_015002.txt_21284", "IMAGES-003-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_015015.txt_19661", "IMAGES-004-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_017590.txt_2821", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_015002.txt_17708", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_015015.txt_19304", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_017590.txt_9190"]


canonical_name [F2d]: Robert Barnett
relationship_description [F3]:
  Insufficient context to determine relationship.

  The email excerpts provided do not contain any direct correspondence between Robert Barnett and Jeffrey Epstein, nor do they provide substantive content about their interactions or relationship nature. The emails appear to involve someone named Weingarten rather than Barnett, and contain minimal content that would indicate the type or context of any relationship.

discussion_ids:
  ["IMAGES-003-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_015015.txt_19661", "IMAGES-004-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_017590.txt_2821", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_015002.txt_17708", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_017590.txt_9190"]


canonical_name [F2d]: Brad Bowen
relationship_description [F3]:
  Insufficient context to determine relationship.

  The email excerpts provided do not contain any communication between Brad Bowen and Jeffrey Epstein, nor do they mention Jeffrey Epstein in any context. The emails appear to focus on political discussions about Trump and other political figures, with Brad Bowen only appearing as a sender in one brief message about Trump being a "problem solver."

discussion_ids:
  ["IMAGES-008-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_025913.txt_2839", "IMAGES-008-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_025920.txt_25347", "IMAGES-008-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_025928.txt_5294", "IMAGES-008-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_025929.txt_6061", "IMAGES-011-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_031699.txt_1130", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_025911.txt_7169", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_031699.txt_24118"]


canonical_name [F2d]: Coy Garrett
relationship_description [F3]:
  Insufficient context to determine relationship.

  The provided email excerpts do not mention Coy Garrett or Jeffrey Epstein, nor do they contain any information about interactions between these individuals. The excerpts appear to be unrelated communications about political figures and other topics.

discussion_ids:
  ["IMAGES-008-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_025913.txt_2839", "IMAGES-008-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_025920.txt_25347", "IMAGES-008-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_025928.txt_5294", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_025911.txt_7169"]


canonical_name [F2d]: Ryan McIntosh
relationship_description [F3]:
  Insufficient context to determine relationship.

  The provided email excerpts do not mention Jeffrey Epstein or contain any interactions involving Ryan McIntosh that would indicate a relationship between McIntosh and Epstein. The emails appear to be unrelated correspondence about other topics and individuals.

discussion_ids:
  ["IMAGES-008-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_025913.txt_2839", "IMAGES-008-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_025920.txt_25347", "IMAGES-008-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_025928.txt_5294", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_025911.txt_7169"]


canonical_name [F2d]: Ehud Barak
relationship_description [F3]:
  Based on these email excerpts, Ehud Barak and Jeffrey Epstein appear to have had a close social and professional relationship. The emails show Epstein facilitating high-level meetings for Barak (including breakfasts with "Ariane Rothschild" and a "Kissinger China guy"), while Barak kept Epstein informed about his travel plans to New York for biography work and shared political insights about appointments and Bill Clinton. The casual tone, use of "Jeff" and "EB," and the nature of their communications suggest they were confidants who regularly exchanged information about political matters and coordinated social engagements within elite circles.

discussion_ids:
  ["IMAGES-008-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_025878.txt_19641", "IMAGES-008-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_025893.txt_19664", "IMAGES-008-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_025898.txt_2893", "IMAGES-008-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_026354.txt_22261", "IMAGES-008-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_026355.txt_21295", "IMAGES-009-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_026618.txt_18803", "IMAGES-009-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_027032.txt_2545", "IMAGES-009-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_027034.txt_5685", "IMAGES-009-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_027099.txt_13584", "IMAGES-009-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_027126.txt_7946", "IMAGES-010-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_028485.txt_12747", "IMAGES-010-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_028486.txt_11244", "IMAGES-010-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_028531.txt_10704", "IMAGES-010-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_029981.txt_11452", "IMAGES-010-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_030383.txt_12082", "IMAGES-011-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_030571.txt_20558", "IMAGES-011-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_032239.txt_22308", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_025163.txt_24357", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_025878.txt_12950", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_025893.txt_13090", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_025898.txt_9628", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_026076.txt_591", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_026354.txt_15971", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_026355.txt_14661", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_026618.txt_15790", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_027032.txt_6310", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_027034.txt_3145", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_027099.txt_16167", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_028485.txt_25720", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_028486.txt_24085", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_028531.txt_23405", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_029981.txt_24345", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_030383.txt_24822", "TEXT-002-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_032239.txt_14973", "TEXT-002-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_032853.txt_20843"]


canonical_name [F2d]: Elisa New
relationship_description [F3]:
  Based on these email excerpts, Elisa New appears to have had a professional relationship with Jeffrey Epstein, likely related to her academic work involving literature or media programming. The exchanges suggest she may have hosted a show or educational program, as references are made to someone "appearing on your show" and her forwarding invitations. The tone seems collegial, with New offering book recommendations and Epstein providing what appears to be guidance about programming decisions, though the fragmentary nature of some messages makes the full context unclear.

discussion_ids:
  ["IMAGES-010-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_029566.txt_12707", "IMAGES-010-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_029573.txt_11576", "IMAGES-010-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_029578.txt_17495", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_029566.txt_25468", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_029569.txt_2931", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_029578.txt_4516"]


canonical_name [F2d]: Emmanuel Riva
relationship_description [F3]:
  Insufficient context to determine relationship.

  The provided email excerpts are from Peggy Siegal describing an Academy Awards ticket pickup event, and they do not mention Emmanuel Riva or Jeffrey Epstein. The emails appear to be incomplete narrative descriptions that cut off mid-sentence and do not contain any information about relationships between the requested individuals.

discussion_ids:
  ["IMAGES-005-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_019465.txt_20254", "IMAGES-011-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_031118.txt_25330", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_019465.txt_23938", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_031118.txt_3056"]


canonical_name [F2d]: Jessica Chastain
relationship_description [F3]:
  Insufficient context to determine relationship.

  The provided email excerpts do not mention Jessica Chastain or Jeffrey Epstein. The emails appear to be from Peggy Siegal describing an Oscar ticket pickup experience at the Academy of Motion Pictures Arts and Sciences, but the messages are incomplete and cut off mid-sentence.

discussion_ids:
  ["IMAGES-005-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_019465.txt_20254", "IMAGES-011-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_031118.txt_25330", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_019465.txt_23938", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_031118.txt_3056"]


canonical_name [F2d]: Norman Jewison
relationship_description [F3]:
  Insufficient context to determine relationship.

  The email excerpts provided do not mention Jeffrey Epstein at all. They only describe Norman Jewison (the distinguished director) waiting in line with Peggy Siegal at the Academy of Motion Pictures Arts and Sciences to pick up Oscar telecast tickets. There is no information about any relationship between Norman Jewison and Jeffrey Epstein in these particular email fragments.

discussion_ids:
  ["IMAGES-005-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_019465.txt_20254", "IMAGES-011-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_031118.txt_25330", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_019465.txt_23938", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_031118.txt_3056"]


canonical_name [F2d]: Paula Wagner
relationship_description [F3]:
  Insufficient context to determine relationship.

  The provided email excerpts are from Peggy Siegal to herself describing an Oscar ticket pickup event, and they do not mention Paula Wagner or Jeffrey Epstein at all. The emails appear to be incomplete narrative fragments about waiting in line at the Academy of Motion Pictures Arts and Sciences.

discussion_ids:
[cell repeats an earlier one in this file: 183 characters]


canonical_name [F2d]: Steven Spielberg
relationship_description [F3]:
  Insufficient context to determine relationship.

  The provided email excerpts do not mention Steven Spielberg or Jeffrey Epstein. The emails appear to be incomplete drafts from Peggy Siegal describing her experience picking up Oscar tickets at the Academy of Motion Pictures Arts and Sciences, but they cut off mid-sentence and contain no information about either Spielberg or Epstein's relationship.

discussion_ids:
[cell repeats an earlier one in this file: 183 characters]


canonical_name [F2d]: Tom Cruise
relationship_description [F3]:
  Insufficient context to determine relationship.

  The provided email excerpts appear to be incomplete fragments from Peggy Siegal describing Oscar ticket pickup, but they cut off mid-sentence and do not mention Tom Cruise or Jeffrey Epstein or any relationship between them.

discussion_ids:
[cell repeats an earlier one in this file: 183 characters]


canonical_name [F2d]: George H.W. Bush
relationship_description [F3]:
  Insufficient context to determine relationship.

  The email excerpts contain only passing references to George H.W. Bush in political contexts (mentions of his 1980 presidential campaign and political polling data), but provide no evidence of any direct relationship, communication, or interaction between Jeffrey Epstein and George H.W. Bush himself.

discussion_ids:
  ["IMAGES-003-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_015002.txt_21284", "IMAGES-008-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_026323.txt_15787", "IMAGES-008-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_026463.txt_11720", "IMAGES-009-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_026510.txt_6397", "IMAGES-010-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_029910.txt_20887", "IMAGES-010-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_030244.txt_3174", "IMAGES-011-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_030863.txt_6695", "IMAGES-011-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_030871.txt_9843", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_026321.txt_19512", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_026463.txt_4970", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_026508.txt_23378", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_030244.txt_15937", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_030266.txt_7925", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_030863.txt_16574"]


canonical_name [F2d]: Ronald Reagan
relationship_description [F3]:
  Insufficient context to determine relationship.

  The email excerpts only contain passing references to Ronald Reagan in historical or comparative contexts (such as mentioning Reagan's former staff members or comparing Trump to "Reagan 2.0"), but do not indicate any direct relationship or interactions between Jeffrey Epstein and Ronald Reagan himself.

discussion_ids:
  ["IMAGES-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_011277.txt_5313", "IMAGES-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_012044.txt_10158", "IMAGES-010-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_030244.txt_3174", "IMAGES-011-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_031159.txt_10887", "IMAGES-011-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_032369.txt_4425", "IMAGES-011-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_032370.txt_21426", "IMAGES-012-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_032915.txt_19586", "IMAGES-012-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_032916.txt_21212", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_025215.txt_24755", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_030244.txt_15937", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_031159.txt_14336", "TEXT-002-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_032369.txt_9947", "TEXT-002-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_032370.txt_15901", "TEXT-002-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_032915.txt_3945", "TEXT-002-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_032916.txt_5605", "TEXT-002-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_033197.txt_23644"]


canonical_name [F2d]: Gwendolyn Beck
relationship_description [F3]:
  Based on these email excerpts, Gwendolyn Beck appears to have had a personal friendship with Jeffrey Epstein that involved shared social and political circles in Washington D.C. The emails show her keeping him updated on political developments (particularly during the Trump era), mentioning mutual acquaintances like Tom McMillen who has connections to the Obamas, and discussing high-level social events like the Aspen Institute programs. The tone is casual and affectionate ("Miss you!" and "Love and Happiness"), suggesting they maintained regular contact and moved in similar elite political and social networks.

discussion_ids:
  ["IMAGES-010-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_029960.txt_16296", "IMAGES-010-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_029968.txt_11258", "IMAGES-010-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_029970.txt_16006", "IMAGES-011-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_031120.txt_19820", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_029960.txt_3299", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_029968.txt_24125", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_029970.txt_3210", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_031120.txt_3446"]


canonical_name [F2d]: Jim Costa
relationship_description [F3]:
  Based on these email excerpts, the relationship between Jim Costa and Jeffrey Epstein appears to be social/personal in nature, with the sender reaching out in a casual, friendly manner asking about Epstein's well-being and sharing political commentary about Trump and Washington politics. The tone suggests they had some form of ongoing contact, as the sender mentions calling Epstein and expresses uncertainty about having the correct phone number. However, the emails are incomplete and don't provide sufficient context to determine the depth, duration, or specific nature of their relationship beyond these apparently friendly communications.

discussion_ids:
  ["IMAGES-010-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_029969.txt_9837", "IMAGES-010-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_029970.txt_16006", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_029969.txt_22615", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_029970.txt_3210"]


canonical_name [F2d]: Jack Scarola
relationship_description [F3]:
  Based on these email excerpts, Jack Scarola appears to have had a professional legal relationship with Jeffrey Epstein as an opposing attorney representing alleged victims in civil litigation. The emails reference Scarola's involvement in legal cases (including correspondence with "The Duke of York"/Prince Andrew), access to deposition materials, and court filings related to Epstein matters. The tone suggests Scarola was acting as counsel against Epstein's interests rather than representing him.

discussion_ids:
  ["IMAGES-003-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_015580.txt_4811", "IMAGES-003-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_015584.txt_1659", "IMAGES-003-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_015585.txt_3235", "IMAGES-003-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_015614.txt_23592", "IMAGES-011-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_031384.txt_16871", "IMAGES-011-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_031388.txt_8812", "IMAGES-011-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_031392.txt_18648", "IMAGES-011-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_031399.txt_10540", "IMAGES-011-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_031403.txt_11970", "IMAGES-011-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_031428.txt_10393"]


canonical_name [F2d]: James E. Hill
relationship_description [F3]:
  Based on these email excerpts, James E. Hill appears to be an ABC News journalist who was professionally covering Jeffrey Epstein-related legal cases and allegations. The emails show Hill reaching out to various attorneys and representatives seeking statements and information about Epstein in connection with lawsuits involving Virginia Giuffre (Roberts) and Ghislaine Maxwell, including requests for responses to allegations that would be featured in ABC News broadcasts. This appears to be a standard journalist-subject relationship where Hill was reporting on Epstein's legal troubles rather than having any personal or business relationship with him.

discussion_ids:
  ["IMAGES-003-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_015585.txt_3235", "IMAGES-007-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_022766.txt_20468", "IMAGES-007-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_022768.txt_3768", "IMAGES-007-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_022927.txt_18942", "IMAGES-007-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_022930.txt_17341", "IMAGES-007-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_022932.txt_18158", "IMAGES-007-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_022941.txt_20520", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_022931.txt_7477", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_022941.txt_3906"]


canonical_name [F2d]: Alain Forget
relationship_description [F3]:
  Based on these email excerpts, Alain Forget and Jeffrey Epstein appear to have had a social or intellectual relationship involving the exchange of political commentary and analysis. The emails show Forget sharing news articles and political observations about Steve Bannon and global nationalist movements, seeking Epstein's perspective on these political developments. The tone suggests an informal correspondence where they discussed current events and political trends, though the limited context makes it difficult to determine the depth or full nature of their relationship.

discussion_ids:
  ["IMAGES-010-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_029021.txt_16126", "IMAGES-010-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_029042.txt_22593", "IMAGES-010-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_029063.txt_3269", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_029021.txt_3368", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_029042.txt_9817", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_029063.txt_16219"]


canonical_name [F2d]: Nirj Deva
relationship_description [F3]:
  Insufficient context to determine relationship.

  The provided email excerpts are from Alain Forget to Jeffrey E., discussing political topics related to Steve Bannon and nationalist movements, but contain no mention of Nirj Deva or any clear connection between the parties mentioned.

discussion_ids:
  ["IMAGES-010-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_029021.txt_16126", "IMAGES-010-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_029042.txt_22593", "IMAGES-010-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_029063.txt_3269", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_029021.txt_3368"]


canonical_name [F2d]: Irwin Corey
relationship_description [F3]:
  Insufficient context to determine relationship.

  The provided email excerpts discuss comedian Irwin Corey's death, his political views about Trump, and past performances, but make no mention of Jeffrey Epstein or any relationship between Corey and Epstein.

discussion_ids:
  ["IMAGES-010-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_030214.txt_19308", "IMAGES-012-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_033225.txt_3817", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_030214.txt_6384", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_030216.txt_3342", "TEXT-002-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_033225.txt_19442"]


canonical_name [F2d]: Jim Drougas
relationship_description [F3]:
  Insufficient context to determine relationship.

  The provided email excerpts discuss James Drougas's relationship with comedian Irwin Corey and his recent death, as well as Paul Krassner's memories of performing with Corey. There is no mention of Jeffrey Epstein in any of these emails.

discussion_ids:
  ["IMAGES-010-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_030214.txt_19308", "IMAGES-010-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_030216.txt_16149", "IMAGES-012-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_033225.txt_3817", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_030214.txt_6384", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_030216.txt_3342", "TEXT-002-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_033225.txt_19442"]


canonical_name [F2d]: Jonathan Victor
relationship_description [F3]:
  Based on these email excerpts, Jonathan Victor appears to have had a limited professional or academic connection with Jeffrey Epstein. David Grosof mentions that Victor "met a few years ago in your [Epstein's] office" and describes him as "powerfully thoughtful on the issues of neural coding" in the context of discussing scientific interests like "signal intelligence in biological systems." The relationship seems to have been brief and centered around Victor's expertise in neurophysiology, likely involving a single meeting at Epstein's office years prior to these email exchanges.

discussion_ids:
  ["IMAGES-008-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_025169.txt_10088", "IMAGES-008-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_025172.txt_13267", "IMAGES-010-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_029085.txt_22417", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_025169.txt_3386", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_025172.txt_19464", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_025176.txt_25646", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_029085.txt_9673"]


canonical_name [F2d]: Reese Jones
relationship_description [F3]:
  Insufficient context to determine relationship.

  The provided email excerpts do not contain any mentions of "Reese Jones" or interactions involving that individual. The emails shown are exchanges between Jeffrey E. (jeevacation@gmail.com) and David Grosof discussing academic topics like probability, statistics, neuroscience, and biological systems, but there is no reference to Reese Jones in any of the content provided.

discussion_ids:
  ["IMAGES-008-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_025169.txt_10088", "IMAGES-010-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_029085.txt_22417", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_025169.txt_3386", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_025172.txt_19464", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_025176.txt_25646", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_029085.txt_9673"]


canonical_name [F2d]: Jessica Joffe
relationship_description [F3]:
  Insufficient context to determine relationship.

  The email excerpts provided do not involve Jessica Joffe at all - they appear to be correspondence between someone named Gwendolyn (signing as "Gw") and Jeffrey Epstein. Without any emails actually involving Jessica Joffe, there is no information available to describe her relationship with Jeffrey Epstein.

discussion_ids:
  ["IMAGES-010-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_029968.txt_11258", "IMAGES-011-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_031120.txt_19820", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_029968.txt_24125", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_031120.txt_3446"]


canonical_name [F2d]: Tom McMillen
relationship_description [F3]:
  Based on these email excerpts, Tom McMillen and Jeffrey Epstein appear to have had a social relationship that had lapsed over time. McMillen specifically mentioned to a mutual contact (Gwendolyn) that he had "lost touch" with Epstein and was asking about him, suggesting they previously had some form of ongoing connection. The relationship seems to have been part of a broader social network involving politically connected individuals, as evidenced by the casual nature of the inquiry and the political context of the conversation.

discussion_ids:
  ["IMAGES-010-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_029968.txt_11258", "IMAGES-011-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_031120.txt_19820", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_029968.txt_24125", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_031120.txt_3446"]


canonical_name [F2d]: Dan Christensen
relationship_description [F3]:
  Insufficient context to determine relationship.

  The email excerpts provided show communications between Dan Christensen and Tonja Haddad Coleman regarding what appears to be a legal story involving someone named Hart and a resisting arrest charge. There is no mention of Jeffrey Epstein in any of these emails, so no relationship between Dan Christensen and Jeffrey Epstein can be determined from this content.

discussion_ids:
  ["IMAGES-011-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_031729.txt_3525", "IMAGES-011-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_031730.txt_22306", "IMAGES-011-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_031731.txt_21277", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_031729.txt_20137"]


canonical_name [F2d]: Stephen Hanson
relationship_description [F3]:
  Based on these email excerpts, Stephen Hanson appears to have had an informal social relationship with Jeffrey Epstein, primarily involving the exchange of political commentary and news articles. The emails show them sharing links and brief thoughts about political figures like Trump, Putin, and Obama, as well as articles about Epstein himself, suggesting a casual correspondence focused on current events and politics. The tone appears conversational and informal, with Hanson using shorthand messages and Epstein sharing news links, indicating they maintained regular but brief contact about topics of mutual interest.

discussion_ids:
  ["IMAGES-008-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_025877.txt_3526", "IMAGES-010-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_030420.txt_8765", "IMAGES-011-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_031489.txt_4097", "IMAGES-011-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_031619.txt_13340", "IMAGES-012-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_032681.txt_25367", "IMAGES-012-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_032689.txt_5307", "IMAGES-012-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_033081.txt_7141", "IMAGES-012-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_033114.txt_14584", "IMAGES-012-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_033456.txt_12555", "IMAGES-012-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_033458.txt_14875", "IMAGES-012-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_033460.txt_17373", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_025877.txt_9766", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_030420.txt_21731", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_031489.txt_20710", "TEXT-002-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_032681.txt_3152", "TEXT-002-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_032689.txt_21176", "TEXT-002-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_033081.txt_16425", "TEXT-002-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_033114.txt_11782", "TEXT-002-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_033456.txt_15445", "TEXT-002-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_033458.txt_12011"]


canonical_name [F2d]: Shawn Lancaster
relationship_description [F3]:
  Based on these email excerpts, Shawn Lancaster appears to have a professional relationship with Jeffrey Epstein, likely serving as an intermediary or broker in aircraft transactions. Eric Roth repeatedly emphasizes that Lancaster is "a friend" and expresses concern about "going around" him, suggesting Lancaster normally handles aircraft deals for Epstein but was being bypassed in this particular Gulfstream aircraft inquiry. The context indicates Lancaster likely worked in aviation sales or brokerage services for Epstein.

discussion_ids:
  ["IMAGES-012-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_033386.txt_3528", "IMAGES-012-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_033463.txt_19017", "IMAGES-012-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_033596.txt_6040", "IMAGES-012-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_033599.txt_22135", "TEXT-002-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_033386.txt_20132", "TEXT-002-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_033463.txt_9039", "TEXT-002-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_033596.txt_22392", "TEXT-002-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_033599.txt_6319"]


canonical_name [F2d]: Ralph Lerner
relationship_description [F3]:
  Insufficient context to determine relationship.

  The email excerpts provided do not contain any clear references to Jeffrey Epstein or communications involving Ralph Lerner's interactions with Epstein. The emails appear to discuss various business or organizational matters involving different individuals (Melanie Spinella, Brad, Barry, etc.), but do not provide information about a relationship between Ralph Lerner and Jeffrey Epstein.

discussion_ids:
  ["IMAGES-007-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_023222.txt_15759", "IMAGES-007-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_023239.txt_12617", "IMAGES-007-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_023242.txt_20620", "IMAGES-007-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_023244.txt_23837", "IMAGES-007-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_023251.txt_22863", "IMAGES-007-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_023264.txt_3585", "IMAGES-007-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_023280.txt_19617", "IMAGES-007-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_023316.txt_583", "IMAGES-007-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_023319.txt_23118", "IMAGES-007-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_023322.txt_20391", "IMAGES-007-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_023323.txt_19946", "IMAGES-007-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_023330.txt_23632", "IMAGES-007-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_023341.txt_13942", "IMAGES-007-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_023354.txt_13474"]


canonical_name [F2d]: A. O. Scott
relationship_description [F3]:
  Insufficient context to determine relationship.

  The email excerpts show A. O. Scott's movie review of "Inside Job" (2010) being shared, but do not contain any direct communication between A. O. Scott and Jeffrey Epstein or provide information about any relationship between them. The emails appear to be forwarding Scott's published film review to someone at a "jeeproject@yahoo.com" address.

discussion_ids:
  ["IMAGES-011-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_031826.txt_11912", "IMAGES-011-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_031988.txt_14266", "TEXT-002-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_031830.txt_3603", "TEXT-002-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_031988.txt_19823"]


canonical_name [F2d]: Henry Paulson
relationship_description [F3]:
  Insufficient context to determine relationship.

  The email excerpts only contain copies of a New York Times movie review for the documentary "Inside Job" (2010), which mentions Henry Paulson as one of the subjects featured in the film about the 2008 financial crisis. There is no direct communication between Paulson and Epstein, nor any content that would indicate the nature of any relationship between them.

discussion_ids:
  ["IMAGES-011-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_031826.txt_11912", "IMAGES-011-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_031830.txt_10805", "IMAGES-011-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_031986.txt_9978", "IMAGES-011-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_031988.txt_14266", "TEXT-002-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_031830.txt_3603", "TEXT-002-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_031988.txt_19823"]


canonical_name [F2d]: Nathaniel Hawthorne
relationship_description [F3]:
  Insufficient context to determine relationship.

  The email excerpts provided contain only repeated copies of a New York Times movie review for the documentary "Inside Job" (2010) about the financial crisis. There is no mention of Nathaniel Hawthorne or Jeffrey Epstein in any of the content, nor any indication of communication between these individuals.

discussion_ids:
  ["IMAGES-011-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_031826.txt_11912", "IMAGES-011-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_031830.txt_10805", "IMAGES-011-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_031986.txt_9978", "IMAGES-011-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_031988.txt_14266", "TEXT-002-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_031830.txt_3603", "TEXT-002-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_031988.txt_19823"]


canonical_name [F2d]: Timothy Geithner
relationship_description [F3]:
  Insufficient context to determine relationship.

  The email excerpts only show copies of a New York Times movie review for the documentary "Inside Job" being sent to various recipients, with Timothy Geithner mentioned solely as one of the government officials featured in the film. There is no direct communication between Geithner and Epstein, nor any content indicating a personal or professional relationship between them.

discussion_ids:
  ["IMAGES-011-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_031826.txt_11912", "IMAGES-011-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_031830.txt_10805", "IMAGES-011-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_031986.txt_9978", "IMAGES-011-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_031988.txt_14266", "TEXT-002-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_031830.txt_3603", "TEXT-002-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_031988.txt_19823"]


canonical_name [F2d]: Stormy Daniels
relationship_description [F3]:
  Insufficient context to determine relationship.

  The email excerpts show Jeffrey Epstein and his associates sharing news articles and commentary about the Stormy Daniels-Trump scandal, but contain no direct communication with Stormy Daniels herself. The emails appear to show Epstein's interest in following Trump-related controversies through media coverage, but provide no evidence of any direct relationship between Epstein and Stormy Daniels.

discussion_ids:
  ["IMAGES-003-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_016218.txt_14212", "IMAGES-008-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_026475.txt_11048", "IMAGES-011-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_031768.txt_18019", "IMAGES-012-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_032801.txt_14894", "IMAGES-012-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_032802.txt_13363", "IMAGES-012-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_033148.txt_19535", "TEXT-002-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_031768.txt_25333", "TEXT-002-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_032801.txt_11491", "TEXT-002-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_033090.txt_14879", "TEXT-002-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_033148.txt_3685"]


canonical_name [F2d]: Caroline Kennedy
relationship_description [F3]:
  Based on these email excerpts, there is insufficient context to determine a direct relationship between Caroline Kennedy and Jeffrey Epstein. The emails show a third party named Shaher forwarding news articles about Caroline Kennedy's Martha's Vineyard property sale to Epstein's email address. These appear to be informational forwards about real estate listings rather than evidence of any direct interaction between Kennedy and Epstein.

discussion_ids:
  ["IMAGES-008-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_025591.txt_11996", "IMAGES-008-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_025592.txt_10353", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_025591.txt_5355", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_025592.txt_3693"]


canonical_name [F2d]: Edwin A. Schlossberg
relationship_description [F3]:
  Insufficient context to determine relationship.

  The provided email excerpts do not contain any direct communication from or to Edwin A. Schlossberg, nor do they mention him in the content. The emails shown are from someone named "Shaher" sending real estate information about Caroline Kennedy's Martha's Vineyard property to Jeffrey Epstein, but there is no apparent connection to or mention of Schlossberg in these particular excerpts.

discussion_ids:
  ["IMAGES-008-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_025591.txt_11996", "IMAGES-008-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_025592.txt_10353", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_025591.txt_5355", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_025592.txt_3693"]


canonical_name [F2d]: Jacqueline Kennedy Onassis
relationship_description [F3]:
  Based on these email excerpts, there is no apparent direct relationship between Jacqueline Kennedy Onassis and Jeffrey Epstein. The emails are from someone named Shaher to Epstein, forwarding news articles about Caroline Kennedy (Jacqueline's daughter) selling Martha's Vineyard property. These appear to be informational forwards about real estate listings rather than evidence of any personal, professional, or business relationship between the Kennedy family and Epstein.

discussion_ids:
  ["IMAGES-008-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_025591.txt_11996", "IMAGES-008-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_025592.txt_10353", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_025591.txt_5355", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_025592.txt_3693"]


canonical_name [F2d]: John F. Kennedy
relationship_description [F3]:
  Insufficient context to determine relationship.

  The email excerpts show someone named Shaher forwarding real estate listings about Caroline Kennedy's Martha's Vineyard property to Jeffrey Epstein, but there is no direct communication between John F. Kennedy (who died in 1963) and Jeffrey Epstein, nor any content that would indicate the nature of any relationship between the Kennedy family and Epstein.

discussion_ids:
  ["IMAGES-008-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_025591.txt_11996", "IMAGES-008-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_025592.txt_10353", "IMAGES-011-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_030823.txt_22429", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_025591.txt_5355", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_025592.txt_3693"]


canonical_name [F2d]: John O'Connell
relationship_description [F3]:
  Insufficient context to determine relationship.

  The provided email excerpts do not contain any communications involving John O'Connell. The emails shown are from someone named Shaher to Jeffrey Epstein regarding Caroline Kennedy's Martha's Vineyard property sale, with no mention of or involvement by John O'Connell.

discussion_ids:
[cell repeats an earlier one in this file: 182 characters]


canonical_name [F2d]: Ariane de Rothschild
relationship_description [F3]:
  Based on these email excerpts, Ariane de Rothschild and Jeffrey Epstein appear to have had a professional relationship focused on financial and investment matters. The emails discuss debt funds, pension fund investments, yield projections, and infrastructure investment opportunities, with Epstein also facilitating introductions to other financial professionals for de Rothschild. The tone suggests an established business relationship involving regular meetings and ongoing financial discussions.

discussion_ids:
  ["IMAGES-008-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_026018.txt_25063", "IMAGES-008-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_026069.txt_15318", "IMAGES-009-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_027034.txt_5685", "IMAGES-011-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_030741.txt_3932", "IMAGES-011-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_030764.txt_21947", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_026018.txt_18766", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_026064.txt_3739", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_026069.txt_22046", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_026431.txt_14330", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_026632.txt_13297", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_029015.txt_24009", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_029277.txt_19067", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_030741.txt_19730", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_030764.txt_6185"]


canonical_name [F2d]: Johnny El Hachem
relationship_description [F3]:
  Based on these email excerpts, Johnny El Hachem appears to have had a professional business relationship with Jeffrey Epstein focused on investment and financing opportunities. The exchanges suggest they were discussing debt funds, public-private partnerships (PPPs), and infrastructure investment strategies, with El Hachem providing analysis on potential returns and expressing willingness to discuss consortium leadership roles. The tone appears cordial and business-oriented, centered around financial structuring and investment yield discussions.

discussion_ids:
  ["IMAGES-008-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_026059.txt_10656", "IMAGES-008-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_026431.txt_20647", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_026064.txt_3739", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_026069.txt_22046"]


canonical_name [F2d]: Amanda Ens
relationship_description [F3]:
  Based on these email excerpts, Amanda Ens appears to have had a professional financial services relationship with Jeffrey Epstein. As a Director of Global Equities at Bank of America Merrill Lynch, she regularly provided him with market analysis, investment recommendations, and trade execution services, including specific options strategies on financial sector ETFs and S&P 500 puts. The emails indicate a standard client-advisor relationship involving significant trading activity, with one transaction showing a notional amount of over $14 million.

discussion_ids:
  ["IMAGES-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_011277.txt_5313", "IMAGES-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_011280.txt_25212", "IMAGES-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_011281.txt_24771", "IMAGES-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_012044.txt_10158", "IMAGES-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_012045.txt_10944", "IMAGES-002-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_014310.txt_7209", "IMAGES-002-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_014312.txt_8971", "IMAGES-002-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_014313.txt_8829", "IMAGES-002-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_014397.txt_23235", "IMAGES-003-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_014516.txt_3748", "IMAGES-003-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_014695.txt_24178", "IMAGES-003-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_014717.txt_5592", "IMAGES-003-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_014860.txt_19395", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_011277.txt_12934", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_011280.txt_7966", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_012044.txt_21085", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_014310.txt_9654", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_014312.txt_6559", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_014397.txt_25689", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_014516.txt_9073", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_014695.txt_14161", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_014717.txt_7627", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_014857.txt_10087", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_014860.txt_18981", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_029458.txt_18314"]


canonical_name [F2d]: Danny Frost
relationship_description [F3]:
  Insufficient context to determine relationship.

  The email excerpts show Danny Frost communicating with journalist Susan Edelman about legal procedures and document redaction policies, but do not contain any direct references to Jeffrey Epstein or indicate the nature of any relationship Frost may have had with him.

discussion_ids:
  ["IMAGES-003-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_016465.txt_5960", "IMAGES-003-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_016467.txt_3757", "IMAGES-003-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_016468.txt_19856", "IMAGES-003-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_016471.txt_6007"]


canonical_name [F2d]: Susan Edelman
relationship_description [F3]:
  Insufficient context to determine relationship.

  The email excerpts show Susan Edelman (a New York Post reporter) corresponding with Danny Frost from the Manhattan DA's office about sealed court documents, but there is no direct communication or clear connection between Susan Edelman and Jeffrey Epstein in these excerpts. While Edelman's name appears in what seems to be a contact list from Epstein's email, this alone doesn't establish the nature of any relationship between them.

discussion_ids:
  ["IMAGES-003-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_016465.txt_5960", "IMAGES-003-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_016466.txt_4364", "IMAGES-003-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_016467.txt_3757", "IMAGES-003-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_016468.txt_19856", "IMAGES-003-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_016470.txt_5371", "IMAGES-003-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_016471.txt_6007", "IMAGES-009-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_026632.txt_16612", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_025101.txt_19174", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_025163.txt_24357"]


canonical_name [F2d]: Irwin Tenenbaum
relationship_description [F3]:
  Based on these email excerpts, Irwin Tenenbaum appears to have a professional/legal relationship with Jeffrey Epstein, likely serving as Epstein's lawyer or legal representative. The emails indicate that Tenenbaum drafted and sent a contract or agreement on Epstein's behalf to Lisa New regarding some arrangement involving "Woody" and what appears to be a Harvard-related event or program. The tone suggests a standard business relationship where Tenenbaum handles contractual matters for Epstein's various dealings or ventures.

discussion_ids:
  ["IMAGES-010-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_028976.txt_3762", "IMAGES-010-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_029269.txt_23890", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_028976.txt_16508", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_029269.txt_10978"]


canonical_name [F2d]: Joe Biden
relationship_description [F3]:
  Insufficient context to determine relationship.

  The email excerpts provided do not contain any direct communications between Joe Biden and Jeffrey Epstein, nor do they describe any specific interactions between them. Biden is only mentioned in passing - in reference to news coverage of his diplomatic work and Cancer Moonshot initiative, and in discussions about event billing hierarchy alongside Bill Clinton.

discussion_ids:
  ["IMAGES-008-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_025944.txt_14924", "IMAGES-009-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_027102.txt_19178", "IMAGES-010-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_028728.txt_14049", "IMAGES-010-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_028976.txt_3762", "IMAGES-010-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_029269.txt_23890", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_025944.txt_21670", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_028976.txt_16508", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_029269.txt_10978", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_031129.txt_22679"]


canonical_name [F2d]: George Rush
relationship_description [F3]:
  Based on the email excerpts provided, George Rush appears to be a journalist working on a story about Jeffrey Epstein for a Sunday column. The relationship is professional in nature, with Rush investigating Epstein-related matters and seeking comments from Howard Rubenstein (who appears to be representing or defending Epstein) regarding allegations and lawsuits against Epstein. The tone suggests a typical reporter-subject dynamic where Rush is pursuing journalistic coverage of Epstein's legal controversies.

discussion_ids:
  ["IMAGES-002-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_013405.txt_25096", "IMAGES-007-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_023338.txt_3790", "IMAGES-011-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_031002.txt_6784", "IMAGES-011-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_031005.txt_11168", "IMAGES-011-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_031008.txt_14720", "IMAGES-011-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_031099.txt_4499", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_013405.txt_22658", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_030999.txt_19732", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_031002.txt_16900", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_031005.txt_13787", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_031008.txt_12056", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_031099.txt_20307"]


canonical_name [F2d]: Fidel Castro
relationship_description [F3]:
  Insufficient context to determine relationship.

  The provided email excerpts do not contain any references to or correspondence involving Fidel Castro. The emails appear to be various communications to/from Jeffrey Epstein involving other individuals, but there is no mention of Castro or any interactions between Castro and Epstein in these particular excerpts.

discussion_ids:
  ["IMAGES-009-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_026632.txt_16612", "IMAGES-010-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_029622.txt_15184", "IMAGES-011-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_032297.txt_11755", "IMAGES-012-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_033225.txt_3817", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_026028.txt_7589", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_026632.txt_13297", "TEXT-002-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_032297.txt_5909", "TEXT-002-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_033225.txt_19442"]


canonical_name [F2d]: Walli Leff
relationship_description [F3]:
  Insufficient context to determine relationship.

  The provided email excerpts do not mention Walli Leff or Jeffrey Epstein. The emails appear to be correspondence involving Paul Krassner discussing comedian Irwin Corey and Daryl Cagle discussing political cartoons and Starbucks branding.

discussion_ids:
  ["IMAGES-012-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_033225.txt_3817", "IMAGES-012-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_033568.txt_5358", "TEXT-002-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_033225.txt_19442", "TEXT-002-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_033568.txt_21016"]


canonical_name [F2d]: Scott J. Link
relationship_description [F3]:
  Based on the email excerpts, Scott J. Link appears to have served as Jeffrey Epstein's attorney in a legal capacity. The emails show Link forwarding news articles about Epstein's legal cases to him, and a journalist's inquiry specifically identifies Epstein as Link's "client" in relation to a lawsuit filed by accuser Sarah Ransome. The relationship appears to be professional, involving Link's representation of Epstein during legal proceedings and media coverage of his cases.

discussion_ids:
  ["IMAGES-007-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_022998.txt_3818", "IMAGES-010-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_028536.txt_7144", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_022998.txt_20193", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_028536.txt_20099", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_031384.txt_6726"]


canonical_name [F2d]: Gordon Getty
relationship_description [F3]:
  Insufficient context to determine relationship.

  The emails do not contain any direct communication between Gordon Getty and Jeffrey Epstein. The only references to Getty are in correspondence from Robert Trivers mentioning Getty's "echo chamber" and "missives" in the context of academic mailing lists, with no indication of any connection to Epstein.

discussion_ids:
  ["IMAGES-008-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_025589.txt_13564", "IMAGES-010-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_029154.txt_17128", "IMAGES-010-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_029163.txt_11963", "IMAGES-010-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_029498.txt_3839", "IMAGES-012-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_032733.txt_20592", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_025589.txt_19841", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_029154.txt_4163", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_029163.txt_24899", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_029498.txt_16591", "TEXT-002-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_032733.txt_4206"]


canonical_name [F2d]: Anthony Scaramucci
relationship_description [F3]:
  Insufficient context to determine relationship.

  The email excerpts only mention Anthony Scaramucci in passing within a news article about Trump advisors seeking a pardon for Michael Milken. There is no direct communication between Scaramucci and Epstein, nor any indication of their relationship beyond Scaramucci being referenced in a news story that was shared with Epstein.

discussion_ids:
  ["IMAGES-011-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_031788.txt_10994", "IMAGES-011-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_031796.txt_19051", "TEXT-002-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_031788.txt_3854", "TEXT-002-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_031789.txt_4276", "TEXT-002-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_031796.txt_24669"]


canonical_name [F2d]: Jared Kushner
relationship_description [F3]:
  Based on these email excerpts, there appears to be minimal direct interaction between Jared Kushner and Jeffrey Epstein. The primary connection shown is a formal invitation to Epstein for the New York Observer's 25th anniversary celebration in 2013, when Kushner was the publisher. The remaining emails consist mainly of news articles being shared with Epstein about Trump administration matters and Kushner's activities, but don't indicate any direct personal or professional relationship between Kushner and Epstein themselves.

discussion_ids:
  ["IMAGES-007-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_023545.txt_14863", "IMAGES-007-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_023548.txt_11028", "IMAGES-010-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_029505.txt_6261", "IMAGES-011-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_031788.txt_10994", "IMAGES-011-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_031796.txt_19051", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_023545.txt_12785", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_023548.txt_13121", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_029505.txt_19038", "TEXT-002-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_031788.txt_3854", "TEXT-002-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_031789.txt_4276", "TEXT-002-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_031796.txt_24669", "TEXT-002-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_033304.txt_8772"]


canonical_name [F2d]: Robert D. Critton Jr.
relationship_description [F3]:
  Insufficient context to determine relationship.

  The email excerpts show multiple instances of Jeffrey Epstein sending emails to Robert D. Critton Jr., but the actual content of these emails is not provided - only the sender/recipient information is shown. Without the email content, it's impossible to determine the nature, context, or tone of their relationship.

discussion_ids:
  ["IMAGES-006-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_021790.txt_19601", "IMAGES-006-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_021794.txt_25511", "IMAGES-010-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_029880.txt_4184", "IMAGES-010-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_029889.txt_23544", "IMAGES-010-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_030299.txt_20890", "IMAGES-010-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_030311.txt_21902", "IMAGES-011-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_030999.txt_3925", "IMAGES-011-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_031002.txt_6784", "IMAGES-011-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_031791.txt_14867", "IMAGES-012-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_033502.txt_18333", "IMAGES-012-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_033508.txt_10246", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_021790.txt_7665", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_021794.txt_11830", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_029889.txt_10654", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_030299.txt_8072", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_030311.txt_8927", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_030999.txt_19732", "TEXT-002-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_031791.txt_21980"]


canonical_name [F2d]: Alexandra Preate
relationship_description [F3]:
  Insufficient context to determine relationship.

  The email excerpts provided show only sender/recipient information and email headers without any actual content, making it impossible to determine the nature, context, or tone of any relationship between Alexandra Preate and Jeffrey Epstein.

discussion_ids:
  ["IMAGES-005-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_019324.txt_4094", "IMAGES-005-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_020443.txt_12940", "IMAGES-006-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_020815.txt_8089", "IMAGES-006-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_021106.txt_11947", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_020443.txt_16654", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_020815.txt_21968", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_021106.txt_25398"]


canonical_name [F2d]: Amy Poehler
relationship_description [F3]:
  Insufficient context to determine relationship.

  The email excerpts only show Amy Poehler mentioned as attending a Worldwide Orphans charity event that was included in a list of social events sent to Jeffrey Epstein. There is no indication of direct communication between them or evidence of any personal or professional relationship.

discussion_ids:
  ["IMAGES-002-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_012711.txt_4124", "IMAGES-010-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_029841.txt_5621", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_012711.txt_4900", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_029841.txt_18428"]


canonical_name [F2d]: Zooey Deschanel
relationship_description [F3]:
  Insufficient context to determine relationship.

  The emails only mention a "Self Magazine & Zooey Deschanel Party" as one of several social events being offered to the recipient, with no indication of any direct relationship between Zooey Deschanel and Jeffrey Epstein. The reference appears to be simply listing a magazine-sponsored event that happened to involve the actress.

discussion_ids:
  ["IMAGES-002-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_012711.txt_4124", "IMAGES-010-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_029841.txt_5621", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_012711.txt_4900", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_029841.txt_18428"]


canonical_name [F2d]: Adrienne Ross
relationship_description [F3]:
  Insufficient context to determine relationship.

  The provided email excerpts do not contain any correspondence involving Adrienne Ross. The emails shown are between Jeffrey Epstein and Steve/Sean Bannon, with one additional email from Thomas D. Williams to Raheem Kassam about Steve Bannon that doesn't involve Epstein at all.

discussion_ids:
  ["IMAGES-008-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_025533.txt_4153", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_025517.txt_15606", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_025520.txt_6992", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_025524.txt_12398", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_025528.txt_13937", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_025533.txt_10813"]


canonical_name [F2d]: Sean Bannon
relationship_description [F3]:
  Based on these email excerpts, Sean Bannon and Steve Bannon appear to have had some form of professional or business relationship with Jeffrey Epstein, likely involving a film project. The emails reference in-person meetings ("Thanks for having us today") and collaboration on what seems to be a film production ("Can we get Jeffrey latest version of film"). However, the excerpts are too brief and lack sufficient detail to fully characterize the nature, extent, or timeline of their relationship.

discussion_ids:
  ["IMAGES-008-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_025524.txt_5784", "IMAGES-008-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_025533.txt_4153", "IMAGES-009-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_027067.txt_13831", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_025524.txt_12398", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_025533.txt_10813"]


canonical_name [F2d]: David Haig
relationship_description [F3]:
  Based on these email excerpts, David Haig appears to have been part of an academic or intellectual correspondence group that included Jeffrey Epstein, facilitated by Robert Trivers. The relationship seems to have been primarily intellectual/academic in nature, with Trivers including both Haig and Epstein as recipients of academic discussions and potential additions to Gordon Getty's intellectual circle. Haig's polite acknowledgment of Jeffrey in his response ("hello Jeffrey") suggests they were at least acquainted within this academic correspondence context, though Haig declined further involvement in additional mailing lists.

discussion_ids:
  ["IMAGES-010-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_029154.txt_17128", "IMAGES-010-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_029163.txt_11963", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_029154.txt_4163", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_029163.txt_24899", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_029498.txt_16591"]


canonical_name [F2d]: Peter Richerson
relationship_description [F3]:
  Insufficient context to determine relationship.

  The email excerpts show academic discussions about evolutionary biology and gene-culture co-evolution involving Peter Richerson, but they do not contain any direct correspondence between Peter Richerson and Jeffrey Epstein, nor do they describe any relationship between these two individuals. The emails appear to be exchanges between other academics (Robert Trivers, David Haig, Alan Rogers) discussing Richerson's academic work.

discussion_ids:
  ["IMAGES-008-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_025589.txt_13564", "IMAGES-010-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_029154.txt_17128", "IMAGES-010-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_029163.txt_11963", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_025589.txt_19841", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_029154.txt_4163", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_029163.txt_24899", "TEXT-002-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_032733.txt_4206"]


canonical_name [F2d]: David Pegg
relationship_description [F3]:
  Based on the email excerpts, David Pegg appears to have a professional journalistic relationship with Jeffrey Epstein. Pegg, a journalist at The Guardian newspaper in London, was attempting to contact Epstein for comment regarding an article in which Epstein would be mentioned, following standard journalistic practice of seeking responses from subjects before publication. The emails show Pegg made multiple unsuccessful attempts to reach Epstein directly and then contacted Epstein's attorney (Weinberg) with deadline-driven requests for a response, indicating this was likely investigative reporting rather than any personal or business relationship.

discussion_ids:
  ["IMAGES-010-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_030335.txt_4233", "IMAGES-010-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_030339.txt_21973", "IMAGES-010-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_030343.txt_10342", "IMAGES-010-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_030377.txt_17106", "IMAGES-011-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_030592.txt_568", "IMAGES-011-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_030596.txt_5887", "IMAGES-012-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_032796.txt_19126", "IMAGES-012-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_032798.txt_8333", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_030335.txt_17005", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_030339.txt_9003", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_030343.txt_23266", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_030377.txt_4136", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_030592.txt_22590", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_030596.txt_22510", "TEXT-002-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_033568.txt_21016"]


canonical_name [F2d]: Ivan Glasenberg
relationship_description [F3]:
  Insufficient context to determine relationship.

  The email excerpts show Jide Zeitlin asking Jeffrey Epstein if he knows Ivan Glasenberg, but there are no direct communications between Glasenberg and Epstein provided. Without actual correspondence or interactions between Glasenberg and Epstein, it's impossible to determine the nature, context, or existence of any relationship between them.

discussion_ids:
  ["IMAGES-012-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_033375.txt_21285", "IMAGES-012-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_033377.txt_20663", "TEXT-002-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_033375.txt_5504", "TEXT-002-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_033377.txt_4247"]


canonical_name [F2d]: Jide Zeitlin
relationship_description [F3]:
  Based on these email excerpts, Jide Zeitlin and Jeffrey Epstein appear to have had a professional/business relationship with social elements, involving high-level networking and introductions. The communications show Zeitlin coordinating meetings with Epstein in Palm Beach, seeking introductions to prominent figures like Russian oligarch Oleg Deripaska and commodities trader Ivan Glasenberg, and discussing interactions with government officials including references to White House meetings and foreign ministers. The tone suggests a working relationship where Epstein served as a connector or intermediary in Zeitlin's business and political networking activities.

discussion_ids:
  ["IMAGES-008-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_026263.txt_8605", "IMAGES-011-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_030954.txt_20184", "IMAGES-012-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_033374.txt_22274", "IMAGES-012-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_033375.txt_21285", "IMAGES-012-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_033377.txt_20663", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_030954.txt_4601", "TEXT-002-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_033374.txt_5849", "TEXT-002-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_033375.txt_5504", "TEXT-002-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_033377.txt_4247"]


canonical_name [F2d]: Okey Enelamah
relationship_description [F3]:
  Insufficient context to determine relationship.

  The email excerpts mention Okey Enelamah only once in passing, where Jide Zeitlin (communicating with Jeffrey Epstein) notes that Enelamah, Nigeria's trade minister, "mentioned his discussions with you at WEF and afterwards." This single reference suggests they may have had some interaction at the World Economic Forum, but provides no details about the nature, scope, or context of their relationship.

discussion_ids:
  ["IMAGES-011-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_030954.txt_20184", "IMAGES-012-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_033374.txt_22274", "IMAGES-012-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_033377.txt_20663", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_030954.txt_4601", "TEXT-002-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_033374.txt_5849", "TEXT-002-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_033377.txt_4247"]


canonical_name [F2d]: Oleg Deripaska
relationship_description [F3]:
  Insufficient context to determine relationship.

  The email excerpts show Jide Zeitlin asking Jeffrey Epstein if he knows Oleg Deripaska, but there is no direct communication between Deripaska and Epstein provided, nor any indication of the nature or extent of any potential relationship between them.

discussion_ids:
  ["IMAGES-012-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_033375.txt_21285", "IMAGES-012-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_033377.txt_20663", "TEXT-002-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_033375.txt_5504", "TEXT-002-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_033377.txt_4247"]


canonical_name [F2d]: Faith Kate
relationship_description [F3]:
  Insufficient context to determine relationship.

  The provided email excerpts do not mention Faith Kate at all. The emails shown are primarily between Jeffrey Epstein and Lisa New (with one from Martin G. Weinberg), discussing what appears to be a list of politicians who have been "taped." Without any emails involving or referencing Faith Kate, I cannot determine what relationship they may have had with Jeffrey Epstein.

discussion_ids:
  ["TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_023198.txt_14939", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_023205.txt_14608", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_029251.txt_8476", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_030149.txt_4254"]


canonical_name [F2d]: Auren Hoffman
relationship_description [F3]:
  Insufficient context to determine relationship.

  The email excerpts do not contain any direct communication between Auren Hoffman and Jeffrey Epstein, nor do they reference any interactions between them. The emails shown appear to be separate communications involving each person independently, with no clear connection established between Hoffman and Epstein based on the provided content.

discussion_ids:
  ["IMAGES-002-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_013484.txt_12328", "IMAGES-004-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_017574.txt_25237", "IMAGES-004-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_017581.txt_4421", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_017574.txt_18921", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_017581.txt_10799"]


canonical_name [F2d]: Bob Crowe
relationship_description [F3]:
  Insufficient context to determine relationship.

  The email excerpts show Bob Crowe involved in what appears to be advocacy work related to human rights and democracy in Senegal, working with colleagues on letters, articles, and State Department meetings. However, there is no mention of Jeffrey Epstein in any of the provided email content, making it impossible to determine any relationship between Bob Crowe and Jeffrey Epstein based on these excerpts.

discussion_ids:
  ["IMAGES-009-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_026835.txt_10911", "IMAGES-009-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_026838.txt_14960", "IMAGES-010-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_028775.txt_21397", "IMAGES-010-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_028776.txt_19797", "IMAGES-010-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_028778.txt_4422", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_026835.txt_7855", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_028775.txt_8603"]


canonical_name [F2d]: El Hadji Amadou Sall
relationship_description [F3]:
  Insufficient context to determine relationship.

  The email excerpts discuss political advocacy efforts regarding President Sall of Senegal and democratic concerns in Africa, but do not mention Jeffrey Epstein or provide any information about El Hadji Amadou Sall's relationship with Epstein. The emails appear to be about lobbying or advocacy work related to Senegalese politics rather than any connection to Jeffrey Epstein.

discussion_ids:
  ["IMAGES-009-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_026835.txt_10911", "IMAGES-009-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_026838.txt_14960", "IMAGES-010-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_028776.txt_19797", "IMAGES-010-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_028778.txt_4422"]


canonical_name [F2d]: Vinoda Basnayake
relationship_description [F3]:
  Insufficient context to determine relationship.

  The email excerpts show Vinoda Basnayake working on advocacy efforts related to human rights issues in Senegal and Africa, collaborating with others on placing articles in political publications and coordinating with the State Department. However, there is no mention of Jeffrey Epstein in any of the provided email content, making it impossible to determine any relationship between Basnayake and Epstein based on these excerpts.

discussion_ids:
  ["IMAGES-009-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_026835.txt_10911", "IMAGES-009-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_026836.txt_12478", "IMAGES-009-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_026838.txt_14960", "IMAGES-010-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_028775.txt_21397", "IMAGES-010-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_028776.txt_19797", "IMAGES-010-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_028778.txt_4422", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_026835.txt_7855", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_028775.txt_8603"]


canonical_name [F2d]: Bernie Sanders
relationship_description [F3]:
  Insufficient context to determine relationship.

  The email excerpts provided do not contain any content involving Bernie Sanders or any apparent relationship between Bernie Sanders and Jeffrey Epstein. The emails appear to be primarily newsletter content from Fareed Zakaria and academic discussions about ranked choice voting between Eric Maskin, Larry Summers, and someone using the email "jeevacation@gmail.com."

discussion_ids:
  ["IMAGES-009-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_026509.txt_19470", "IMAGES-011-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_030876.txt_7919", "IMAGES-011-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_031112.txt_4446", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_026321.txt_19512", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_026508.txt_23378", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_030876.txt_17275", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_031112.txt_20852"]


canonical_name [F2d]: Fareed Zakaria
relationship_description [F3]:
  Based on these email excerpts, there appears to be no direct relationship between Fareed Zakaria and Jeffrey Epstein. The emails show that a third party (Sultan Bin Sulayem) was forwarding Fareed Zakaria's publicly published Washington Post columns to Epstein's email address. There is no evidence of direct communication, meetings, or any personal or professional relationship between Zakaria and Epstein in these materials.

discussion_ids:
  ["IMAGES-010-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_029849.txt_25061", "IMAGES-011-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_030876.txt_7919", "IMAGES-011-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_031112.txt_4446", "IMAGES-012-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_033482.txt_11090", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_029849.txt_12317", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_030876.txt_17275", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_031112.txt_20852", "TEXT-002-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_033482.txt_13745"]


canonical_name [F2d]: Howard Rubenstein
relationship_description [F3]:
  Based on the email excerpt provided, Howard Rubenstein appears to have served as a spokesperson or public relations representative for Jeffrey Epstein during legal controversies. The email shows a journalist seeking comment from Rubenstein about previous statements he made defending Epstein against accusations, suggesting Rubenstein was acting in a professional PR or crisis management capacity. The tone indicates Rubenstein had previously made public statements characterizing Epstein's accusers as liars rather than victims.

discussion_ids:
  ["IMAGES-011-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_031002.txt_6784", "IMAGES-011-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_031005.txt_11168", "IMAGES-011-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_031008.txt_14720", "IMAGES-011-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_031099.txt_4499", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_030999.txt_19732", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_031002.txt_16900", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_031005.txt_13787", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_031008.txt_12056", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_031099.txt_20307"]


canonical_name [F2d]: Alice Cooper
relationship_description [F3]:
  Insufficient context to determine relationship.

  The email excerpts only contain a brief mention of Alice Cooper in the context of a musical performance that included Cooper, Joe Perry, and someone referred to as "Johnny" (likely Johnny Depp based on context). There is no direct communication between Alice Cooper and Jeffrey Epstein, nor any indication of a direct relationship between them in these materials.

discussion_ids:
  ["IMAGES-008-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_025636.txt_8460", "IMAGES-008-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_025639.txt_18151", "IMAGES-008-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_025651.txt_4523", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_025639.txt_24285"]


canonical_name [F2d]: Joe Perry
relationship_description [F3]:
  Insufficient context to determine relationship.

  The email excerpts only contain a brief mention of Joe Perry in passing, where Lawrence Krauss references attending a show featuring "alice cooper and joe perry in la" while discussing other matters with Jeffrey Epstein. There is no direct communication between Joe Perry and Epstein, nor any indication of the nature of their relationship, if any existed.

discussion_ids:
  ["IMAGES-008-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_025636.txt_8460", "IMAGES-008-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_025639.txt_18151", "IMAGES-008-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_025651.txt_4523", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_025639.txt_24285"]


canonical_name [F2d]: Cathy Alexander
relationship_description [F3]:
  Based on these email excerpts, Cathy Alexander appears to have had a professional relationship with Jeffrey Epstein as the manager of his Little St. James island property from 1999 through 2007. Alexander is communicating with what appears to be Epstein's attorney (Martin Weinberg) in a legal context, offering to provide sworn testimony about visitors to the island, specifically regarding whether high-profile political figures like President Clinton and Vice President Gore visited the property. The tone suggests Alexander is cooperating with legal proceedings and providing factual information about island operations during their tenure as manager.

discussion_ids:
  ["IMAGES-008-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_025880.txt_23812", "IMAGES-008-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_025885.txt_22269", "IMAGES-008-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_026358.txt_4529", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_025882.txt_17898"]


canonical_name [F2d]: Arthur Sulzberger
relationship_description [F3]:
  Insufficient context to determine relationship.

  The email excerpts are between Jeffrey Epstein and Michael Wolff, not Arthur Sulzberger. Arthur Sulzberger is only mentioned once by Wolff as someone he expects to face consequences in what appears to be the context of #MeToo allegations, but there are no direct communications between Sulzberger and Epstein provided.

discussion_ids:
  ["IMAGES-011-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_030684.txt_8182", "IMAGES-011-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_030686.txt_7958", "IMAGES-011-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_030771.txt_21607", "IMAGES-011-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_030773.txt_20345", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_030684.txt_18181", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_030686.txt_17362", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_030771.txt_5209", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_030773.txt_4553"]


canonical_name [F2d]: Israel Horovitz
relationship_description [F3]:
  Insufficient context to determine relationship.

  The email excerpts are between Jeffrey E. and Michael Wolff, with Israel Horovitz only mentioned briefly by Wolff as "the 80-year-old father of my friend Rachel Horovitz--the playwright Israel Horovitz--whacked" in what appears to be discussion of public figures facing scandals. There is no direct communication between Jeffrey E. and Israel Horovitz, nor any indication of a relationship between them.

discussion_ids:
  ["IMAGES-011-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_030684.txt_8182", "IMAGES-011-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_030686.txt_7958", "IMAGES-011-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_030771.txt_21607", "IMAGES-011-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_030773.txt_20345", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_030684.txt_18181", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_030686.txt_17362", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_030771.txt_5209", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_030773.txt_4553"]


canonical_name [F2d]: Lorin Stein
relationship_description [F3]:
  Insufficient context to determine relationship.

  The email excerpts show correspondence between Jeffrey E. and Michael Wolff, where Wolff mentions that "My buddy, Lorin Stein, who runs the Paris Review--the Paris Review for god's sake!--just went down" in what appears to be discussion of public figures facing scandals. However, there is no direct correspondence between Lorin Stein and Jeffrey Epstein in these excerpts, nor any indication of a direct relationship between them.

discussion_ids:
  ["IMAGES-011-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_030684.txt_8182", "IMAGES-011-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_030686.txt_7958", "IMAGES-011-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_030771.txt_21607", "IMAGES-011-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_030773.txt_20345", "IMAGES-012-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_033307.txt_16493", "IMAGES-012-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_033311.txt_18995", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_030684.txt_18181", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_030686.txt_17362", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_030771.txt_5209", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_030773.txt_4553", "TEXT-002-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_033311.txt_9068"]


canonical_name [F2d]: Rachel Horovitz
relationship_description [F3]:
  Insufficient context to determine relationship.

  The email excerpts are correspondence between Jeffrey Epstein and Michael Wolff, not Rachel Horovitz. Rachel Horovitz is only mentioned once by Wolff as "my friend Rachel Horovitz" when discussing her father, playwright Israel Horovitz, in what appears to be a conversation about public figures facing scandals.

discussion_ids:
  ["IMAGES-011-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_030684.txt_8182", "IMAGES-011-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_030686.txt_7958", "IMAGES-011-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_030771.txt_21607", "IMAGES-011-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_030773.txt_20345", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_030684.txt_18181", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_030686.txt_17362", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_030771.txt_5209", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_030773.txt_4553"]


canonical_name [F2d]: Peter Attia
relationship_description [F3]:
  Based on these email excerpts, Peter Attia and Jeffrey Epstein appear to have had an informal, social relationship where they shared political commentary and personal updates. The emails show Attia sharing news articles about political figures (Clinton/Trump) and making casual political remarks, while also checking in about Epstein's activities ("Glad you were able to see him"). The tone suggests a friendly, conversational dynamic focused on current events and personal matters.

discussion_ids:
  ["IMAGES-010-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_030015.txt_17551", "IMAGES-011-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_032317.txt_17299", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_030015.txt_4557", "TEXT-002-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_032317.txt_22851"]


canonical_name [F2d]: Deepak Chopra
relationship_description [F3]:
  Based on the email excerpts, Deepak Chopra and Jeffrey Epstein appear to have had a casual social relationship that included regular meetups and intellectual discussions. The emails show them arranging meetings (including one at "the alchemist kitchen"), sharing articles about topics like Donald Trump and consciousness, and engaging in conversations about health concepts like heart rate variability. One email references a civil case against Epstein and mentions meetings involving other individuals including "the russian," suggesting Chopra was aware of Epstein's legal issues and broader social circle.

discussion_ids:
  ["IMAGES-008-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_026008.txt_20147", "IMAGES-009-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_026788.txt_9484", "IMAGES-010-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_028980.txt_22991", "IMAGES-010-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_028985.txt_21469", "IMAGES-010-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_028986.txt_19805", "IMAGES-010-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_029003.txt_11414", "IMAGES-010-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_029005.txt_8149", "IMAGES-010-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_029017.txt_11382", "IMAGES-010-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_029203.txt_11175", "IMAGES-010-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_029276.txt_5070", "IMAGES-010-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_029402.txt_6951", "IMAGES-010-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_029403.txt_7651", "IMAGES-010-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_029503.txt_3006", "IMAGES-010-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_029509.txt_20768", "IMAGES-011-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_032296.txt_12573", "IMAGES-011-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_032350.txt_2830", "IMAGES-011-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_032351.txt_2093", "IMAGES-011-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_032366.txt_20564", "IMAGES-011-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_032367.txt_19795", "IMAGES-011-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_032406.txt_23691", "IMAGES-011-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_032451.txt_10190", "IMAGES-012-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_032513.txt_3091", "IMAGES-012-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_032515.txt_6365", "IMAGES-012-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_033170.txt_25617", "IMAGES-012-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_033249.txt_13495", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_026008.txt_13403", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_028980.txt_10270", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_028985.txt_8685", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_028986.txt_7075", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_029003.txt_24279", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_029010.txt_22397", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_029017.txt_24272", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_029203.txt_23849", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_029276.txt_18072", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_029402.txt_19929", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_029503.txt_15778", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_029509.txt_7805", "TEXT-002-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_032296.txt_5476", "TEXT-002-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_032350.txt_8326", "TEXT-002-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_032351.txt_9502", "TEXT-002-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_032366.txt_13153", "TEXT-002-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_032367.txt_14289", "TEXT-002-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_032405.txt_18044", "TEXT-002-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_032451.txt_4578", "TEXT-002-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_033170.txt_2802", "TEXT-002-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_033249.txt_9807"]


canonical_name [F2d]: Bernie Nussbaum
relationship_description [F3]:
  Insufficient context to determine relationship.

  The email excerpts show Jeffrey Epstein providing background information about Bernie Nussbaum (former White House counsel) to Michael Wolff, who appears to be preparing for an interview with Nussbaum. However, the emails don't reveal any direct relationship between Epstein and Nussbaum - only that Epstein had knowledge about political figures that he shared with the journalist.

discussion_ids:
  ["IMAGES-008-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_025935.txt_24646", "IMAGES-010-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_029274.txt_4631", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_025935.txt_18404", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_028978.txt_7692", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_029274.txt_17428"]


canonical_name [F2d]: Vince Foster
relationship_description [F3]:
  Insufficient context to determine relationship.

  The email excerpts show Jeffrey Epstein and Michael Wolff discussing Vince Foster and Bernard Nussbaum in what appears to be preparation for an interview, but the fragments are too brief and lack sufficient detail to characterize the nature of any relationship between Epstein and Foster specifically. The exchanges seem to involve Epstein providing background information to journalist Michael Wolff, but don't establish any direct connection between Epstein and Foster themselves.

discussion_ids:
  ["IMAGES-008-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_025935.txt_24646", "IMAGES-010-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_029274.txt_4631", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_025935.txt_18404", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_028978.txt_7692", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_029274.txt_17428"]


canonical_name [F2d]: Ebrahim Raisi
relationship_description [F3]:
  Based on these email excerpts, there is no direct relationship between Ebrahim Raisi and Jeffrey Epstein. The emails show a third party (Alireza Ittihadieh) forwarding news coverage about Iranian politics to Epstein, with Raisi mentioned only as a political figure who lost an election to Hassan Rouhani. The content appears to be informational updates about Middle Eastern political developments rather than evidence of any personal or professional connection between Raisi and Epstein.

discussion_ids:
  ["IMAGES-011-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_032217.txt_25516", "IMAGES-012-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_033001.txt_20242", "TEXT-002-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_032217.txt_18221", "TEXT-002-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_033001.txt_4633"]


canonical_name [F2d]: Fazel Meybodi
relationship_description [F3]:
  Insufficient context to determine relationship.

  The email excerpts provided do not mention Fazel Meybodi at all. The emails shown are from Alireza Ittihadieh to Jeffrey Epstein discussing Iranian election results and appear to be news updates about President Rouhani's victory, but contain no information about Fazel Meybodi or any relationship between Meybodi and Epstein.

discussion_ids:
  ["IMAGES-011-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_032217.txt_25516", "IMAGES-012-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_033001.txt_20242", "TEXT-002-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_032217.txt_18221", "TEXT-002-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_033001.txt_4633"]


canonical_name [F2d]: Martin Weinberg
relationship_description [F3]:
  Insufficient context to determine relationship.

  The email excerpts provided do not contain enough substantive content to characterize Martin Weinberg's relationship with Jeffrey Epstein. While there is one email showing Martin G. Weinberg sending something to Epstein's email address (jeevacation@gmail.com), the content of that communication is not included, making it impossible to determine the nature, context, or tone of their interactions.

discussion_ids:
  ["IMAGES-006-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_021113.txt_12393", "IMAGES-011-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_031217.txt_8156", "TEXT-002-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_032848.txt_4683", "TEXT-002-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_033293.txt_15926"]


canonical_name [F2d]: Patricia Gayle Gordon
relationship_description [F3]:
  Insufficient context to determine relationship.

  The email excerpts provided do not contain any direct correspondence to, from, or specifically about Patricia Gayle Gordon in relation to Jeffrey Epstein. While Gordon is mentioned once in passing as having recommended lawyers to Robert Trivers (who was corresponding with Epstein), there is no information about Gordon's direct relationship with Epstein, the nature of any interactions between them, or the context of their connection.

discussion_ids:
  ["IMAGES-004-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_016677.txt_6000", "IMAGES-008-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_025139.txt_19696", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_016636.txt_23726", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_025139.txt_13116", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_025140.txt_4696"]


canonical_name [F2d]: Nick Pyke
relationship_description [F3]:
  Insufficient context to determine relationship.

  The provided email excerpts do not contain any direct communication between Nick Pyke and Jeffrey Epstein, nor do they mention Nick Pyke in any context related to Epstein. The emails appear to involve other parties (Fred Haddad, Sharon Churcher, Tonja Haddad Coleman) discussing legal matters and media coverage related to Epstein, but provide no information about any relationship between Epstein and Nick Pyke.

discussion_ids:
  ["IMAGES-007-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_023024.txt_16265", "IMAGES-007-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_023067.txt_4716", "IMAGES-011-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_030620.txt_4793", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_023067.txt_19671"]


canonical_name [F2d]: Bill Maher
relationship_description [F3]:
  Insufficient context to determine relationship.

  The email excerpts provided are primarily from Michael Wolff to Jeffrey E., discussing various political and media matters, along with some joke emails from "jokeland@aol.com." There are no emails shown that involve Bill Maher as a sender or recipient, nor any content that references Bill Maher or describes interactions between him and Jeffrey Epstein.

discussion_ids:
  ["IMAGES-011-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_030688.txt_16248", "IMAGES-011-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_030689.txt_17626", "IMAGES-011-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_030691.txt_9598", "IMAGES-011-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_030693.txt_6602", "IMAGES-011-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_030775.txt_23500", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_023550.txt_11559", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_029752.txt_4725", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_030689.txt_7682", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_030691.txt_18968", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_030693.txt_16539", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_030696.txt_14968", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_030699.txt_11826"]


canonical_name [F2d]: Eddie Murphy
relationship_description [F3]:
  Insufficient context to determine relationship.

  The email excerpts contain joke content and business discussions mentioning someone named "murphy" in a corporate context (described as COO rather than CFO), but there is no clear indication that this refers to Eddie Murphy the entertainer, nor is there any direct connection established between Eddie Murphy and Jeffrey Epstein in these communications.

discussion_ids:
  ["IMAGES-007-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_023272.txt_6175", "IMAGES-007-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_023348.txt_7598", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_023550.txt_11559", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_029752.txt_4725"]


canonical_name [F2d]: Andrew Friendly
relationship_description [F3]:
  Based on the email excerpts, Andrew Friendly appears to have had a social relationship with Jeffrey Epstein, facilitated through his connection to Kelly Friendly (likely a family member). The emails indicate Andrew visited Epstein's private island and benefited from Epstein's hospitality, including use of his car and transportation arrangements in St. Thomas. The relationship seems to have involved social visits and personal favors, with a tone of gratitude for Epstein's "overwhelming generosity."

discussion_ids:
  ["IMAGES-008-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_026462.txt_12613", "IMAGES-008-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_026464.txt_9395", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_023612.txt_18802", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_023616.txt_13422", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_023621.txt_9233", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_026461.txt_4727", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_026463.txt_4970", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_031174.txt_19163"]


canonical_name [F2d]: Ann Marie C. Villafana
relationship_description [F3]:
  Based on these email excerpts, Ann Marie C. Villafana was a federal prosecutor who handled Jeffrey Epstein's criminal case and negotiated a non-prosecution agreement on his behalf. The emails show extensive professional correspondence between Villafana and Epstein's attorney Jay Lefkowitz regarding plea negotiations, victim compensation procedures, and finalizing the controversial deal that allowed Epstein to avoid federal indictment. The tone indicates a standard prosecutorial relationship, with Villafana setting firm deadlines for concluding negotiations while working through the legal and procedural details of the agreement.

discussion_ids:
  ["IMAGES-002-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_012614.txt_7997", "IMAGES-002-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_012617.txt_9580", "IMAGES-002-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_012620.txt_13035", "IMAGES-002-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_012625.txt_17956", "IMAGES-002-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_012628.txt_7928", "IMAGES-002-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_012631.txt_17922", "IMAGES-002-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_012632.txt_16323", "IMAGES-006-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_021740.txt_23758", "IMAGES-007-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_022834.txt_19644", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_021740.txt_10316", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_022834.txt_4796"]


canonical_name [F2d]: James Flynn
relationship_description [F3]:
  Insufficient context to determine relationship.

  The email excerpts show James Flynn being mentioned only in forwarded content from John Brockman to Jeffrey Epstein, where Flynn is discussed in an academic/intellectual context regarding his work on "shorthand abstractions" and scientific concepts. There is no direct communication between Flynn and Epstein, nor any indication of personal, professional, or other direct interaction between them in these materials.

discussion_ids:
  ["IMAGES-008-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_026463.txt_11720", "IMAGES-010-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_029901.txt_25635", "IMAGES-011-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_031560.txt_9745", "IMAGES-011-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_032056.txt_11449", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_026463.txt_4970", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_029901.txt_12854", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_031545.txt_12353", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_031560.txt_13465"]


canonical_name [F2d]: Richard Nixon
relationship_description [F3]:
  Insufficient context to determine relationship.

  The email excerpts provided do not contain any direct communication between Richard Nixon and Jeffrey Epstein, nor do they describe any relationship between the two individuals. The mentions of Nixon appear only in the context of historical references to his impeachment proceedings, while the emails themselves appear to be from a much later time period discussing contemporary political matters.

discussion_ids:
  ["IMAGES-005-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_019845.txt_25374", "IMAGES-008-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_026463.txt_11720", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_026463.txt_4970", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_026612.txt_7708", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_028487.txt_22632"]


canonical_name [F2d]: Bill Burns
relationship_description [F3]:
  Based on these email excerpts, Jeffrey Epstein appears to have had social and professional connections with high-level government and diplomatic circles that included Bill Burns. The emails suggest Epstein was arranging informal meetings and dinners with prominent figures including Burns (described as "the diplomat's diplomat"), and was part of networks that included former Obama White House counsel Kathy Ruemmler and other senior national security officials. The tone suggests these were casual social interactions among individuals who moved in elite political and policy circles.

discussion_ids:
  ["IMAGES-007-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_023419.txt_15013", "IMAGES-010-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_028856.txt_19064", "IMAGES-010-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_028859.txt_9423", "IMAGES-010-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_029910.txt_20887", "IMAGES-010-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_029912.txt_21130", "IMAGES-010-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_030215.txt_17803", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_023418.txt_12069", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_025820.txt_24155", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_025827.txt_19439", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_025834.txt_24111", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_028859.txt_22358", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_028866.txt_20714", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_028870.txt_21274", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_028875.txt_22800", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_029213.txt_21376", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_029910.txt_8068", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_029912.txt_8119", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_030215.txt_4998"]


canonical_name [F2d]: Ozan Tarman
relationship_description [F3]:
  Insufficient context to determine relationship.

  The email excerpts show communications between Jeffrey Epstein and Landon Thomas Jr. regarding hedge fund information, and a separate financial market analysis from Ozan Tarman, but there is no direct communication or clear connection shown between Ozan Tarman and Jeffrey Epstein in these particular excerpts.

discussion_ids:
  ["IMAGES-007-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_023635.txt_18468", "IMAGES-007-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_023717.txt_5010", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_023635.txt_9180", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_023717.txt_22273"]


canonical_name [F2d]: Stephen Ross
relationship_description [F3]:
  Insufficient context to determine relationship.

  The email excerpts don't provide clear information about the nature of Stephen Ross's relationship with Jeffrey Epstein. While the emails suggest some connection involving legal strategy discussions and potentially shared interests in Palm Beach real estate, there isn't enough context to determine whether their relationship was primarily professional, social, or what specific role Ross played in Epstein's affairs.

discussion_ids:
  ["IMAGES-009-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_027063.txt_18502", "IMAGES-010-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_030295.txt_6383", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_030229.txt_5066", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_030295.txt_19307"]


canonical_name [F2d]: George Krassner
relationship_description [F3]:
  Insufficient context to determine relationship.

  The email excerpts provided do not contain any mention of Jeffrey Epstein or any interactions between George Krassner and Jeffrey Epstein. The emails appear to be discussions about magazine publishing, particularly regarding Cavalier magazine, and other unrelated topics, but provide no information about any relationship with Jeffrey Epstein.

discussion_ids:
  ["IMAGES-008-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_024923.txt_11406", "IMAGES-008-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_025329.txt_22756", "IMAGES-011-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_031973.txt_18102", "IMAGES-012-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_033568.txt_5358", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_024923.txt_5159", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_025329.txt_16453", "TEXT-002-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_031973.txt_25230", "TEXT-002-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_033568.txt_21016"]


canonical_name [F2d]: Isaac Asimov
relationship_description [F3]:
  Insufficient context to determine relationship.

  The email excerpts only mention Isaac Asimov in passing as one of several notable writers who contributed to Cavalier magazine in the 1950s-60s. There is no mention of Jeffrey Epstein anywhere in these emails, nor any content that would indicate a relationship between Asimov and Epstein.

discussion_ids:
  ["IMAGES-008-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_024624.txt_23385", "IMAGES-008-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_024923.txt_11406", "IMAGES-011-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_031973.txt_18102", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_024624.txt_17226", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_024923.txt_5159", "TEXT-002-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_031973.txt_25230"]


canonical_name [F2d]: Philip Roth
relationship_description [F3]:
  Insufficient context to determine relationship.

  The email excerpts provided do not contain any information about a relationship between Philip Roth and Jeffrey Epstein. The emails only mention Philip Roth in passing as one of several notable writers who contributed to Cavalier magazine in the 1950s-60s, and there is no reference to Jeffrey Epstein anywhere in the provided content.

discussion_ids:
  ["IMAGES-008-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_024624.txt_23385", "IMAGES-008-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_024923.txt_11406", "IMAGES-011-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_031973.txt_18102", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_024624.txt_17226", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_024923.txt_5159", "TEXT-002-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_031973.txt_25230"]


canonical_name [F2d]: Rebecca Risman
relationship_description [F3]:
  Insufficient context to determine relationship.

  The provided email excerpts are from Paul Krassner to George Krassner discussing Cavalier magazine's history and writers. While one email appears to include "Rebecca Risman" in a recipient list, there is no actual content about Rebecca Risman or Jeffrey Epstein, nor any indication of their relationship to each other.

discussion_ids:
  ["IMAGES-008-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_024923.txt_11406", "IMAGES-011-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_031973.txt_18102", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_024923.txt_5159", "TEXT-002-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_031973.txt_25230"]


canonical_name [F2d]: Theodore Sturgeon
relationship_description [F3]:
  Insufficient context to determine relationship.

  The email excerpts only mention Theodore Sturgeon as one of several notable writers who contributed to Cavalier magazine in the 1950s, but contain no references to Jeffrey Epstein or any interactions between Sturgeon and Epstein.

discussion_ids:
  ["IMAGES-008-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_024624.txt_23385", "IMAGES-008-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_024923.txt_11406", "IMAGES-011-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_031973.txt_18102", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_024624.txt_17226", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_024923.txt_5159", "TEXT-002-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_031973.txt_25230"]


canonical_name [F2d]: Thomas Pynchon
relationship_description [F3]:
  Insufficient context to determine relationship.

  The email excerpts provided do not mention Jeffrey Epstein at all. They only discuss Thomas Pynchon in the context of being a writer who contributed to Cavalier magazine in the 1950s-60s, along with other notable authors like Philip Roth and Isaac Asimov.

discussion_ids:
[cell repeats an earlier one in this file: 275 characters]


canonical_name [F2d]: William Saroyan
relationship_description [F3]:
  Insufficient context to determine relationship.

  The email excerpts provided do not contain any information about a relationship between William Saroyan and Jeffrey Epstein. The emails only mention Saroyan in passing as one of several notable writers who contributed to Cavalier magazine in the 1950s-60s, and there is no reference to Jeffrey Epstein anywhere in the provided content.

discussion_ids:
[cell repeats an earlier one in this file: 275 characters]


canonical_name [F2d]: Susan Rice
relationship_description [F3]:
  Insufficient context to determine relationship.

  The email excerpts do not contain any direct communication between Susan Rice and Jeffrey Epstein. While there are references to Susan Rice in news article links shared between other parties, and mentions of discussing "Flynn focus" in what appears to be political/legal strategy conversations, there is no evidence in these excerpts of any direct interaction or relationship between Rice and Epstein.

discussion_ids:
  ["IMAGES-008-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_025647.txt_5194", "IMAGES-008-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_026254.txt_14033", "IMAGES-008-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_026264.txt_12360", "IMAGES-008-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_026269.txt_13487", "IMAGES-008-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_026270.txt_12386", "IMAGES-008-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_026473.txt_7768", "IMAGES-008-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_026474.txt_10071", "IMAGES-009-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_026787.txt_19133", "IMAGES-012-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_032727.txt_20623", "IMAGES-012-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_033073.txt_18619", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_025649.txt_15921", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_026254.txt_20204", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_026255.txt_20138", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_026258.txt_5689", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_026787.txt_15676", "TEXT-002-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_033073.txt_9449"]


canonical_name [F2d]: George Mitchell
relationship_description [F3]:
  Based on these email excerpts, George Mitchell appears to have been included in Epstein's professional/social network, specifically being listed for a "Seminar-POWER" event alongside other high-profile political and business figures like Bill Clinton and Bill Gates. The context suggests this was likely related to Epstein's practice of hosting intellectual gatherings or seminars with prominent individuals.

  However, the emails provide insufficient context to determine the depth, frequency, or specific nature of any direct relationship between Mitchell and Epstein beyond this seminar invitation.

discussion_ids:
  ["IMAGES-005-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_019871.txt_5271", "IMAGES-010-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_029622.txt_15184", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_022994.txt_5723", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_026549.txt_12202", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_028784.txt_18916"]


canonical_name [F2d]: Erika Najarian
relationship_description [F3]:
  Insufficient context to determine relationship.

  The email excerpts show Amanda Ens from Bank of America Merrill Lynch sharing financial research analysis by Erika Najarian with Jeffrey E., but there is no direct communication between Erika Najarian and Jeffrey Epstein in these emails. Erika Najarian is only mentioned as the BAML research analyst who conducted the financials research being shared.

discussion_ids:
  ["IMAGES-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_011277.txt_5313", "IMAGES-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_011280.txt_25212", "IMAGES-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_012044.txt_10158", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_011277.txt_12934", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_012044.txt_21085"]


canonical_name [F2d]: Diana deGette
relationship_description [F3]:
  Insufficient context to determine relationship.

  The email excerpts provided are all from Barbro C. Ehnbom to Jeffrey Epstein, not involving Diana deGette. There is no mention of Diana deGette in any of these communications, so no relationship between Diana deGette and Jeffrey Epstein can be determined from these materials.

discussion_ids:
  ["IMAGES-004-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_017523.txt_11953", "IMAGES-010-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_028752.txt_5347", "IMAGES-011-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_031213.txt_11353", "IMAGES-011-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_031221.txt_12990", "IMAGES-011-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_031226.txt_17741", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_017523.txt_5346", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_026569.txt_18513", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_028752.txt_18350", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_031213.txt_14028", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_031221.txt_10286", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_031226.txt_7552"]


canonical_name [F2d]: Greta Tufvesson
relationship_description [F3]:
  Insufficient context to determine relationship.

  The emails only contain a brief mention that Barbro Ehnbom hoped "Greta Tufvesson got hold of you re research service," but provide no direct communication between Greta Tufvesson and Jeffrey Epstein, nor any details about the nature or extent of their potential interaction.

discussion_ids:
  ["IMAGES-004-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_017523.txt_11953", "IMAGES-010-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_028752.txt_5347", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_017523.txt_5346", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_026569.txt_18513", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_028752.txt_18350"]


canonical_name [F2d]: Jeff Kriendler
relationship_description [F3]:
  I cannot provide a description of Jeff Kriendler's relationship with Jeffrey Epstein based on these email excerpts, as none of the emails shown are from or to Jeff Kriendler. All the emails provided are correspondence between Barbro C. Ehnbom and Jeffrey Epstein, discussing various professional matters including summit invitations, research services, and travel plans. To assess Kriendler's relationship with Epstein, I would need to see actual email exchanges involving Jeff Kriendler.

discussion_ids:
  ["IMAGES-004-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_017523.txt_11953", "IMAGES-010-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_028752.txt_5347", "IMAGES-011-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_031213.txt_11353", "IMAGES-011-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_031221.txt_12990", "IMAGES-011-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_031226.txt_17741", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_017523.txt_5346", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_026569.txt_18513", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_028752.txt_18350", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_031213.txt_14028", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_031221.txt_10286", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_031226.txt_7552"]


canonical_name [F2d]: Daniel Dawson
relationship_description [F3]:
  Insufficient context to determine relationship.

  The email excerpts provided do not contain any mention of Daniel Dawson or Jeffrey Epstein. The emails appear to be between Daryl Cagle and Paul Krassner discussing topics like political cartoons, Howard Schultz, Starbucks logos, and a work called "The Last of the Manson Girls."

discussion_ids:
  ["IMAGES-008-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_025329.txt_22756", "IMAGES-012-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_033568.txt_5358", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_025329.txt_16453", "TEXT-002-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_033568.txt_21016"]


canonical_name [F2d]: Paul Morris
relationship_description [F3]:
  Based on the email excerpts, Paul Morris and Jeffrey Epstein appear to have had a professional relationship centered around financial or tax advisory services. Morris discusses introducing Epstein to senior colleagues, shares information about tax breaks and investment opportunities, and references working with "large clients," suggesting Morris may have been providing financial consulting or tax planning services to Epstein. The tone of their interactions appears business-focused and collaborative, with Morris offering expertise and resources to Epstein as a client or business contact.

discussion_ids:
  ["IMAGES-003-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_014525.txt_19942", "IMAGES-003-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_016413.txt_11857", "IMAGES-006-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_022260.txt_22872", "IMAGES-006-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_022272.txt_19725", "IMAGES-006-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_022275.txt_23828", "IMAGES-006-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_022322.txt_5375", "IMAGES-006-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_022346.txt_9123", "IMAGES-006-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_022359.txt_13432", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_014525.txt_18750", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_016413.txt_976", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_016801.txt_21492", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_022260.txt_10879", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_022262.txt_11878", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_022275.txt_10250", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_022322.txt_19079", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_022346.txt_21380", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_022359.txt_1347"]


canonical_name [F2d]: Vinit Sahni
relationship_description [F3]:
  Based on these email excerpts, Vinit Sahni appears to have had a professional financial services relationship with Jeffrey Epstein, likely involving trading or investment management. The exchanges show Epstein expressing frustration with slow response times in a "fast moving market," while Sahni provided market analysis on topics like S&P 500 performance and volatility levels. Paul Morris served as an intermediary who introduced Sahni to Epstein, and the tone suggests a client-service provider dynamic where Epstein was dissatisfied with the speed of service delivery.

discussion_ids:
  ["IMAGES-006-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_022260.txt_22872", "IMAGES-006-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_022262.txt_25471", "IMAGES-006-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_022272.txt_19725", "IMAGES-006-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_022322.txt_5375", "IMAGES-006-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_022346.txt_9123", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_022260.txt_10879", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_022262.txt_11878", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_022272.txt_7521", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_022322.txt_19079", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_022346.txt_21380"]


canonical_name [F2d]: Joseph Palazzolo
relationship_description [F3]:
  Based on the email excerpt, Joseph Palazzolo appears to be a journalist seeking comment from Jeffrey Epstein's representatives regarding a legal case involving Epstein and Donald Trump in the Southern District of New York. The relationship is professional in nature, with Palazzolo contacting Epstein's team (through Michael Miller) for a statement on a story he was preparing to publish online. The interaction suggests a typical reporter-subject dynamic where Palazzolo was covering legal proceedings involving Epstein.

discussion_ids:
  ["IMAGES-011-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_032306.txt_15724", "IMAGES-012-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_032892.txt_5420", "TEXT-002-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_032304.txt_20749", "TEXT-002-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_032306.txt_21217"]


canonical_name [F2d]: Bruce Moskowitz
relationship_description [F3]:
  Based on the email excerpts, Bruce Moskowitz and Jeffrey Epstein appear to have had a professional relationship centered around medical/cancer research technology. The emails show Moskowitz sharing information about cancer research initiatives (including links about Trump administration cancer programs) and acknowledging Epstein's input with messages like "you were right." The tone suggests a collaborative dynamic where Epstein may have provided advice or insights related to Moskowitz's work in cancer research databases and clinical trial platforms.

discussion_ids:
  ["IMAGES-005-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_019211.txt_19162", "IMAGES-008-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_025944.txt_14924", "IMAGES-008-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_025945.txt_15681", "IMAGES-011-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_032394.txt_5441", "IMAGES-011-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_032404.txt_24654", "IMAGES-012-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_033198.txt_24132", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_019211.txt_15659", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_025944.txt_21670", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_025945.txt_21917", "TEXT-002-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_032394.txt_12609", "TEXT-002-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_032404.txt_19089", "TEXT-002-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_033198.txt_1147"]


canonical_name [F2d]: Jackie Perczel
relationship_description [F3]:
  Based on the email excerpts, Jackie Perczel appears to have served in a media relations or communications role for Jeffrey Epstein during his legal proceedings. The emails show attorneys like Martin Weinberg and Darren Indyke coordinating with Perczel on handling media inquiries about Epstein's case, including requests for comments on allegations involving Virginia Giuffre and sharing news articles about the legal proceedings. The relationship appears to be professional, with Perczel functioning as an intermediary between Epstein's legal team and journalists seeking statements or responses regarding the ongoing litigation.

discussion_ids:
  ["IMAGES-002-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_013405.txt_25096", "IMAGES-002-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_013415.txt_20176", "IMAGES-007-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_022818.txt_25551", "IMAGES-007-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_022820.txt_19615", "IMAGES-007-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_022823.txt_21279", "IMAGES-012-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_033361.txt_21336", "IMAGES-012-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_033512.txt_14019", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_013405.txt_22658", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_013415.txt_22573", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_022817.txt_24236", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_022822.txt_4908", "TEXT-002-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_033361.txt_5499", "TEXT-002-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_033512.txt_11338"]


canonical_name [F2d]: John Humphrys
relationship_description [F3]:
  Insufficient context to determine relationship.

  The email excerpts show only promotional materials for an Intelligence Squared event featuring John Humphrys, along with one unrelated email about a Turkish cleric. There is no direct communication between John Humphrys and Jeffrey Epstein, nor any content indicating they had any form of relationship.

discussion_ids:
  ["IMAGES-010-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_030434.txt_8773", "IMAGES-010-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_030445.txt_5505", "IMAGES-011-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_031484.txt_21773", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_030434.txt_21783", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_030445.txt_18497"]


canonical_name [F2d]: Justin Webb
relationship_description [F3]:
  Insufficient context to determine relationship.

  The email excerpts provided are primarily promotional materials for an Intelligence Squared event featuring BBC Radio 4 presenters John Humphrys and Justin Webb, along with one unrelated email about a Turkish cleric. There is no direct communication between Justin Webb and Jeffrey Epstein, nor any content that would indicate the nature of any relationship between them.

discussion_ids:
  ["IMAGES-010-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_030434.txt_8773", "IMAGES-010-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_030445.txt_5505", "IMAGES-011-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_031484.txt_21773", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_030434.txt_21783", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_030445.txt_18497"]


canonical_name [F2d]: John Kerry
relationship_description [F3]:
  Insufficient context to determine relationship.

  The email excerpts provided do not contain any direct correspondence between John Kerry and Jeffrey Epstein, nor do they reference John Kerry in any way. The emails shown are brief fragments from Jeffrey Epstein to unspecified recipients, with no clear connection to Kerry that would allow for any assessment of their relationship.

discussion_ids:
  ["IMAGES-010-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_029622.txt_15184", "IMAGES-012-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_032877.txt_22145", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_026517.txt_5580", "TEXT-002-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_032877.txt_6393"]


canonical_name [F2d]: Richard John Nawrot
relationship_description [F3]:
  Insufficient context to determine relationship.

  The email excerpts show Richard John Nawrot communicating with Terje Rod-Larsen about infrastructure investment matters, while separate emails show Rod-Larsen communicating with Jeffrey Epstein, but there is no direct communication or clear connection established between Nawrot and Epstein in the provided excerpts.

discussion_ids:
  ["IMAGES-008-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_025547.txt_12256", "IMAGES-010-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_028506.txt_18426", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_025547.txt_5925", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_028506.txt_5620"]


canonical_name [F2d]: Terje Rod-Larsen
relationship_description [F3]:
  Insufficient context to determine relationship.

  The email excerpts show that Terje Rod-Larsen sent emails to Jeffrey Epstein's email address, but the content of those emails is not provided - only the headers indicating they were sent from an iPhone. Without the actual message content, it's impossible to determine the nature, context, or tone of their interactions.

discussion_ids:
  ["IMAGES-008-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_025547.txt_12256", "IMAGES-010-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_028506.txt_18426", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_025547.txt_5925", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_028506.txt_5620"]


canonical_name [F2d]: Henry Kissinger
relationship_description [F3]:
  Insufficient context to determine relationship.

  The email excerpts only contain brief, fragmented references to Henry Kissinger in the context of what appears to be media/interview scheduling discussions between Jeffrey Epstein and Lisa New. Kissinger is mentioned only as someone who could potentially attend a breakfast meeting and as being on a list of politicians available for taping/interviews, but there's no direct communication with Kissinger or details about the nature of any relationship between him and Epstein.

discussion_ids:
  ["IMAGES-007-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_023198.txt_12280", "IMAGES-007-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_023202.txt_8479", "IMAGES-007-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_023205.txt_12650", "IMAGES-009-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_027034.txt_5685", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_023198.txt_14939", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_023202.txt_19202", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_023205.txt_14608"]


canonical_name [F2d]: Alec Baldwin
relationship_description [F3]:
  Insufficient context to determine relationship.

  The email excerpts only show Glenn Dubin and Jeffrey Epstein sharing news articles about Alec Baldwin's Saturday Night Live parodies of Donald Trump in 2016-2017. There is no evidence of any direct communication, meetings, or relationship between Alec Baldwin and Jeffrey Epstein in these materials.

discussion_ids:
  ["IMAGES-010-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_030348.txt_18710", "IMAGES-010-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_030385.txt_8869", "IMAGES-012-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_032948.txt_15872", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_030348.txt_5730", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_030385.txt_21640", "TEXT-002-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_032948.txt_12169"]


canonical_name [F2d]: Glenn Dubin
relationship_description [F3]:
  Based on the email excerpts, Glenn Dubin and Jeffrey Epstein appear to have had an informal social relationship where they shared news articles and political commentary. The emails show Dubin regularly forwarding links to Epstein about topics like Trump/SNL coverage, Michael Cohen, and Wall Street tax matters, suggesting they had ongoing casual communication about current events. The tone appears informal and friendly, indicating a personal rather than strictly professional relationship.

discussion_ids:
  ["IMAGES-007-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_023564.txt_8457", "IMAGES-010-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_028494.txt_7979", "IMAGES-010-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_029910.txt_20887", "IMAGES-010-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_030348.txt_18710", "IMAGES-010-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_030385.txt_8869", "IMAGES-010-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_030432.txt_11967", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_023564.txt_19204", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_030348.txt_5730", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_030385.txt_21640", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_030432.txt_24897"]


canonical_name [F2d]: Heidi
relationship_description [F3]:
  Insufficient context to determine relationship.

  The provided email excerpts are all from Jonathan Farkas discussing someone named Heidi, but contain no mention of Jeffrey Epstein or any interactions between Heidi and Epstein that would allow me to characterize their relationship.

discussion_ids:
  ["IMAGES-010-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_028507.txt_18708", "IMAGES-012-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_033490.txt_7865", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_028507.txt_5731", "TEXT-002-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_033490.txt_17049"]


canonical_name [F2d]: James Cohen
relationship_description [F3]:
  Insufficient context to determine relationship.

  The email excerpts only mention James Cohen in passing as someone Jonathan Farkas visited at his house, describing Cohen as "a nice guy" who had sold Hudson News. There is no direct communication between James Cohen and Jeffrey Epstein, nor any indication of how Cohen might be connected to Epstein beyond being mentioned in emails sent to what appears to be an Epstein email address.

discussion_ids:
  ["IMAGES-012-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_032730.txt_22220", "IMAGES-012-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_033075.txt_15376", "TEXT-002-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_032730.txt_5819", "TEXT-002-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_033075.txt_12725"]


canonical_name [F2d]: Stephanie Winston Wolkoff
relationship_description [F3]:
  Insufficient context to determine relationship.

  The emails only show Jeffrey Epstein (J) and Nicholas Ribis sharing a New York Times article about Stephanie Winston Wolkoff's Trump inauguration controversy, with a brief comment referring to her as "our friend," but provide no details about the actual nature, context, or scope of any relationship between Epstein and Winston Wolkoff.

discussion_ids:
  ["IMAGES-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_011907.txt_21754", "IMAGES-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_012102.txt_14229", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_011907.txt_10028", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_012102.txt_5843"]


canonical_name [F2d]: Stephen Moore
relationship_description [F3]:
  Insufficient context to determine relationship.

  The email excerpts provided do not contain any direct communication between Stephen Moore and Jeffrey Epstein, nor do they reference any interactions, meetings, or relationship between the two individuals. The excerpts only show Stephen Moore's name as the author of an article about "Atlas Shrugged" that was being shared between other parties.

discussion_ids:
  ["IMAGES-008-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_025295.txt_5846", "IMAGES-010-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_030235.txt_12898", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_025295.txt_12477", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_030235.txt_25677"]


canonical_name [F2d]: Bill Siegel
relationship_description [F3]:
  Based on the email excerpts, Bill Siegel and Jeffrey Epstein appear to have had a casual social relationship where Siegel regularly shared political articles and commentary with Epstein, particularly content related to national security and radical Islam from conservative publications. Epstein's brief, informal responses ("SAAAAAAAAAAAFe good boy" and congratulating Siegel while expressing hope to see him soon) suggest a friendly, though not necessarily close, personal connection. The tone indicates they knew each other well enough for regular communication and planned to meet in person, but the relationship seems primarily centered around Siegel sharing his political interests with Epstein.

discussion_ids:
  ["IMAGES-007-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_024384.txt_10910", "IMAGES-007-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_024407.txt_13413", "IMAGES-007-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_024419.txt_8697", "IMAGES-008-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_025028.txt_16695", "IMAGES-011-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_031688.txt_5894", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_024384.txt_13574", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_024395.txt_18390", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_024407.txt_10639", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_024419.txt_18604", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_025028.txt_23256", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_031688.txt_22507"]


canonical_name [F2d]: Daniel Kahneman
relationship_description [F3]:
  Based on these email excerpts, Daniel Kahneman appears to have been included on Epstein's contact lists for intellectual or business seminars, specifically being listed multiple times for a "Seminar-MONEY" event. The relationship appears to be professional/academic in nature, as Kahneman is grouped with other prominent figures from technology, finance, and academia. However, these emails only show him being included on invitation lists rather than any direct interaction, so the depth or actual existence of any personal relationship cannot be determined from this limited context.

discussion_ids:
  ["IMAGES-009-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_026549.txt_9596", "IMAGES-010-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_028784.txt_5939", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_026549.txt_12202", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_028784.txt_18916"]


canonical_name [F2d]: Dick Merkin
relationship_description [F3]:
  Based on the email excerpts, Dick Merkin appears to have been considered for inclusion in what seems to be a professional or intellectual seminar organized by Jeffrey Epstein, specifically for a "Seminar-MONEY" focused event. The question mark next to Merkin's name suggests uncertainty about his participation or availability. The context indicates a potential professional or networking relationship, though the limited information and tentative notation make it unclear how established their actual relationship was.

discussion_ids:
  ["IMAGES-009-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_026549.txt_9596", "IMAGES-010-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_028784.txt_5939", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_026549.txt_12202", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_028784.txt_18916"]


canonical_name [F2d]: Eric Schmidt
relationship_description [F3]:
  Insufficient context to determine relationship.

  The email excerpts only show Eric Schmidt's name appearing on what appears to be guest lists for seminars organized by or for Jeffrey Epstein, with topics labeled "MONEY" and "POWER." There is no direct communication between Schmidt and Epstein, nor any details about the nature of their interactions, whether Schmidt actually attended these events, or the specific context of any relationship they may have had.

discussion_ids:
  ["IMAGES-007-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_023454.txt_24678", "IMAGES-009-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_026549.txt_9596", "IMAGES-010-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_028784.txt_5939", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_026549.txt_12202", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_028784.txt_18916"]


canonical_name [F2d]: Jaron Lanier
relationship_description [F3]:
  Based on these email excerpts, Jaron Lanier appears to have been on an invitation list for what seems to be a professional or intellectual seminar organized by Jeffrey Epstein, specifically one labeled "Seminar-MONEY" that included various tech industry leaders and entrepreneurs. The emails show only administrative planning communications from Epstein's assistant, with no direct interaction between Lanier and Epstein evident in these excerpts. The context suggests a potential professional or intellectual networking relationship, though the emails provide insufficient detail to determine the actual nature or extent of any relationship between them.

discussion_ids:
  ["IMAGES-009-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_026549.txt_9596", "IMAGES-010-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_028784.txt_5939", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_026549.txt_12202", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_028784.txt_18916"]


canonical_name [F2d]: Jeff Bezos
relationship_description [F3]:
  Insufficient context to determine relationship.

  The emails only show Jeff Bezos's name listed among other prominent figures on what appears to be a "Seminar-MONEY" invitation or attendee list being compiled by Lesley Groff for Jeffrey Epstein. There is no direct communication between Bezos and Epstein, nor any indication of the nature, frequency, or context of any actual relationship between them.

discussion_ids:
  ["IMAGES-007-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_023454.txt_24678", "IMAGES-009-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_026549.txt_9596", "IMAGES-010-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_028784.txt_5939", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_026549.txt_12202", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_028784.txt_18916", "TEXT-002-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_033568.txt_21016"]


canonical_name [F2d]: Jim Simons
relationship_description [F3]:
  Based on these email excerpts, Jim Simons appears to have been considered for inclusion in Jeffrey Epstein's professional or intellectual circles, specifically for what seems to be a "MONEY" seminar or gathering. The emails show Simons' name on guest lists alongside other prominent figures from technology and finance, suggesting a potential professional or networking relationship. However, these excerpts only show planning documents and don't provide sufficient context to determine the actual nature, extent, or tone of any direct relationship between Simons and Epstein.

discussion_ids:
[cell repeats an earlier one in this file: 182 characters]


canonical_name [F2d]: Paul Batista
relationship_description [F3]:
  Based on these email excerpts, Paul Batista appears to have been considered for inclusion in what seems to be a "money" seminar or gathering organized by Jeffrey Epstein. However, Lesley Groff's notation "(Not sure this is who you mean)" suggests uncertainty about Batista's identity or appropriateness for the event, indicating a potentially distant or unclear connection to Epstein's circle. The limited context suggests a possible professional or networking relationship, but the uncertainty expressed makes the exact nature of their relationship ambiguous.

discussion_ids:
[cell repeats an earlier one in this file: 182 characters]


canonical_name [F2d]: Sergey Brin
relationship_description [F3]:
  Insufficient context to determine relationship.

  The email excerpts only show Sergey Brin's name appearing on what appears to be guest lists for seminars organized by or for Jeffrey Epstein (labeled "Seminar-MONEY"), alongside other prominent tech and business figures. There is no direct communication between Brin and Epstein, nor any details about the nature, extent, or tone of any potential relationship between them.

discussion_ids:
  ["IMAGES-007-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_023454.txt_24678", "IMAGES-009-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_026549.txt_9596", "IMAGES-010-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_028784.txt_5939", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_026549.txt_12202", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_028784.txt_18916"]


canonical_name [F2d]: Conchita Sarnoff
relationship_description [F3]:
  Insufficient context to determine relationship.

  The email excerpts provided do not contain any direct correspondence between Conchita Sarnoff and Jeffrey Epstein, nor do they provide meaningful information about their relationship. The only mention appears to be Sarnoff's name associated with what seems to be a critical article or post about Epstein, but this alone does not establish the nature of any relationship between them.

discussion_ids:
  ["IMAGES-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_012019.txt_6052", "IMAGES-010-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_029625.txt_18758", "IMAGES-011-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_031748.txt_12688", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_031748.txt_15313"]


canonical_name [F2d]: Newt Gingrich
relationship_description [F3]:
  Insufficient context to determine relationship.

  The email excerpts provided do not contain any direct communication between Newt Gingrich and Jeffrey Epstein, nor do they mention any relationship between the two individuals. The emails appear to be general political commentary and news sharing that only reference Gingrich in passing as a political figure being discussed in media debates or as an author of opinion pieces about Trump.

discussion_ids:
  ["IMAGES-008-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_025921.txt_24630", "IMAGES-008-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_025929.txt_6061", "IMAGES-011-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_031696.txt_23668", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_031696.txt_1626"]


canonical_name [F2d]: Jerrold Nadler
relationship_description [F3]:
  Insufficient context to determine relationship.

  The email excerpts are from David Schoen to someone else (jeevacation@gmail.com) discussing third-party websites and news articles that mention both Nadler and Epstein, but they don't contain any direct communication between Nadler and Epstein or provide reliable information about any actual relationship between them. The emails appear to be sharing questionable online content rather than documenting any genuine interactions.

discussion_ids:
  ["IMAGES-011-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_031344.txt_18367", "IMAGES-011-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_031775.txt_11577", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_031344.txt_8407", "TEXT-002-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_031775.txt_6085"]


canonical_name [F2d]: Ed Boyden
relationship_description [F3]:
  Based on these email excerpts, Ed Boyden appears to have had a professional relationship with Jeffrey Epstein, coordinated through Epstein's assistant Lesley Groff. The emails show Boyden canceling meetings (including one requiring plane travel) due to his work on the Obama BRAIN Initiative at MIT, suggesting they had scheduled professional discussions or consultations. The tone is polite and apologetic, indicating a formal but cordial professional interaction rather than a personal relationship.

discussion_ids:
  ["IMAGES-010-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_028852.txt_13277", "IMAGES-010-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_029207.txt_8335", "IMAGES-010-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_029209.txt_19114", "IMAGES-010-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_029324.txt_22099", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_028852.txt_273", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_029207.txt_21369", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_029209.txt_6138", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_029324.txt_9146"]


canonical_name [F2d]: Neil Gershenfeld
relationship_description [F3]:
  Based on these email excerpts, Neil Gershenfeld appears to have had a professional relationship with Jeffrey Epstein that involved in-person meetings at MIT. The emails show Gershenfeld confirming lunch meetings at his MIT office (E15-401) and suggesting these were preliminary to future meetings in "more entertaining venues." The tone appears cordial and suggests an ongoing professional interaction, though the limited context doesn't reveal the specific nature or purpose of their relationship.

discussion_ids:
  ["IMAGES-010-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_028852.txt_13277", "IMAGES-010-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_029207.txt_8335", "IMAGES-010-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_029209.txt_19114", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_029207.txt_21369", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_029209.txt_6138", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_029324.txt_9146"]


canonical_name [F2d]: Alan Halperin
relationship_description [F3]:
  Based on these email excerpts, Alan Halperin appears to have had a professional financial or legal advisory relationship with Jeffrey Epstein. The emails reference complex financial matters including credit lines with high daily interest costs ($50k+), tax strategies, art-related transactions, and what appears to be a substantial fee arrangement ($40 million annually). The tone suggests a business relationship involving high-stakes financial planning and wealth management, though some exchanges hint at tension around compensation and documentation of agreements.

discussion_ids:
  ["IMAGES-007-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_023212.txt_11088", "IMAGES-007-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_023241.txt_22181", "IMAGES-007-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_023266.txt_6189", "IMAGES-007-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_023295.txt_20704", "IMAGES-007-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_023321.txt_22040", "IMAGES-010-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_029344.txt_14067", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_029344.txt_1071"]


canonical_name [F2d]: Ben Rattray
relationship_description [F3]:
  Insufficient context to determine relationship.

  The email excerpts only show Ben Rattray being mentioned in Reid Hoffman's newsletter as the CEO of Change.org celebrating a milestone, with no direct communication between Rattray and Epstein or any indication of their interaction.

discussion_ids:
  ["IMAGES-010-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_029983.txt_11325", "IMAGES-010-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_030002.txt_19149", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_029983.txt_23993", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_030002.txt_6199"]


canonical_name [F2d]: Byron Auguste
relationship_description [F3]:
  Insufficient context to determine relationship.

  The email excerpts only mention Byron Auguste in the context of Reid Hoffman's newsletter updates about Auguste launching a new civic enterprise called Opportunity@Work. There is no direct communication between Byron Auguste and Jeffrey Epstein shown in these excerpts.

discussion_ids:
  ["IMAGES-010-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_029983.txt_11325", "IMAGES-010-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_030002.txt_19149", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_029983.txt_23993", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_030002.txt_6199"]


canonical_name [F2d]: Emily Chang
relationship_description [F3]:
  Insufficient context to determine relationship.

  The email excerpts mention Emily Chang only in the context of her role as a Bloomberg West host interviewing a CEO, with no direct communication between Emily Chang and Jeffrey Epstein shown. The emails appear to be from Reid Hoffman's newsletter/updates, but provide no information about any relationship between Emily Chang and Jeffrey Epstein.

discussion_ids:
  ["IMAGES-010-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_029983.txt_11325", "IMAGES-010-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_030002.txt_19149", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_029983.txt_23993", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_030002.txt_6199"]


canonical_name [F2d]: Sarah Tavel
relationship_description [F3]:
  Insufficient context to determine relationship.

  The email excerpts show Sarah Tavel being mentioned in Reid Hoffman's newsletter announcements about her joining Greylock Partners, but there is no direct communication between Sarah Tavel and Jeffrey Epstein, nor any indication of their having any relationship at all.

discussion_ids:
[cell repeats an earlier one in this file: 183 characters]


canonical_name [F2d]: Tom Friedman
relationship_description [F3]:
  Insufficient context to determine relationship.

  The provided email excerpts appear to be from Reid Hoffman to Jeffrey Epstein, not involving Tom Friedman. The brief messages only show casual communication about meeting plans and general well-wishes, without providing enough context to characterize the nature of their relationship or any specific business, social, or other interactions.

discussion_ids:
[cell repeats an earlier one in this file: 183 characters]


canonical_name [F2d]: Stephen Hawking
relationship_description [F3]:
  Based on these email excerpts, Stephen Hawking appears to have been falsely accused of sexual misconduct alongside Jeffrey Epstein, according to Epstein's own account. Epstein claims in an email to Michael Wolff that "the girl who claimed prince andrew had sex with her also accused stephen hawking and marvin minsky" and describes these accusations as "ludicrous." The emails suggest Epstein viewed Hawking as another victim of false allegations rather than indicating any direct relationship between them.

discussion_ids:
  ["IMAGES-007-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_022668.txt_11689", "IMAGES-007-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_022834.txt_19644", "IMAGES-007-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_022835.txt_20719", "IMAGES-007-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_022837.txt_21245", "IMAGES-007-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_022839.txt_6246", "IMAGES-010-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_030383.txt_12082", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_022668.txt_16018", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_022835.txt_3302", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_022839.txt_21066", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_022841.txt_11428", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_030383.txt_24822"]


canonical_name [F2d]: Ivanka Trump
relationship_description [F3]:
  Insufficient context to determine relationship.

  The email excerpts primarily show invitations to Jeffrey Epstein for a New York Observer anniversary event hosted by Jared Kushner in 2013, suggesting Epstein was considered part of New York's social/business elite at that time. However, there is no direct communication involving Ivanka Trump or specific details about any personal relationship between Ivanka Trump and Jeffrey Epstein in these excerpts.

discussion_ids:
  ["IMAGES-007-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_023545.txt_14863", "IMAGES-007-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_023548.txt_11028", "IMAGES-010-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_029505.txt_6261", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_023548.txt_13121", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_029505.txt_19038"]


canonical_name [F2d]: Neil deGrasse Tyson
relationship_description [F3]:
  Insufficient context to determine relationship.

  The email excerpts only contain references to Neil deGrasse Tyson in the form of a quote used in a Huffington Post article about private science funding that Epstein appears to have been involved with or mentioned in. There are no direct communications between Tyson and Epstein, nor any indication of personal or professional interactions between them in these materials.

discussion_ids:
  ["IMAGES-008-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_026165.txt_6344", "IMAGES-009-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_026755.txt_14167", "IMAGES-012-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_032565.txt_8262", "TEXT-002-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_032565.txt_18192", "TEXT-002-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_033016.txt_6277", "TEXT-002-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_033246.txt_12985"]


canonical_name [F2d]: Gordon Brown
relationship_description [F3]:
  Insufficient context to determine relationship.

  Gordon Brown is only mentioned once in these emails, appearing in a list of high-profile individuals that Epstein mentions having meetings with during what appears to be a climate summit or UN General Assembly week. There is no direct correspondence between Brown and Epstein, nor any details about the nature, frequency, or context of any potential interactions between them.

discussion_ids:
  ["IMAGES-007-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_023419.txt_15013", "IMAGES-010-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_028854.txt_16444", "IMAGES-010-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_028856.txt_19064", "IMAGES-010-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_028859.txt_9423", "IMAGES-010-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_028862.txt_11685", "IMAGES-010-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_029211.txt_7827", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_023418.txt_12069", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_025820.txt_24155", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_025827.txt_19439", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_025834.txt_24111", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_028856.txt_6285", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_028859.txt_22358", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_028866.txt_20714", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_028870.txt_21274", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_028875.txt_22800", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_029213.txt_21376"]


canonical_name [F2d]: Hardeep Puri
relationship_description [F3]:
  Insufficient context to determine relationship.

  The emails only mention Hardeep Puri in a list of high-profile individuals that Epstein was apparently meeting or hosting during what appears to be a climate summit or UN General Assembly week. There is no direct communication with Puri or details about the nature of any relationship between him and Epstein.

discussion_ids:
  ["IMAGES-007-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_023419.txt_15013", "IMAGES-010-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_028854.txt_16444", "IMAGES-010-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_028859.txt_9423", "IMAGES-010-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_028862.txt_11685", "IMAGES-010-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_029211.txt_7827", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_023418.txt_12069", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_025820.txt_24155", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_025827.txt_19439", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_025834.txt_24111", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_028856.txt_6285", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_028859.txt_22358", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_028870.txt_21274", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_028875.txt_22800", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_029211.txt_20626", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_029213.txt_21376"]


canonical_name [F2d]: Eric Maskin
relationship_description [F3]:
  Insufficient context to determine relationship.

  The email excerpts show communications between Eric Maskin and Larry Summers discussing ranked choice voting (RCV) and political theory, with no mention of Jeffrey Epstein. The emails appear to be forwarded to "jeevacation@gmail.com" but there is no indication this address belongs to Epstein or any context establishing a relationship between Maskin and Epstein.

discussion_ids:
  ["IMAGES-008-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_026321.txt_13238", "IMAGES-009-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_026508.txt_20897", "IMAGES-009-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_026509.txt_19470", "IMAGES-009-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_026510.txt_6397", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_026321.txt_19512"]


canonical_name [F2d]: Ralph Nader
relationship_description [F3]:
  Insufficient context to determine relationship.

  The email excerpts show Ralph Nader being mentioned only as a hypothetical example in a discussion about ranked choice voting between Larry Summers and Eric Maskin, where Summers notes that RCV "might encourage Ralph Nader cuz he'd get more first round votes and not elect George Bush." There is no direct communication between Nader and Epstein, nor any indication of personal or professional interaction between them in these exchanges.

discussion_ids:
  ["IMAGES-008-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_026323.txt_15787", "IMAGES-009-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_026510.txt_6397", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_026321.txt_19512", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_026508.txt_23378"]


canonical_name [F2d]: Jeb Bush
relationship_description [F3]:
  Insufficient context to determine relationship.

  These email excerpts do not show any direct relationship between Jeb Bush and Jeffrey Epstein. Jeb Bush is only mentioned by an unidentified third party who is writing to Epstein about having received more votes than Bush in Iowa, suggesting this person was involved in Republican politics during what appears to be a primary season.

discussion_ids:
  ["IMAGES-010-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_029958.txt_15965", "IMAGES-010-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_029962.txt_19166", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_029958.txt_3192", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_029962.txt_6431"]


canonical_name [F2d]: Eva Lewis
relationship_description [F3]:
  Insufficient context to determine relationship.

  The email excerpts mention "Lewis" only in passing as someone invited to dinner gatherings, but do not provide enough information to establish the specific nature of Eva Lewis's relationship with Jeffrey Epstein, the context of their interactions, or the tone of their communications.

discussion_ids:
  ["IMAGES-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_011905.txt_20183", "IMAGES-010-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_029976.txt_19215", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_011904.txt_11678", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_029976.txt_6437"]


canonical_name [F2d]: Alan Fraade
relationship_description [F3]:
  Insufficient context to determine relationship.

  The provided email excerpts do not contain any communications involving Alan Fraade with Jeffrey Epstein. The emails are primarily from Steven Hoffenberg to various recipients discussing political matters, with some redacted communications from Darren Indyke to Epstein, but no content involving Alan Fraade is present in these excerpts.

discussion_ids:
  ["IMAGES-011-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_031196.txt_15539", "IMAGES-011-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_031204.txt_12908", "IMAGES-011-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_031207.txt_11368", "IMAGES-011-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_031228.txt_6533", "IMAGES-011-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_031231.txt_19335", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_026849.txt_21246", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_031195.txt_11328", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_031206.txt_13441", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_031230.txt_8617"]


canonical_name [F2d]: Gary Baise
relationship_description [F3]:
  Insufficient context to determine relationship.

  The provided email excerpts do not contain any direct communication between Gary Baise and Jeffrey Epstein, nor do they mention any interactions between them. The emails are primarily from Steven Hoffenberg to Gary Baise regarding food policy and Trump administration matters, with separate fragmentary emails involving Epstein's associates but no clear connection to Baise.

discussion_ids:
  ["IMAGES-011-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_031193.txt_17262", "IMAGES-011-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_031204.txt_12908", "IMAGES-011-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_031207.txt_11368", "IMAGES-011-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_031228.txt_6533", "IMAGES-011-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_031231.txt_19335", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_031203.txt_18352", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_031206.txt_13441", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_031227.txt_7029", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_031230.txt_8617"]


canonical_name [F2d]: Ann Coulter
relationship_description [F3]:
  Based on these email excerpts, Ann Coulter and Jeffrey Epstein do not appear to have had any personal relationship. The emails show Coulter writing about Epstein in a third-person, adversarial manner as part of what appears to be a political commentary piece titled "Media Magic: How a Democrat Pedophile Became a 'Trump Scandal.'" The tone is entirely journalistic/political commentary, with Coulter criticizing Epstein and characterizing him as a "pedophile and major Democratic donor."

discussion_ids:
  ["IMAGES-010-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_029903.txt_22719", "IMAGES-010-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_029905.txt_19481", "IMAGES-010-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_029907.txt_22482", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_029903.txt_9785", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_029905.txt_6554", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_029907.txt_9701"]


canonical_name [F2d]: Haley Robson
relationship_description [F3]:
  Insufficient context to determine relationship.

  The email excerpts provided do not contain any direct communication between Haley Robson and Jeffrey Epstein, nor do they mention Haley Robson in any context related to Epstein. The emails appear to be commentary pieces and news links about Epstein's legal case, but do not reference or discuss Haley Robson specifically.

discussion_ids:
  ["IMAGES-009-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_026786.txt_18007", "IMAGES-010-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_029905.txt_19481", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_026786.txt_14946", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_029903.txt_9785", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_029905.txt_6554", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_029907.txt_9701"]


canonical_name [F2d]: Serge Moati
relationship_description [F3]:
  Based on the email excerpts provided, there appears to be a professional relationship involving a film project. Jack Lang is facilitating contact between Jeffrey Epstein and filmmaker Serge Moati through Philippe Castro, who serves as an English-speaking intermediary since Moati doesn't speak English. The limited context suggests a potential business or collaborative relationship related to film production, though the specific nature and details of their involvement are not clear from these brief exchanges.

discussion_ids:
  ["IMAGES-008-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_026324.txt_18111", "IMAGES-012-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_032811.txt_17280", "IMAGES-012-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_033120.txt_9599", "IMAGES-012-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_033122.txt_6601", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_026324.txt_24274", "TEXT-002-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_032811.txt_7924", "TEXT-002-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_033120.txt_18969", "TEXT-002-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_033122.txt_16538"]


canonical_name [F2d]: Tom Jacques
relationship_description [F3]:
  Insufficient context to determine relationship.

  The email excerpts show Tom Jacques being mentioned in what appears to be recipient lines of emails from Jeffrey Epstein to someone named Jack, but there is no actual communication content between Tom Jacques and Jeffrey Epstein, nor any substantive information about the nature of their relationship or interactions.

discussion_ids:
  ["IMAGES-012-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_033122.txt_6601", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_026324.txt_24274", "TEXT-002-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_033120.txt_18969", "TEXT-002-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_033122.txt_16538"]


canonical_name [F2d]: Ira Rosen
relationship_description [F3]:
  Based on these email excerpts, I cannot determine the relationship between Ira Rosen and Jeffrey Epstein. Ira Rosen is only mentioned once in passing by Michael Wolff, who describes him as "a 60 Minutes producer and a friend of Bannon's" delivering a message from Steve Bannon. There is no indication that Rosen had any direct contact or relationship with Epstein in these communications.

discussion_ids:
  ["IMAGES-011-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_030688.txt_16248", "IMAGES-011-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_030689.txt_17626", "IMAGES-011-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_030691.txt_9598", "IMAGES-011-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_030693.txt_6602", "IMAGES-011-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_030775.txt_23500", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_030688.txt_6898", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_030689.txt_7682", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_030691.txt_18968", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_030693.txt_16539", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_030696.txt_14968", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_030699.txt_11826"]


canonical_name [F2d]: Alistair Darling
relationship_description [F3]:
  Insufficient context to determine relationship.

  The email excerpts provided do not contain any direct communication between Alistair Darling and Jeffrey Epstein, nor do they reference any specific interactions, meetings, or business dealings between them. The only mention of Darling appears to be in a news headline about his warnings regarding Wall Street, which provides no information about any connection to Epstein.

discussion_ids:
  ["IMAGES-011-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_030487.txt_9435", "IMAGES-011-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_030501.txt_16603", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_030487.txt_18736", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_030501.txt_6683"]


canonical_name [F2d]: Kate Kelly
relationship_description [F3]:
  Based on the email excerpts, Kate Kelly appears to be a journalist who was seeking an interview with Jeffrey Epstein, which was declined. Epstein's relationship with Kelly seems adversarial, as evidenced by his derogatory comment calling her "a snake" in communications with Jes Staley, and his apparent relief that "they said no interview." The context suggests Kelly was likely pursuing Epstein for journalistic purposes, but he viewed her as hostile and was actively avoiding media contact with her.

discussion_ids:
  ["IMAGES-007-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_023612.txt_8902", "IMAGES-008-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_026450.txt_14780", "IMAGES-011-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_030501.txt_16603", "IMAGES-011-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_030652.txt_9692", "IMAGES-011-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_030655.txt_11430", "IMAGES-011-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_030706.txt_15149", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_026450.txt_21169", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_030501.txt_6683", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_030652.txt_18871", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_030655.txt_15112"]


canonical_name [F2d]: Daniel Sabba
relationship_description [F3]:
  Based on the available email excerpts, Daniel Sabba appears to have had an informal communication relationship with Jeffrey Epstein, sharing political news and analysis via email. The emails show Sabba sending Epstein links to political articles (specifically about Trump's media dominance in 2015) with brief commentary like "thought provoking stats." The tone appears casual and suggests they may have shared interests in political developments, though the limited content doesn't reveal the depth or full nature of their relationship.

discussion_ids:
  ["IMAGES-011-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_030861.txt_9561", "IMAGES-011-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_030863.txt_6695", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_030856.txt_10189", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_030861.txt_18889", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_030863.txt_16574"]


canonical_name [F2d]: Neal Kassell
relationship_description [F3]:
  Based on these email excerpts, Neal Kassell and Jeffrey Epstein appear to have had a professional/social relationship that was facilitated by mutual acquaintance Melanie Walker. The emails show Walker introducing them to each other, suggesting they would enjoy spending time together during Kassell's visit to NYC, and subsequent brief exchanges about scheduling meetings through Epstein's assistant Leslie. The tone suggests a cordial, business-oriented relationship centered around their mutual connection to Walker.

discussion_ids:
  ["IMAGES-012-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_032803.txt_14094", "IMAGES-012-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_032804.txt_16579", "IMAGES-012-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_033112.txt_17947", "TEXT-002-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_032803.txt_11284", "TEXT-002-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_032804.txt_6701", "TEXT-002-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_033112.txt_8536"]


canonical_name [F2d]: Guy Amico
relationship_description [F3]:
  Insufficient context to determine relationship.

  The email excerpts provided contain minimal substantive content, with most appearing to be empty message headers. The only content visible is a brief exchange between Larry (Visoski) and someone regarding aircraft tail design styling with an "E" and flag rendering for a vertical stabilizer, but this doesn't establish any clear relationship between Guy Amico and Jeffrey Epstein.

discussion_ids:
  ["IMAGES-012-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_033491.txt_6743", "IMAGES-012-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_033495.txt_12664", "IMAGES-012-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_033496.txt_11137", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_026548.txt_12122", "TEXT-002-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_033491.txt_16842", "TEXT-002-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_033495.txt_15340"]


canonical_name [F2d]: Andrew McCabe
relationship_description [F3]:
  Insufficient context to determine relationship.

  The email excerpts discuss Andrew McCabe in the context of FBI investigations and political matters, but they do not establish any direct relationship between McCabe and Jeffrey Epstein. McCabe is mentioned as part of discussions about FBI personnel and investigations, while the reference to Epstein appears only in a separate Ann Coulter article excerpt about media coverage.

discussion_ids:
  ["IMAGES-008-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_026287.txt_18236", "IMAGES-008-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_026290.txt_16598", "IMAGES-008-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_026469.txt_16424", "IMAGES-010-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_029903.txt_22719", "IMAGES-011-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_030703.txt_16810", "IMAGES-011-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_030706.txt_15149", "IMAGES-011-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_031560.txt_9745", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_026287.txt_24816", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_026290.txt_23191", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_030703.txt_6857", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_030706.txt_11662", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_031560.txt_13465"]


canonical_name [F2d]: James Baker
relationship_description [F3]:
  Insufficient context to determine relationship.

  The email excerpts provided do not contain any direct communication between James Baker and Jeffrey Epstein, nor do they reference any interactions between them. The emails appear to be between other individuals (LHS/LH and jeffrey E.) discussing political matters, and include an unrelated Ann Coulter piece about Epstein that doesn't mention Baker.

discussion_ids:
  ["IMAGES-008-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_026469.txt_16424", "IMAGES-010-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_029903.txt_22719", "IMAGES-011-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_030703.txt_16810", "IMAGES-011-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_030706.txt_15149", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_030703.txt_6857", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_030706.txt_11662"]


canonical_name [F2d]: James Rybicki
relationship_description [F3]:
  Insufficient context to determine relationship.

  The email excerpts provided do not contain any correspondence between James Rybicki and Jeffrey Epstein, nor do they mention James Rybicki at all. The emails appear to be between other individuals (LHS, LH, jeffrey E., Ann Coulter) discussing various political matters and include one excerpt about Epstein from what appears to be a media piece, but there is no information about any relationship between Rybicki and Epstein.

discussion_ids:
  ["IMAGES-008-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_026469.txt_16424", "IMAGES-010-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_029903.txt_22719", "IMAGES-011-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_030703.txt_16810", "IMAGES-011-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_030706.txt_15149", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_030703.txt_6857", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_030706.txt_11662"]


canonical_name [F2d]: Andrea Mitchell
relationship_description [F3]:
  Insufficient context to determine relationship.

  The only mention of Andrea Mitchell appears in an email from Kathy Ruemmler to Jeffrey Epstein, where Ruemmler mentions meeting with Mitchell to "discuss Trump/DOJ." There is no direct communication between Epstein and Mitchell in these excerpts, nor any indication of the nature of their relationship, if any existed.

discussion_ids:
  ["IMAGES-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_011905.txt_20183", "IMAGES-007-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_023198.txt_12280", "IMAGES-007-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_023201.txt_6864", "IMAGES-007-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_023202.txt_8479", "IMAGES-007-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_023205.txt_12650", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_011904.txt_11678", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_023198.txt_14939", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_023201.txt_17588", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_023202.txt_19202", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_023205.txt_14608", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_026632.txt_13297"]


canonical_name [F2d]: Mohamed Waheed Hassan
relationship_description [F3]:
  Based on these email excerpts, Mohamed Waheed Hassan appears to have had an advisory relationship with Jeffrey Epstein, where Hassan sought Epstein's counsel on high-level political and financial matters. The emails indicate Hassan was consulting Epstein about a $4 billion financial arrangement involving the Maldives' Central Bank and government, as well as campaign-related activities. The tone suggests Hassan was deferential to Epstein's advice, referring to him as his "savior" and indicating he would follow Epstein's guidance exactly.

discussion_ids:
  ["IMAGES-010-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_029530.txt_25599", "IMAGES-010-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_029534.txt_19609", "IMAGES-010-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_029535.txt_20734", "IMAGES-010-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_029622.txt_15184", "IMAGES-010-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_029680.txt_20231", "IMAGES-010-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_029681.txt_20142", "IMAGES-010-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_029684.txt_24879", "IMAGES-010-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_029685.txt_25090", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_026632.txt_13297", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_029530.txt_12641", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_029534.txt_6871", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_029684.txt_11981"]


canonical_name [F2d]: Eric H. Holder Jr.
relationship_description [F3]:
  Insufficient context to determine relationship.

  The email excerpts provided mention Eric H. Holder Jr. only in the context of his role as U.S. Attorney General and his succession by Loretta Lynch, with one reference to his friendship with attorney Reid Weingarten. There is no direct mention of Jeffrey Epstein or any communication between Holder and Epstein in these excerpts.

discussion_ids:
  ["IMAGES-009-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_026605.txt_12443", "IMAGES-009-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_026607.txt_10260", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_026444.txt_21174", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_026607.txt_6872"]


canonical_name [F2d]: Nancy Cain
relationship_description [F3]:
  Insufficient context to determine relationship.

  The email excerpts mention Jeffrey Epstein only in passing - primarily in a forwarded news article about Alan Dershowitz representing Epstein, and in what appears to be an email address (jeevacation@gmail.com) that receives political polling information. There is no direct communication between Nancy Cain and Jeffrey Epstein, nor any clear indication of the nature of any relationship between them in these excerpts.

discussion_ids:
  ["IMAGES-007-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_023280.txt_19617", "IMAGES-008-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_025329.txt_22756", "IMAGES-011-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_032457.txt_6902", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_025329.txt_16453", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_030266.txt_7925", "TEXT-002-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_033311.txt_9068"]


canonical_name [F2d]: Gernot Kramper
relationship_description [F3]:
  Insufficient context to determine relationship.

  The provided email excerpts do not mention Gernot Kramper at all. The emails shown are primarily between Steve Bannon and Jeffrey Epstein, with one message from Thomas D. Williams about a German media article. Without any correspondence or references involving Gernot Kramper, it's impossible to determine what relationship, if any, existed between Kramper and Epstein based on these materials.

discussion_ids:
  ["TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_025517.txt_15606", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_025520.txt_6992", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_025524.txt_12398", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_025528.txt_13937", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_025533.txt_10813"]


canonical_name [F2d]: Bennet J. Moskowitz
relationship_description [F3]:
  Insufficient context to determine relationship.

  The email excerpts show Bennet J. Moskowitz communicating with Darren Indyke (who appears to be connected to Jeffrey Epstein based on one email address), but the actual content of Moskowitz's emails is redacted due to privilege. Without the substantive content of these communications, it's impossible to determine the nature, context, or tone of any relationship between Moskowitz and Epstein.

discussion_ids:
  ["IMAGES-011-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_031203.txt_8142", "IMAGES-011-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_031206.txt_9726", "IMAGES-011-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_031230.txt_17765", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_031203.txt_18352", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_031206.txt_13441", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_031227.txt_7029", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_031230.txt_8617"]


canonical_name [F2d]: John McFarlane
relationship_description [F3]:
  Insufficient context to determine relationship.

  The provided email excerpts do not mention Jeffrey Epstein at all, nor do they provide clear context about the nature of any relationship between John McFarlane and Epstein. The emails appear to be communications involving John McFarlane (seemingly associated with Barclays) and someone named Staley, but without explicit mention of Epstein or clear contextual information about the subject matter being discussed, no meaningful assessment of McFarlane's relationship with Epstein can be made from these excerpts alone.

discussion_ids:
  ["IMAGES-010-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_030353.txt_9038", "IMAGES-010-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_030354.txt_11977", "IMAGES-010-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_030355.txt_12334", "IMAGES-010-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_030360.txt_18721", "IMAGES-010-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_030361.txt_18391", "IMAGES-010-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_030362.txt_16757", "IMAGES-010-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_030391.txt_8900", "IMAGES-010-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_030392.txt_7255", "IMAGES-010-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_030393.txt_7334"]


canonical_name [F2d]: Natalia Veselnitskaya
relationship_description [F3]:
  Insufficient context to determine relationship.

  The email excerpts only show third parties (Nicholas Ribis and Edward Epstein) forwarding news articles and political analysis to Jeffrey Epstein that mention Natalia Veselnitskaya in the context of her meeting with Donald Trump Jr. There is no direct communication between Veselnitskaya and Epstein, nor any indication of a personal or professional relationship between them.

discussion_ids:
  ["IMAGES-008-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_025548.txt_15405", "IMAGES-011-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_031742.txt_17543", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_025548.txt_22037", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_031742.txt_7352"]


canonical_name [F2d]: Tim Zagat
relationship_description [F3]:
  Based on these email excerpts, Tim Zagat and Jeffrey Epstein appear to have had a social relationship involving regular dinner invitations and casual exchanges. The communications show Zagat actively reaching out to arrange dinners both in New York City and at his country residence, sharing books, and wanting to discuss personal anecdotes (like his dream about Trump). The tone suggests a friendly, ongoing social connection where Zagat was the one initiating contact and extending hospitality to Epstein.

discussion_ids:
  ["IMAGES-011-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_032218.txt_2985", "IMAGES-012-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_032800.txt_15706", "IMAGES-012-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_033110.txt_17608", "TEXT-002-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_032218.txt_8574", "TEXT-002-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_032800.txt_12802", "TEXT-002-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_033110.txt_7634"]


canonical_name [F2d]: Anastasia Kuznetsova
relationship_description [F3]:
  Insufficient context to determine relationship.

  The email excerpts only show Daniel Sicd/Siad mentioning Anastasia Kuznetsova's name to Jeffrey Epstein, with Epstein responding about being in Paris. There is no direct communication between Epstein and Kuznetsova, nor sufficient detail to establish the nature, purpose, or context of any potential relationship between them.

discussion_ids:
  ["IMAGES-010-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_030152.txt_7650", "IMAGES-010-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_030154.txt_10947", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_030152.txt_20417", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_030154.txt_23618"]


canonical_name [F2d]: Richard Frank
relationship_description [F3]:
  Insufficient context to determine relationship.

  The email excerpts mention Richard Frank only in the context of a Harvard Medical School news item about a health care opinion piece he co-authored. There is no direct communication between Richard Frank and Jeffrey Epstein, nor any indication of interaction between them in these excerpts.

discussion_ids:
  ["IMAGES-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_012038.txt_25349", "IMAGES-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_012040.txt_9244", "IMAGES-010-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_029403.txt_7651", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_012037.txt_17742", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_029402.txt_19929"]


canonical_name [F2d]: Anas Alrasheed
relationship_description [F3]:
  Insufficient context to determine relationship.

  The email excerpts are too brief and fragmented to establish the nature of the relationship between Anas Alrasheed and Jeffrey Epstein. While there are references to a watch investment and some personal exchanges, the incomplete messages and lack of clear context make it impossible to determine whether this was a business, social, or other type of relationship.

discussion_ids:
  ["IMAGES-012-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_032836.txt_7675", "IMAGES-012-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_033022.txt_2358", "IMAGES-012-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_033039.txt_24913", "IMAGES-012-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_033041.txt_8804", "TEXT-002-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_032836.txt_17624", "TEXT-002-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_033022.txt_24404", "TEXT-002-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_033033.txt_19623", "TEXT-002-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_033039.txt_1872", "TEXT-002-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_033041.txt_17990"]


canonical_name [F2d]: Harry Fisch
relationship_description [F3]:
  Insufficient context to determine relationship.

  The emails show discussions about healthcare policy, contraception access, and political topics, but there is no clear indication that the "jeffrey E." in these communications is Jeffrey Epstein. The email address (jeevacation@gmail.com) and content focused on progressive political issues and healthcare advocacy do not align with known information about Jeffrey Epstein's interests or communications.

discussion_ids:
  ["IMAGES-005-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_019218.txt_12845", "IMAGES-011-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_031639.txt_7694", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_019218.txt_9301", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_031639.txt_17647"]


canonical_name [F2d]: Roger Schank
relationship_description [F3]:
  Based on these email excerpts, Epstein and Schank appear to have had a professional relationship focused on educational technology and business matters. The emails discuss Bill Gates' interest in online education and frustrations with finding quality courses, as well as business meetings ("they are sending their rep here on the second week of dec"). The tone suggests they were collaborating or consulting on educational initiatives, with Epstein sharing insider information about Gates' activities in the online education space.

discussion_ids:
  ["IMAGES-011-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_030483.txt_10056", "IMAGES-011-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_030484.txt_7749", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_030483.txt_13594", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_030484.txt_17126"]


canonical_name [F2d]: Mohammad Bin Salman
relationship_description [F3]:
  Insufficient context to determine relationship.

  The email excerpts show people forwarding news articles and social media posts about Mohammad Bin Salman to Jeffrey Epstein, and one person requesting to meet Epstein while in New York, but there's no clear evidence of direct communication between MBS and Epstein or indication of the specific nature of any relationship they may have had.

discussion_ids:
  ["IMAGES-011-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_030804.txt_6377", "IMAGES-012-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_032643.txt_24713", "TEXT-002-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_032391.txt_7769", "TEXT-002-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_032582.txt_7002", "TEXT-002-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_032643.txt_1667"]


canonical_name [F2d]: Elisabeth Feliho
relationship_description [F3]:
  Insufficient context to determine relationship.

  The email excerpts provided do not contain any direct communication between Elisabeth Feliho and Jeffrey Epstein, nor do they mention Jeffrey Epstein at all. The emails appear to be from Vinoda Basnayake regarding political advocacy work related to African democracy issues, with only one brief mention of Elisabeth Feliho as a recipient.

discussion_ids:
  ["IMAGES-009-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_026836.txt_12478", "IMAGES-009-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_026838.txt_14960", "IMAGES-010-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_028775.txt_21397", "IMAGES-010-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_028776.txt_19797", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_026835.txt_7855"]


canonical_name [F2d]: Barry Josephson
relationship_description [F3]:
  Based on the email excerpts provided, Barry Josephson and Jeffrey Epstein appear to have had a casual social or acquaintance-level relationship, with Josephson sharing political news articles about Trump and Clinton polling data. The tone seems informal and friendly, with Josephson signing off as "Barry J" and sharing commentary like "What a difference a week makes!" The limited context suggests they may have shared political interests or discussions, but the excerpts don't provide enough detail to determine the depth or specific nature of their relationship beyond these casual exchanges.

discussion_ids:
  ["IMAGES-012-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_033299.txt_17349", "IMAGES-012-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_033301.txt_13227", "TEXT-002-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_033299.txt_7937", "TEXT-002-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_033301.txt_10375"]


canonical_name [F2d]: Judge Johnson
relationship_description [F3]:
  Insufficient context to determine relationship.

  The email excerpts do not contain any direct communications between Judge Johnson and Jeffrey Epstein, nor do they provide clear context about the nature of their relationship. The first email appears to reference a judge's court duty in what may be a legal proceeding, but the connection to Epstein is unclear from these fragments.

discussion_ids:
  ["IMAGES-002-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_012614.txt_7997", "IMAGES-012-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_033307.txt_16493", "IMAGES-012-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_033311.txt_18995", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_031714.txt_20272", "TEXT-002-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_033311.txt_9068"]


canonical_name [F2d]: Edyta Wynberg
relationship_description [F3]:
  Insufficient context to determine relationship.

  The provided email excerpts show communications between Edyta Wynberg and someone named "behnbom" (Barbro) regarding Swedish banking details, but contain no mention of Jeffrey Epstein or any interaction with him.

discussion_ids:
  ["IMAGES-009-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_026745.txt_18085", "IMAGES-011-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_031215.txt_8031", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_026745.txt_15079", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_031215.txt_17160"]


canonical_name [F2d]: Jeremy Rubin
relationship_description [F3]:
  Based on the email excerpts, Jeremy Rubin and Jeffrey Epstein appear to have had a professional relationship centered around cryptocurrency and technology interests. The emails show Rubin sharing updates about Bitcoin-related political developments, seeking Jeffrey's perspective on cryptocurrency matters, and discussing his research presentations at Stanford. The tone is casual but professional, suggesting they had established communication around shared interests in Bitcoin and tech industry developments.

discussion_ids:
  ["IMAGES-010-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_029087.txt_19546", "IMAGES-010-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_029090.txt_21194", "IMAGES-010-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_029092.txt_20824", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_029087.txt_6582", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_029090.txt_8153", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_029092.txt_8032"]


canonical_name [F2d]: Hoss Carwright
relationship_description [F3]:
  Insufficient context to determine relationship.

  The email excerpts only show Hoss Carwright being mentioned by a third party (Tom Pritzker) in correspondence with Jeffrey Epstein, where Carwright is listed among high-level government and military officials as a member of some unnamed organization or group. There is no direct communication between Carwright and Epstein shown, nor any specific context about their interaction or relationship type.

discussion_ids:
  ["IMAGES-010-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_029910.txt_20887", "IMAGES-010-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_029912.txt_21130", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_029910.txt_8068", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_029912.txt_8119"]


canonical_name [F2d]: Nick Burns
relationship_description [F3]:
  Insufficient context to determine relationship.

  The emails are between Tom Pritzker and Jeffrey Epstein, with Nick Burns only mentioned as someone who "runs" an unnamed organization or group alongside other high-profile national security and foreign policy figures. There is no direct communication between Nick Burns and Epstein, nor any indication of the nature of any relationship they may have had.

discussion_ids:
  ["IMAGES-010-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_029910.txt_20887", "IMAGES-010-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_029912.txt_21130", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_029910.txt_8068", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_029912.txt_8119"]


canonical_name [F2d]: Mitchell Bard
relationship_description [F3]:
  Insufficient context to determine relationship.

  The email excerpts show Mitchell Bard sending content about Middle Eastern political topics (UNRWA funding and British-Arab historical correspondence) to an email address (jeevacation@gmail.com), but there is no indication this email address belongs to Jeffrey Epstein, nor is there any content that would indicate the nature of any relationship between Bard and Epstein.

discussion_ids:
  ["IMAGES-011-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_032012.txt_21006", "IMAGES-012-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_033517.txt_18820", "IMAGES-012-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_033528.txt_17228", "TEXT-002-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_032012.txt_15501", "TEXT-002-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_032023.txt_10422", "TEXT-002-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_033517.txt_9644", "TEXT-002-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_033528.txt_8071"]


canonical_name [F2d]: Kevin Maxwell
relationship_description [F3]:
  Insufficient context to determine relationship.

  The email excerpts primarily consist of news sharing and media-related discussions involving Ross Gow and Ghislaine Maxwell, with references to Jeffrey Epstein in news articles rather than direct communications between Kevin Maxwell and Epstein. The emails don't provide clear evidence of the nature, context, or tone of any direct relationship between Kevin Maxwell and Jeffrey Epstein.

discussion_ids:
  ["IMAGES-010-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_030222.txt_11337", "IMAGES-010-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_030226.txt_8170", "IMAGES-010-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_030229.txt_17834", "IMAGES-010-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_030232.txt_8132", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_030222.txt_24033"]


canonical_name [F2d]: Allen West
relationship_description [F3]:
  Insufficient context to determine relationship.

  The provided email excerpts do not mention Jeffrey Epstein at all. The emails are entirely focused on the Iran nuclear deal and requests to watch a Dennis Prager video, with correspondence between Terry Kafka, Mike Cohen, and Allen West about political advocacy efforts.

discussion_ids:
  ["IMAGES-009-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_026620.txt_13494", "IMAGES-010-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_028482.txt_8172", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_026620.txt_16448", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_028482.txt_21008"]


canonical_name [F2d]: Bennett Schmidt
relationship_description [F3]:
  Insufficient context to determine relationship.

  The provided email excerpts do not mention Bennett Schmidt or Jeffrey Epstein at all. The emails are between Terry Kafka, Allen West, and Mike Cohen discussing the Iran nuclear deal and sharing a Dennis Prager video.

discussion_ids:
  ["IMAGES-009-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_026620.txt_13494", "IMAGES-010-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_028482.txt_8172", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_026620.txt_16448", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_028482.txt_21008"]


canonical_name [F2d]: Dennis Prager
relationship_description [F3]:
  Insufficient context to determine relationship.

  The email excerpts mention Dennis Prager only in the context of people sharing his video content about the Iran deal. There is no indication of any direct communication between Dennis Prager and Jeffrey Epstein, nor any mention of Epstein in these particular excerpts.

discussion_ids:
  ["IMAGES-009-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_026620.txt_13494", "IMAGES-010-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_028482.txt_8172", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_026620.txt_16448", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_028482.txt_21008"]


canonical_name [F2d]: Gary Gross
relationship_description [F3]:
  Insufficient context to determine relationship.

  The provided email excerpts do not mention Gary Gross or Jeffrey Epstein. The emails are communications between Terry Kafka, Allen West, and Mike Cohen regarding the Iran nuclear deal and Dennis Prager videos, with no reference to either Gary Gross or Jeffrey Epstein.

discussion_ids:
[cell repeats an earlier one in this file: 183 characters]


canonical_name [F2d]: Henry Hortenstine
relationship_description [F3]:
  Insufficient context to determine relationship.

  The provided email excerpts do not mention Henry Hortenstine or Jeffrey Epstein. The emails are from Terry Kafka and Mike Cohen discussing the Iran deal and asking recipients to watch a Dennis Prager video and contact congressmen.

discussion_ids:
[cell repeats an earlier one in this file: 183 characters]


canonical_name [F2d]: James Ramsey
relationship_description [F3]:
  Insufficient context to determine relationship.

  The provided email excerpts do not contain any mention of James Ramsey or Jeffrey Epstein. The emails appear to be political communications between Terry Kafka, Mike Cohen, and Allen West regarding the Iran deal, with no reference to either James Ramsey or Jeffrey Epstein.

discussion_ids:
[cell repeats an earlier one in this file: 183 characters]


canonical_name [F2d]: John Zouzelka
relationship_description [F3]:
  Insufficient context to determine relationship.

  The provided email excerpts do not mention John Zouzelka or Jeffrey Epstein at all. The emails are from Terry Kafka and Mike Cohen discussing the Iran deal and asking recipients to watch a Dennis Prager video and contact congressmen.

discussion_ids:
[cell repeats an earlier one in this file: 183 characters]


canonical_name [F2d]: Nate White
relationship_description [F3]:
  Insufficient context to determine relationship.

  The provided email excerpts do not mention Nate White or Jeffrey Epstein at all. The emails are focused on discussions about the Iran deal between individuals named Terry Kafka, Allen West, and Mike Cohen.

discussion_ids:
[cell repeats an earlier one in this file: 183 characters]


canonical_name [F2d]: Neil Anderson
relationship_description [F3]:
  Insufficient context to determine relationship.

  The provided email excerpts do not mention Neil Anderson or Jeffrey Epstein at all. The emails are correspondence between Terry Kafka, Allen West, and Mike Cohen regarding the Iran nuclear deal and a Dennis Prager video.

discussion_ids:
[cell repeats an earlier one in this file: 183 characters]


canonical_name [F2d]: Rita Hortenstine
relationship_description [F3]:
  Insufficient context to determine relationship.

  The provided email excerpts do not mention Rita Hortenstine or Jeffrey Epstein, nor do they contain any information about interactions between these two individuals. The emails appear to be political communications about the Iran deal between other parties entirely.

discussion_ids:
[cell repeats an earlier one in this file: 183 characters]


canonical_name [F2d]: Uri Fouzailov
relationship_description [F3]:
  Insufficient context to determine relationship.

  The provided email excerpts do not mention Uri Fouzailov or Jeffrey Epstein at all. The emails are entirely focused on discussions about the Iran deal between other individuals (Terry Kafka, Allen West, and Mike Cohen).

discussion_ids:
[cell repeats an earlier one in this file: 183 characters]


canonical_name [F2d]: Val Sherman
relationship_description [F3]:
  Insufficient context to determine relationship.

  The provided email excerpts do not mention Val Sherman or Jeffrey Epstein at all. The emails are communications between Terry Kafka, Allen West, and Mike Cohen regarding sharing videos about the Iran deal.

discussion_ids:
[cell repeats an earlier one in this file: 183 characters]


canonical_name [F2d]: Scott Stambaugh
relationship_description [F3]:
  Insufficient context to determine relationship.

  The provided email excerpts do not mention Scott Stambaugh or contain any substantive content that would indicate a relationship between Scott Stambaugh and Jeffrey Epstein. The emails appear to be brief communications involving Larry Visoski and others regarding aircraft design details, but lack the necessary context to describe any relationship involving Scott Stambaugh.

discussion_ids:
  ["IMAGES-009-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_026548.txt_8222", "IMAGES-012-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_033495.txt_12664", "IMAGES-012-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_033496.txt_11137", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_026548.txt_12122", "TEXT-002-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_033491.txt_16842", "TEXT-002-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_033495.txt_15340"]


canonical_name [F2d]: Bertha Henry
relationship_description [F3]:
  Insufficient context to determine relationship.

  The email excerpts provided do not contain any information about Bertha Henry's relationship with Jeffrey Epstein. The emails appear to be about a separate FBI investigation involving Broward County officials, and while Bertha Henry is mentioned as a County Administrator, there is no reference to Jeffrey Epstein in any of the provided content.

discussion_ids:
  ["IMAGES-011-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_030934.txt_15331", "IMAGES-011-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_030940.txt_20215", "IMAGES-011-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_030945.txt_25082", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_030927.txt_8324"]


canonical_name [F2d]: Bev Gallagher
relationship_description [F3]:
  Insufficient context to determine relationship.

  The email excerpts mention Bev Gallagher only in the context of a federal investigation involving her arrest as a School Board member, alongside other local officials. There is no mention of Jeffrey Epstein in any of the provided email content.

discussion_ids:
  ["IMAGES-011-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_030934.txt_15331", "IMAGES-011-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_030940.txt_20215", "IMAGES-011-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_030945.txt_25082", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_030927.txt_8324"]


canonical_name [F2d]: Grant J. Smith
relationship_description [F3]:
  Insufficient context to determine relationship.

  The provided email excerpts do not mention Jeffrey Epstein at all. The emails from Grant J. Smith appear to be sharing an article about FBI investigations involving Broward County officials, but contain no reference to or discussion of Jeffrey Epstein.

discussion_ids:
  ["IMAGES-011-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_030927.txt_18470", "IMAGES-011-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_030934.txt_15331", "IMAGES-011-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_030940.txt_20215", "IMAGES-011-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_030945.txt_25082", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_030927.txt_8324"]


canonical_name [F2d]: Joe Friday
relationship_description [F3]:
  Insufficient context to determine relationship.

  The provided email excerpts do not mention Joe Friday or Jeffrey Epstein. The emails appear to be from Grant J. Smith discussing FBI investigations related to Broward County officials and warning about FBI interview procedures ("The 302"), but contain no information about either Joe Friday or Jeffrey Epstein or any relationship between them.

discussion_ids:
  ["IMAGES-011-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_030934.txt_15331", "IMAGES-011-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_030940.txt_20215", "IMAGES-011-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_030945.txt_25082", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_030927.txt_8324"]


canonical_name [F2d]: Josephus Eggleston
relationship_description [F3]:
  Insufficient context to determine relationship.

  The email excerpts mention Josephus Eggleston only in the context of being a Broward County Commissioner who was arrested as part of a federal investigation, but there is no mention of Jeffrey Epstein anywhere in the provided text. The emails appear to be discussing local Broward County corruption cases and FBI interview procedures, which seems unrelated to Epstein.

discussion_ids:
[cell repeats an earlier one in this file: 185 characters]


canonical_name [F2d]: Rajeev Misra
relationship_description [F3]:
  Insufficient context to determine relationship.

  The email excerpts provided do not mention Rajeev Misra or show any direct communication between him and Jeffrey Epstein. The emails appear to be between Jeffrey Epstein (using the "J" initial and jeevacation@gmail.com address) and someone named Weingarten, who appears to be an attorney given the legal privilege references and discussion of representation.

discussion_ids:
  ["IMAGES-010-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_028578.txt_5481", "IMAGES-010-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_028590.txt_4009", "IMAGES-010-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_028601.txt_21202", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_028589.txt_9064", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_028601.txt_8404"]


canonical_name [F2d]: Damian Woetzel
relationship_description [F3]:
  Insufficient context to determine relationship.

  The email excerpts provided do not mention Damian Woetzel at all. The emails are exchanges between Jeffrey Epstein and Lisa New discussing politicians, interviews, and Woody Allen footage, but contain no references to or involvement from Damian Woetzel that would indicate any type of relationship between him and Epstein.

discussion_ids:
  ["IMAGES-010-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_029251.txt_21264", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_023198.txt_14939", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_023202.txt_19202", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_023205.txt_14608", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_028955.txt_12521", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_029251.txt_8476"]


canonical_name [F2d]: Diane Paulus
relationship_description [F3]:
  Insufficient context to determine relationship.

  The email excerpts provided are between Jeffrey Epstein and Lisa New, discussing politicians, filming arrangements with Woody Allen, and what appears to be some kind of media project. There is no mention of Diane Paulus in any of these emails, so no relationship between Diane Paulus and Jeffrey Epstein can be determined from this correspondence.

discussion_ids:
  ["IMAGES-010-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_029251.txt_21264", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_023198.txt_14939", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_023202.txt_19202", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_023205.txt_14608", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_028955.txt_12521", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_029251.txt_8476"]


canonical_name [F2d]: Eve Ensler
relationship_description [F3]:
  Insufficient context to determine relationship.

  The email excerpts provided are between Jeffrey Epstein and someone named "Lisa New," not Eve Ensler. Without any emails actually involving Eve Ensler, there is no information available to describe her relationship with Jeffrey Epstein based on these communications.

discussion_ids:
  ["IMAGES-010-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_029251.txt_21264", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_023198.txt_14939", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_023202.txt_19202", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_023205.txt_14608", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_028955.txt_12521", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_029251.txt_8476"]


canonical_name [F2d]: John Lithgow
relationship_description [F3]:
  Insufficient context to determine relationship.

  The provided email excerpts do not mention John Lithgow at all. The emails are between Jeffrey Epstein and Lisa New, discussing filming/taping sessions with various politicians and celebrities including Woody Allen, but John Lithgow is not referenced in any of the correspondence shown.

discussion_ids:
[cell repeats an earlier one in this file: 271 characters]


canonical_name [F2d]: Condaleeza Rice
relationship_description [F3]:
  Insufficient context to determine relationship.

  The emails show Jeffrey Epstein communicating with Lisa New about a media project involving interviews with various politicians and public figures. Condoleezza Rice is only mentioned in a list of potential interview subjects who had given tentative approval ("yeses from politicians not yet scheduled"), with no direct communication, meetings, or specific interactions described between her and Epstein.

discussion_ids:
  ["IMAGES-007-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_023198.txt_12280", "IMAGES-007-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_023202.txt_8479", "IMAGES-007-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_023205.txt_12650", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_023198.txt_14939", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_023202.txt_19202", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_023205.txt_14608"]


canonical_name [F2d]: David Coleman
relationship_description [F3]:
  Insufficient context to determine relationship.

  The email excerpts do not mention David Coleman at all. The emails are between Jeffrey E. (using jeevacation@gmail.com) and Lisa New, discussing footage of Woody Allen and a list of politicians/public figures that Lisa has interviewed or plans to interview. Without any mention of David Coleman in these particular excerpts, it's impossible to determine what relationship he may have had with Jeffrey Epstein.

discussion_ids:
  ["IMAGES-007-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_023198.txt_12280", "IMAGES-007-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_023202.txt_8479", "IMAGES-007-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_023205.txt_12650", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_023198.txt_14939", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_023202.txt_19202", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_023205.txt_14608"]


canonical_name [F2d]: Frank Gehry
relationship_description [F3]:
  Insufficient context to determine relationship.

  The email excerpts mention Frank Gehry only in passing as part of a list of people that Lisa New has interviewed or filmed, but contain no direct communication between Jeffrey Epstein and Frank Gehry, nor any specific details about interactions between them.

discussion_ids:
  ["IMAGES-007-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_023198.txt_12280", "IMAGES-007-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_023202.txt_8479", "IMAGES-007-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_023205.txt_12650", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_023198.txt_14939", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_023202.txt_19202", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_023205.txt_14608"]


canonical_name [F2d]: Jerry Brown
relationship_description [F3]:
  Insufficient context to determine relationship.

  The email excerpts do not contain any direct communication between Jerry Brown and Jeffrey Epstein. Jerry Brown is only mentioned once in a list of politicians that someone named Lisa New had scheduled for interviews or tapings, in what appears to be a media or documentary project that Epstein had some involvement with or interest in.

discussion_ids:
[cell repeats an earlier one in this file: 275 characters]


canonical_name [F2d]: Joel Klein
relationship_description [F3]:
  Insufficient context to determine relationship.

  The email excerpts do not contain any direct communication between Joel Klein and Jeffrey Epstein. Joel Klein is only mentioned once in a list of politicians and officials that someone named Lisa New has interviewed or scheduled for interviews, in what appears to be correspondence between Lisa New and Jeffrey Epstein about a media project involving Woody Allen.

discussion_ids:
[cell repeats an earlier one in this file: 275 characters]


canonical_name [F2d]: Peter Gallison
relationship_description [F3]:
  Insufficient context to determine relationship.

  The email excerpts do not involve Peter Gallison at all - they are entirely correspondence between Jeffrey Epstein (using the email jeevacation@gmail.com) and Lisa New regarding what appears to be a media/filming project involving Woody Allen and various political figures. Without any emails actually involving Peter Gallison, there is no basis to describe his relationship with Jeffrey Epstein from these materials.

discussion_ids:
[cell repeats an earlier one in this file: 275 characters]


canonical_name [F2d]: Richard Dawkins
relationship_description [F3]:
  Insufficient context to determine relationship.

  The email excerpts provided do not contain any correspondence involving Richard Dawkins. All emails shown are between Jeffrey Epstein and Lisa New discussing what appears to be a television or educational project involving various politicians and public figures, with mentions of funding, filming, and Woody Allen, but there is no reference to or communication with Richard Dawkins in any of the provided content.

discussion_ids:
  ["IMAGES-007-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_023198.txt_12280", "IMAGES-007-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_023202.txt_8479", "IMAGES-007-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_023205.txt_12650", "IMAGES-008-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_025511.txt_25074", "IMAGES-008-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_025514.txt_20195", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_023198.txt_14939", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_023202.txt_19202", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_023205.txt_14608", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_025511.txt_18771", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_025514.txt_14004", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_025537.txt_8592"]


canonical_name [F2d]: Samantha Power
relationship_description [F3]:
  Insufficient context to determine relationship.

  The email excerpts only show Samantha Power's name listed among politicians that someone named Lisa New has either "taped" or received "yeses" from for what appears to be some kind of interview or filming project. There is no direct communication between Samantha Power and Jeffrey Epstein, nor any indication of the nature of any relationship between them in these materials.

discussion_ids:
[cell repeats an earlier one in this file: 275 characters]


canonical_name [F2d]: Greg Andres
relationship_description [F3]:
  Insufficient context to determine relationship.

  The email excerpts appear to involve multiple different people named "Andres" (Greg Andres and Andres Serrano) rather than a consistent correspondence between Greg Andres and Jeffrey Epstein. While there is one brief political exchange from someone signed "Andres" to Jeffrey E., and a separate reference to Greg Andres as a prosecutor, there isn't enough coherent context to determine the specific nature of any relationship between Greg Andres and Jeffrey Epstein.

discussion_ids:
  ["IMAGES-008-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_026288.txt_8556", "IMAGES-011-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_031561.txt_11369", "IMAGES-011-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_032311.txt_14122", "TEXT-002-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_032312.txt_21222"]


canonical_name [F2d]: David Malan
relationship_description [F3]:
  Insufficient context to determine relationship.

  The email excerpts provided are all from Lisa New to Jeffrey Epstein regarding funding for an HGSE (Harvard Graduate School of Education) course, but do not mention or involve David Malan in any way. Without any reference to David Malan in these communications, it's impossible to assess his relationship with Jeffrey Epstein based on this material.

discussion_ids:
  ["IMAGES-008-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_025511.txt_25074", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_025511.txt_18771", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_025514.txt_14004", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_025537.txt_8592"]


canonical_name [F2d]: David Mossberg
relationship_description [F3]:
  Insufficient context to determine relationship.

  The provided email excerpts are all from Lisa New to Jeffrey Epstein regarding educational funding proposals, but contain no mention of David Mossberg or any interactions between Mossberg and Epstein.

discussion_ids:
  ["IMAGES-008-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_025511.txt_25074", "IMAGES-008-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_025514.txt_20195", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_025511.txt_18771", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_025514.txt_14004", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_025537.txt_8592"]


canonical_name [F2d]: Walter Isaacson
relationship_description [F3]:
  Insufficient context to determine relationship.

  The provided email excerpts are all from Lisa New to Jeffrey Epstein regarding what appears to be educational funding proposals, but there is no correspondence from or reference to Walter Isaacson in any of these emails. Without any mention of Isaacson in the provided excerpts, it's impossible to assess his relationship with Epstein based on this material.

discussion_ids:
  ["IMAGES-008-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_025511.txt_25074", "IMAGES-008-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_025514.txt_20195", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_025511.txt_18771", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_025514.txt_14004", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_025537.txt_8592"]


canonical_name [F2d]: Oliver Stone
relationship_description [F3]:
  Insufficient context to determine relationship.

  The provided email excerpts are between Jeffrey Epstein and Peggy Siegal, not Oliver Stone, and contain only brief references to a trip without any substantive details about relationships or interactions.

discussion_ids:
  ["IMAGES-006-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_021235.txt_22465", "IMAGES-011-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_032005.txt_19359", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_021235.txt_8794", "TEXT-002-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_032005.txt_13923"]


canonical_name [F2d]: Ben Sasse
relationship_description [F3]:
  Based on these email excerpts, Ben Sasse appears to have had a professional governmental relationship with Jeffrey Epstein in his capacity as a U.S. Senator conducting oversight duties. The specific context mentioned shows Sasse questioning Attorney General nominee William Barr about the Jeffrey Epstein case during confirmation hearings on January 15, 2019, securing Barr's commitment to have the Department of Justice investigate the handling of the case. The interaction appears to be part of Sasse's official senatorial role in judicial oversight rather than any personal relationship with Epstein.

discussion_ids:
  ["IMAGES-011-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_031384.txt_16871", "IMAGES-011-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_031388.txt_8812", "IMAGES-011-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_031392.txt_18648", "IMAGES-011-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_031399.txt_10540", "IMAGES-011-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_031403.txt_11970", "IMAGES-011-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_031428.txt_10393"]


canonical_name [F2d]: Julie K. Brown
relationship_description [F3]:
  Based on these email excerpts, Julie K. Brown appears to have a professional adversarial relationship with Jeffrey Epstein as an investigative journalist. Brown, writing for the Miami Herald, was reporting critically on Epstein's legal case, including coverage of prosecutorial misconduct and the controversial plea deal involving Alexander Acosta. The emails show her articles being forwarded to Epstein's email address, suggesting he or his associates were monitoring her investigative reporting about his case.

discussion_ids:
  ["IMAGES-006-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_021740.txt_23758", "IMAGES-007-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_023126.txt_23468", "IMAGES-011-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_031384.txt_16871", "IMAGES-011-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_031388.txt_8812", "IMAGES-011-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_031392.txt_18648", "IMAGES-011-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_031399.txt_10540", "IMAGES-011-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_031403.txt_11970", "IMAGES-011-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_031428.txt_10393", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_021740.txt_10316"]


canonical_name [F2d]: William Barr
relationship_description [F3]:
  Based on these email excerpts, the relationship between William Barr and Jeffrey Epstein appears to be professional and legal in nature, with Barr in his role as Attorney General nominee/Attorney General having oversight responsibility for the Epstein case. The emails reference Barr's January 15, 2019 commitment during his confirmation hearing to have the Department of Justice investigate the handling of the Epstein case if confirmed. The context suggests a formal law enforcement relationship rather than any personal connection between the two individuals.

discussion_ids:
  ["IMAGES-011-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_031384.txt_16871", "IMAGES-011-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_031388.txt_8812", "IMAGES-011-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_031392.txt_18648", "IMAGES-011-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_031399.txt_10540", "IMAGES-011-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_031403.txt_11970", "IMAGES-011-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_031428.txt_10393"]


canonical_name [F2d]: Joe Lockhart
relationship_description [F3]:
  Insufficient context to determine relationship.

  The email excerpts only show a third-party suggestion that Jeffrey Epstein should speak with Joe Lockhart at Glover Park Group for what appears to be public relations or crisis management assistance (given the mention of Lockhart helping Clinton and General Petraeus). There are no direct communications between Epstein and Lockhart shown, nor any indication of an existing relationship between them.

discussion_ids:
  ["IMAGES-010-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_029898.txt_21904", "IMAGES-010-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_029899.txt_21661", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_029898.txt_8930", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_029899.txt_8896"]


canonical_name [F2d]: Tazia Smith
relationship_description [F3]:
  Insufficient context to determine relationship.

  The provided email excerpts do not contain any correspondence to, from, or mentioning Tazia Smith. The emails shown are between Jeffrey Epstein and individuals named Paul Morris and Vinit Sahni, discussing what appears to be business or financial matters.

discussion_ids:
  ["IMAGES-006-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_022260.txt_22872", "IMAGES-006-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_022272.txt_19725", "IMAGES-006-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_022346.txt_9123", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_022260.txt_10879", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_022262.txt_11878", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_022346.txt_21380"]


canonical_name [F2d]: Alberto Gonzales
relationship_description [F3]:
  Insufficient context to determine relationship.

  The email excerpts provided are primarily from Kathy Ruemmler to Jeffrey Epstein, with only two brief references to Alberto Gonzales in the form of links to Senator Obama's floor statement regarding Gonzales's nomination for Attorney General. There is no direct communication between Gonzales and Epstein, nor any substantive discussion about Gonzales that would indicate the nature of any relationship between him and Epstein.

discussion_ids:
  ["IMAGES-008-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_026344.txt_22940", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_026344.txt_16258", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_030109.txt_18312", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_030113.txt_9125", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_030118.txt_13438", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_030129.txt_12383", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_030135.txt_18241"]


canonical_name [F2d]: Frank Pizzurro
relationship_description [F3]:
  Insufficient context to determine relationship.

  The email excerpts provided do not contain any direct communication between Frank Pizzurro and Jeffrey Epstein, nor do they reference any interactions, business dealings, or relationship between the two individuals. The excerpts appear to be unrelated communications involving Pizzurro in what seems to be legal/professional contexts, while the Epstein emails are separate fragments without substantive content.

discussion_ids:
  ["IMAGES-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_012040.txt_9244", "IMAGES-010-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_030098.txt_22256", "IMAGES-010-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_030105.txt_19853", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_030098.txt_9481"]


canonical_name [F2d]: Prateek Jain
relationship_description [F3]:
  Insufficient context to determine relationship.

  The provided email excerpts show Prateek Jain sending oil market analysis reports, but Jeffrey Epstein only appears as a recipient in one email from a different sender (Daniel Sabba). There is no direct communication between Prateek Jain and Jeffrey Epstein visible in these excerpts, nor any context about the nature of their potential relationship.

discussion_ids:
  ["IMAGES-011-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_030856.txt_13062", "IMAGES-011-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_030861.txt_9561", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_030856.txt_10189", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_030861.txt_18889"]


canonical_name [F2d]: Cecilia Steen
relationship_description [F3]:
  Based on these email excerpts, Cecilia Steen appears to have had a personal relationship with Jeffrey Epstein, expressing concern about legal troubles he was facing and signing off with "All my love always." The emails suggest a social or personal connection rather than a strictly professional one, with Cecilia showing emotional investment in Epstein's wellbeing. There also appears to be some connection to "SALSS" (possibly an organization or program) through communications involving Barbro Ehnbom, though the exact nature of this connection is unclear from the provided excerpts.

discussion_ids:
  ["IMAGES-011-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_032267.txt_14712", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_028752.txt_18350", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_031221.txt_10286", "TEXT-002-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_032267.txt_22148"]


canonical_name [F2d]: Carolina Herrera
relationship_description [F3]:
  Insufficient context to determine relationship.

  The email excerpts provided do not contain any direct communication between Carolina Herrera and Jeffrey Epstein, nor do they mention Carolina Herrera at all. The emails shown are primarily about a New York Observer anniversary event invitation, with communication between Epstein and his assistant Lesley Groff.

discussion_ids:
  ["IMAGES-007-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_023545.txt_14863", "IMAGES-007-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_023548.txt_11028", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_018045.txt_13157", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_023548.txt_13121"]


canonical_name [F2d]: Cynthia McFadden
relationship_description [F3]:
  Insufficient context to determine relationship.

  The email excerpts mention Cynthia McFadden only as a participant in Tina Brown's "Women in the World Summit," but there is no direct communication between McFadden and Epstein, nor any context indicating the nature of any relationship they may have had.

discussion_ids:
  ["IMAGES-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_011905.txt_20183", "IMAGES-007-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_023545.txt_14863", "IMAGES-007-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_023548.txt_11028", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_011904.txt_11678", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_023548.txt_13121"]


canonical_name [F2d]: Joseph Meyer
relationship_description [F3]:
  Insufficient context to determine relationship.

  The email excerpts provided do not contain any correspondence between Joseph Meyer and Jeffrey Epstein. The emails shown are invitations from the New York Observer being forwarded to Epstein by his assistant Lesley Groff, but there is no mention of Joseph Meyer or any direct communication involving him.

discussion_ids:
  ["IMAGES-007-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_023545.txt_14863", "IMAGES-007-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_023548.txt_11028", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_023545.txt_12785", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_023548.txt_13121"]


canonical_name [F2d]: Stephen Schwarzman
relationship_description [F3]:
  Insufficient context to determine relationship.

  The email excerpts show Stephen Schwarzman only mentioned in passing as part of a news article about private equity leaders in the Trump administration, with no direct communication or interaction between Schwarzman and Epstein evident in these materials.

discussion_ids:
  ["IMAGES-007-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_023545.txt_14863", "IMAGES-007-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_023548.txt_11028", "IMAGES-009-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_026650.txt_23658", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_023548.txt_13121", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_026650.txt_20603"]


canonical_name [F2d]: Dwight Eisenhower
relationship_description [F3]:
  Insufficient context to determine relationship.

  The email excerpts only contain forwarded news articles by Fareed Zakaria that mention Dwight Eisenhower in passing as a historical reference point for comparison with Donald Trump. There is no direct communication between Eisenhower and Epstein, nor any indication of any actual relationship between them.

discussion_ids:
  ["IMAGES-010-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_029849.txt_25061", "IMAGES-012-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_033482.txt_11090", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_029849.txt_12317", "TEXT-002-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_033482.txt_13745"]


canonical_name [F2d]: George Washington
relationship_description [F3]:
  Insufficient context to determine relationship.

  The email excerpts only contain forwarded news articles about Donald Trump's 2015 presidential campaign, where George Washington is mentioned in passing as a comparison point by journalist Fareed Zakaria. There is no direct communication between George Washington and Jeffrey Epstein, nor any indication of an actual relationship between them in these materials.

discussion_ids:
  ["IMAGES-010-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_029849.txt_25061", "IMAGES-012-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_033482.txt_11090", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_029849.txt_12317", "TEXT-002-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_033482.txt_13745"]


canonical_name [F2d]: Heather Mann
relationship_description [F3]:
  Based on these email excerpts, Heather Mann appears to have had a casual, social relationship with Jeffrey Epstein. The informal tone, use of "xx" (kisses), and her joking request about staying on "your island" suggests they were on friendly, familiar terms. The brief exchanges about political preferences (Trump or Hillary) and her lighthearted comment about needing to "hide a while" indicate personal rather than strictly professional communication.

discussion_ids:
  ["IMAGES-011-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_032268.txt_11603", "IMAGES-011-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_032269.txt_12711", "TEXT-002-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_032268.txt_6073", "TEXT-002-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_032269.txt_5305"]


canonical_name [F2d]: Rachel Brand
relationship_description [F3]:
  Insufficient context to determine relationship.

  The email excerpts provided do not contain any direct correspondence between Rachel Brand and Jeffrey Epstein, nor do they mention Rachel Brand by name. While there is a brief reference to "resignation of justice Dept number 3" (which could refer to Brand's departure from her role as Associate Attorney General), the emails primarily discuss political matters and do not establish any clear connection or relationship between Brand and Epstein.

discussion_ids:
  ["IMAGES-008-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_026469.txt_16424", "IMAGES-011-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_030703.txt_16810", "IMAGES-011-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_030706.txt_15149", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_026469.txt_22722", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_030706.txt_11662"]


canonical_name [F2d]: Al Franken
relationship_description [F3]:
  Insufficient context to determine relationship.

  The email excerpts only show Al Franken's name mentioned in passing - once in what appears to be a sarcastic list from Lawrence Krauss suggesting a "men of the world conference" of controversial figures, and several times in forwarded news articles about Sarah Silverman defending Franken. There is no direct communication between Al Franken and Jeffrey Epstein, nor any indication of the nature of any relationship they may have had.

discussion_ids:
  ["IMAGES-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_011904.txt_20168", "IMAGES-009-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_026938.txt_19642", "IMAGES-011-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_031779.txt_13142", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_011904.txt_11678", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_026938.txt_22986", "TEXT-002-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_031779.txt_20552"]


canonical_name [F2d]: Tina Brown
relationship_description [F3]:
  Based on these email excerpts, the relationship between Tina Brown and Jeffrey Epstein appears to be primarily professional/journalistic in nature. The emails indicate that Brown, in her role at Newsweek, assigned a substantial feature story about Epstein, with a PR consultant warning Epstein about the upcoming article and offering to help shape its coverage. There is no evidence of a personal relationship between Brown and Epstein in these communications.

discussion_ids:
  ["IMAGES-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_011905.txt_20183", "IMAGES-005-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_019406.txt_13777", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_011904.txt_11678", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_019406.txt_17549"]


canonical_name [F2d]: Benny Shabtai
relationship_description [F3]:
  Insufficient context to determine relationship.

  The provided email excerpts do not mention Benny Shabtai at all. The emails reference individuals named Jack, Joel, Jack Goldberger (described as Epstein's local attorney), and Brian Baker, but contain no information about Benny Shabtai or any interactions between Shabtai and Jeffrey Epstein.

discussion_ids:
  ["IMAGES-012-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_033456.txt_12555", "IMAGES-012-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_033458.txt_14875", "IMAGES-012-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_033460.txt_17373", "TEXT-002-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_033456.txt_15445", "TEXT-002-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_033458.txt_12011"]


canonical_name [F2d]: Cecile de Jongh
relationship_description [F3]:
  Insufficient context to determine relationship.

  The email excerpts are too fragmentary and incomplete to establish the nature of the relationship between Cecile de Jongh and Jeffrey Epstein. The exchanges include only brief responses like "Very good news indeed" and incomplete messages, with one sharing an NPR article about Antigua's trade dispute, but there's no clear indication of whether their interactions were professional, social, legal, or otherwise.

discussion_ids:
  ["IMAGES-011-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_031169.txt_15709", "IMAGES-011-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_031172.txt_12512", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_026580.txt_17131", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_031169.txt_12800", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_031172.txt_16008"]


canonical_name [F2d]: Steven Sinofsky
relationship_description [F3]:
  Based on the email excerpts, Steven Sinofsky and Jeffrey Epstein appear to have had a casual social or professional relationship involving informal exchanges about topics like Bitcoin investments and technology news. The emails show Sinofsky sharing articles with Epstein and Epstein thanking him "for taking the time," suggesting some level of ongoing communication or meetings. The tone appears informal and friendly, though the limited content doesn't reveal the depth or primary purpose of their relationship.

discussion_ids:
  ["IMAGES-005-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_020143.txt_23889", "IMAGES-006-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_021096.txt_14699", "IMAGES-009-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_026632.txt_16612", "IMAGES-010-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_029963.txt_17948", "IMAGES-010-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_030235.txt_12898", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_020143.txt_20228", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_021096.txt_2838", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_026632.txt_13297", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_029963.txt_4949", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_030235.txt_25677"]


canonical_name [F2d]: Kenneth E. Mapp
relationship_description [F3]:
  Insufficient context to determine relationship.

  The only mention of "Mapp" appears in what seems to be a contact list or name compilation among many other individuals including academics, politicians, and public figures. There are no direct communications, meeting references, or contextual details that would indicate the specific nature of any relationship between Kenneth E. Mapp and Jeffrey Epstein.

discussion_ids:
  ["IMAGES-008-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_026420.txt_25428", "IMAGES-009-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_026632.txt_16612", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_026420.txt_19262", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_026632.txt_13297"]


canonical_name [F2d]: Raafat Alsabbagh
relationship_description [F3]:
  Based on the limited email excerpts provided, Raafat Alsabbagh appears to have had a collaborative relationship with Jeffrey Epstein, possibly involving business or advisory activities. The emails suggest Epstein was seeking Alsabbagh's input on documents or proposals, and they were coordinating activities involving someone named Mohammed, including potential visits to Washington and MIT. The tone appears professional and suggests Alsabbagh may have been traveling ("I am happy you are returning so fast"), but there is insufficient context to determine the specific nature of their business relationship or the purpose of these collaborations.

discussion_ids:
  ["IMAGES-008-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_026383.txt_22343", "IMAGES-009-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_026632.txt_16612", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_026383.txt_16035", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_026632.txt_13297", "TEXT-002-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_032951.txt_13710"]


canonical_name [F2d]: Abdulmalik Al-Makhlafi
relationship_description [F3]:
  Insufficient context to determine relationship.

  The email excerpts are too fragmented and lack sufficient identifying information to establish a clear relationship between Abdulmalik Al-Makhlafi and Jeffrey Epstein. While there appear to be brief communications about Yemen peace talks and Dubai meetings, the incomplete nature of the emails and missing context makes it impossible to determine the nature, tone, or specific circumstances of their relationship.

discussion_ids:
  ["IMAGES-008-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_026080.txt_13554", "IMAGES-008-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_026083.txt_15115", "IMAGES-008-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_026086.txt_16792", "IMAGES-008-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_026090.txt_18709"]


canonical_name [F2d]: Ismail Ould Cheikh Ahmed
relationship_description [F3]:
  Insufficient context to determine relationship.

  The email excerpts are too fragmentary and lack sufficient detail to establish the nature of the relationship between Ismail Ould Cheikh Ahmed and Jeffrey Epstein. While the emails appear to reference Yemen peace talks and mentions of Kuwait and Dubai, the incomplete sender/recipient information and truncated content make it impossible to determine whether this was a professional, diplomatic, or other type of relationship.

discussion_ids:
  ["IMAGES-008-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_026080.txt_13554", "IMAGES-008-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_026083.txt_15115", "IMAGES-008-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_026086.txt_16792", "IMAGES-008-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_026090.txt_18709"]


canonical_name [F2d]: Benjamin Netanyahu
relationship_description [F3]:
  Insufficient context to determine relationship.

  The email excerpts do not provide evidence of a direct relationship between Benjamin Netanyahu and Jeffrey Epstein. The emails appear to be either satirical messages sent from other accounts using Netanyahu's name, political commentary about Middle East policy, or discussions about Netanyahu's political activities rather than authentic correspondence between the two individuals.

discussion_ids:
  ["IMAGES-009-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_027099.txt_13584", "IMAGES-011-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_031332.txt_25146", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_027099.txt_16167", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_031332.txt_2959", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_031705.txt_24993"]


canonical_name [F2d]: Gino Yu
relationship_description [F3]:
  Based on these email excerpts, Gino Yu appears to have had a social/networking relationship with Jeffrey Epstein, characterized by shared connections in elite social circles. The emails show Yu organizing exclusive gatherings (including a 40+ person event in Tulum), facilitating introductions between Epstein and other contacts, and sharing information about mutual acquaintances in locations like St. Moritz and NYC. The tone suggests an informal but purposeful relationship focused on high-level social networking and event coordination within affluent international circles.

discussion_ids:
  ["IMAGES-008-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_026036.txt_21846", "IMAGES-008-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_026041.txt_15386", "IMAGES-008-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_026042.txt_13781", "IMAGES-012-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_033234.txt_2204", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_026036.txt_15525", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_026041.txt_22036", "TEXT-002-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_033234.txt_24173"]


canonical_name [F2d]: Paul Schulte
relationship_description [F3]:
  Insufficient context to determine relationship.

  The email excerpts show communications between Gino Yu and Jeffrey Epstein about travel plans and meetings, with Gino offering to introduce Jeffrey to Paul Schulte (described as his "benefactor in NYC"). However, there are no direct communications between Paul Schulte and Jeffrey Epstein in these excerpts, making it impossible to determine the nature of any relationship between them.

discussion_ids:
  ["IMAGES-008-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_026037.txt_21715", "IMAGES-008-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_026041.txt_15386", "IMAGES-008-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_026042.txt_13781", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_026036.txt_15525", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_026041.txt_22036"]


canonical_name [F2d]: John Page
relationship_description [F3]:
  Insufficient context to determine relationship.

  The email excerpts provided discuss John Page's involvement in Palm Beach municipal matters, specifically regarding ARCOM (Architectural Review Commission) meetings and code enforcement cases related to Trump properties at 515 N. County Road. However, there is no mention of Jeffrey Epstein in any of these emails, making it impossible to determine any relationship between John Page and Epstein based on this content.

discussion_ids:
  ["IMAGES-004-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_016595.txt_17797", "IMAGES-004-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_016596.txt_16142", "IMAGES-004-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_016690.txt_20524", "IMAGES-004-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_016691.txt_19816", "IMAGES-004-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_016692.txt_21477", "IMAGES-004-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_016693.txt_22107", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_016595.txt_24300", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_016690.txt_13975", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_016692.txt_15086", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_016693.txt_15512"]


canonical_name [F2d]: Ray Royce
relationship_description [F3]:
  Insufficient context to determine relationship.

  The provided email excerpts do not mention Ray Royce or Jeffrey Epstein. The emails only discuss ARCOM (Architectural Review Committee) meetings regarding landscaping matters for a Trump property in Palm Beach, with correspondence between John Page and Kirk Blouin.

discussion_ids:
  ["IMAGES-004-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_016596.txt_16142", "IMAGES-004-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_016691.txt_19816", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_016595.txt_24300", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_016690.txt_13975"]


canonical_name [F2d]: Rob Walton
relationship_description [F3]:
  Insufficient context to determine relationship.

  The provided email excerpts discuss municipal code enforcement matters related to landscaping/hedging at a Trump property in Palm Beach, with Rob Walton mentioned only as someone who would be available for a July 23rd meeting. There is no mention of Jeffrey Epstein in these emails, nor any content that would indicate a relationship between Rob Walton and Jeffrey Epstein.

discussion_ids:
  ["IMAGES-004-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_016595.txt_17797", "IMAGES-004-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_016690.txt_20524", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_016595.txt_24300", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_016690.txt_13975"]


canonical_name [F2d]: Joscha Bach
relationship_description [F3]:
  Based on these email excerpts, Joscha Bach and Jeffrey Epstein appear to have had an intellectual/academic relationship involving discussions about human intelligence, cognitive development, and social organization. The emails reference in-person meetings that included academic figures like Noam Chomsky, with Epstein seemingly providing "support and encouragement" to Bach's work or ideas. The exchanges include concerning discussions about racial intelligence differences and theories about cognitive enhancement, suggesting Epstein may have been involved in or funding Bach's research interests in these areas.

discussion_ids:
  ["IMAGES-008-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_025949.txt_10959", "IMAGES-008-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_025954.txt_17312", "IMAGES-008-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_025960.txt_10203", "IMAGES-008-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_026393.txt_22825", "IMAGES-008-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_026399.txt_5088", "IMAGES-008-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_026406.txt_1975", "IMAGES-008-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_026413.txt_2965", "IMAGES-010-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_029622.txt_15184", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_025949.txt_4216", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_025954.txt_23556", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_025960.txt_3879", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_026393.txt_16127", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_026399.txt_11421", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_026406.txt_8274", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_026413.txt_9549"]


canonical_name [F2d]: Gerald Barton
relationship_description [F3]:
  Based on these email excerpts, Gerald Barton appears to have had a close personal and business relationship with Jeffrey Epstein spanning multiple years. The relationship involved both financial/business discussions (including a $166 million tax loss opportunity that Epstein discussed with Larry Summers) and personal hospitality, with Barton and his family staying at Epstein's New York apartment. The tone is notably warm and familiar, with Barton addressing Epstein as "My Extraordinarily Talented, Outrageous Friend" and expressing gratitude for Epstein's support during what appears to be Barton's financial difficulties with his company Landmark.

discussion_ids:
  ["IMAGES-009-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_026547.txt_17895", "IMAGES-011-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_032256.txt_11125", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_026547.txt_15256", "TEXT-002-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_032256.txt_3692", "TEXT-002-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_032865.txt_3110"]


canonical_name [F2d]: Andres Serrano
relationship_description [F3]:
  Based on these email excerpts, Andres Serrano and Jeffrey Epstein appear to have had a casual social relationship where they exchanged personal opinions on political matters. The emails show Serrano sharing updates about his art exhibitions (mentioning a show called "Torture" in Ireland) and offering candid political commentary about Trump and Bill Clinton during what appears to be the 2016 election period. The tone suggests a familiar, informal correspondence between acquaintances who felt comfortable discussing both professional updates and controversial political views.

discussion_ids:
  ["IMAGES-011-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_032312.txt_15694", "IMAGES-011-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_032314.txt_18922", "TEXT-002-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_032311.txt_19575", "TEXT-002-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_032312.txt_21222", "TEXT-002-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_032314.txt_24411"]


canonical_name [F2d]: Robert Gold
relationship_description [F3]:
  Based on the email excerpts, Robert Gold appears to have had a legal/professional relationship with Jeffrey Epstein, likely serving as his attorney. The emails show Epstein reaching out to Gold about a lawyer who had previously sued Trump, with Epstein noting this was someone "separate from you," suggesting Gold was his primary or current legal counsel. The informal tone ("hey, hope this finds you well") indicates they had an established working relationship with some level of familiarity.

discussion_ids:
  ["IMAGES-009-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_026849.txt_24600", "IMAGES-012-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_033007.txt_23400", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_026849.txt_21246", "TEXT-002-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_033007.txt_1358"]


canonical_name [F2d]: Valeria Chomsky
relationship_description [F3]:
  Based on these email excerpts, Valeria Chomsky appears to have a social or advisory relationship with Jeffrey Epstein, where she discusses political predictions and career aspirations. The emails suggest she confided in him about her early predictions regarding election outcomes and sought his input or support regarding a desired position as a political analyst in the White House. The tone appears informal and familiar, with references to coordinating travel plans to Arizona and mentions of her husband Noam's work schedule.

discussion_ids:
  ["IMAGES-008-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_026055.txt_15379", "IMAGES-011-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_032365.txt_22171", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_026055.txt_21995", "TEXT-002-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_032365.txt_14692"]


canonical_name [F2d]: Peter Scher
relationship_description [F3]:
  Insufficient context to determine relationship.

  The provided email excerpts only mention Peter Scher in his professional capacity as Head of Corporate Responsibility for JPMorgan Chase in relation to a post-election conference call. There is no mention of Jeffrey Epstein or any interaction between Peter Scher and Jeffrey Epstein in these emails.

discussion_ids:
  ["IMAGES-011-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_030837.txt_22384", "IMAGES-011-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_031126.txt_23004", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_030837.txt_6033", "TEXT-001-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_031126.txt_123"]


canonical_name [F2d]: Robert Lynch
relationship_description [F3]:
  Insufficient context to determine relationship.

  The emails only show that Jeffrey Epstein was pleased that both his work and Robert Lynch's work were cited together in a Nation article about Donald Trump's lack of humor, and that he was congratulating Lynch. However, there's no clear indication of the nature of their relationship, whether they knew each other directly, or any specific context about their interactions beyond this shared media mention.

discussion_ids:
  ["IMAGES-012-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_033169.txt_200", "IMAGES-012-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_033584.txt_2848", "TEXT-002-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_033169.txt_23015", "TEXT-002-HOUSE_OVERSIGHT_033584.txt_25676"]


